Career Employer

Your FREE Law School Admission Test (LSAT) Practice Test 2026 – 450+ Q&A

Prepare with realistic, LSAT-style questions — take a full practice test or drill Logical Reasoning and Reading Comprehension, the two scored question types on the current exam.

How ready are you?

To find us again, just search “Career Employer LSAT”

By
LSAT exam by the numbersStandard mode

Where the LSAT exam's points come from

LSAC's official outline weights, the exam rules and our 451 free practice questions mapped domain by domain. Use it to plan your study hours.

  • Scored sections:3 (Logical Reasoning ×2, Reading Comprehension ×1)
  • Unscored sections:1 experimental (LR or RC) + LSAT Argumentative Writing
  • Result:Scaled score 120–180 (no pass/fail)
  • Administered by:LSAC via Prometric (online live remote-proctored or at a test center)
  • Eligibility:Open to anyone applying to law school; no degree required to register
  • Retake limits:5 times per current reportable period, 7 lifetime; no retakes after a 180
Facts from LSAC's official exam outline and rules
~3 hrs
Length
$253
Cost

Where the LSAT points are

LSAC's official weight for each of the two domains.

See these numbers as a table
Weights from LSAC's LSAT exam outline. Practice questions: Career Employer's LSAT bank.
DomainOfficial weightOur practice questions
Logical Reasoning65%225
Reading Comprehension35%226

What to do: Logical Reasoning is the biggest domain at 65%. Reading Comprehension is the smallest at 35%.

Split your study time

Your hours, divided by LSAC's domain weights.

Logical Reasoning
39 hrs
Reading Comprehension
21 hrs

Our LSAT student data is on its way

We’ve logged 583 first-try answers on our LSAT questions so far. This section switches to real LSAT student results by itself once each part has enough people behind it:

What switches onNeeds
Headline numbers150 studiers
Accuracy by domain300 answers + 50 people per domain
First full exam score100 full exams
Finish rate150 people starting

Then it shows points lost by domain, you vs everyone and question difficulty.

Weights and rules from LSAC's published LSAT exam outline and certification pages. Practice-question counts from Career Employer's LSAT bank. Fees and requirements can change; check LSAC before you register.

The LSAT — officially the Law School Admission Test — is administered by the Law School Admission Council (LSAC) and is the standardized test used for admission to law schools across the U.S. and Canada.

[1]In August 2024, LSAC made the biggest change in the test’s history: it removed the Analytical Reasoning section — the famous “Logic Games” — from the scored test.

The current LSAT scores two Logical Reasoning sections and one Reading Comprehension section, plus one unscored experimental section and a separate, unscored LSAT Argumentative Writing sample.[1] These free practice questions mirror the current format so you practice the way the real exam is built.

[3] For deeper review, pair these with our free study guide, flashcards, and cheat sheet.

What Is on the LSAT?

The current LSAT has three scored sections — two Logical Reasoning and one Reading Comprehension — plus one unscored experimental section and a separate, unscored LSAT Argumentative Writing sample.[1]

Logical Reasoning now makes up two of the three scored sections — about half your score. Analytical Reasoning (“Logic Games”) was retired from the scored test in August 2024 and is no longer tested content. Our full practice test mirrors the current weighting, roughly 50 Logical Reasoning questions and 27 Reading Comprehension questions across the three scored sections.

LSAT practice test — practice questions by domain with answer explanations

Practice Questions by Section

Use Start Test for a full weighted LSAT simulation, or open the hub and pick a single section to drill your weak area. After each full exam, your results show a per-section breakdown so you know exactly where to focus — most candidates need the most reps on Logical Reasoning, now the heaviest-weighted section.

Who Can Take the LSAT?

Anyone planning to apply to law school can take the LSAT — there is no degree, GPA, or work-experience requirement to register.[2] Most test takers are undergraduate students or graduates pursuing a J.D. at an ABA-approved or Canadian law school. You register through an LSAC online account.

How Do You Register for the LSAT?

You register for the LSAT at LSAC.org by creating an account, choosing a test date and delivery method, and paying the $253 fee for the 2026–27 testing year, which includes the LSAT Argumentative Writing.[2]

You can test online with live remote proctoring via Prometric’s ProProctor, or in person at a Prometric digital testing center. The Credential Assembly Service (CAS), required by most law schools, costs an additional $219. Fee waivers are available for candidates with demonstrated financial need.

How Is the LSAT Scored?

The LSAT is scored on a scaled range of 120 to 180 — there is no pass/fail.[3] Your raw score (number of questions answered correctly across the scored sections) is converted to this scaled score and reported with a percentile rank comparing you to other recent test takers.

There is no penalty for wrong answers, so you should answer every question. The unscored experimental section and the Argumentative Writing sample do not affect your 120–180 score.

How Hard Is the LSAT? (Score Ranges)

The LSAT has no pass/fail score — it is a competitive, norm-referenced exam with a median score of about 152 (roughly the 50th percentile).[5] A 160 lands near the 75th percentile and is considered strong, while top-25 and T14 law schools typically post medians of 165–173. Aim for the score range your target schools report.

120–180
Scaled score range
no pass/fail
~152
Median score
≈50th percentile
160+
Competitive target
≈75th percentile

The takeaway: drill until you’re consistently scoring in your target schools’ range on full-length practice — especially Logical Reasoning — before you book your test date.

What to Expect on Test Day

Test day runs about three hours: four 35-minute sections (three scored, one experimental) with a single 10-minute break after the second section.

[1] The LSAT is delivered by LSAC through Prometric — either online with live remote proctoring (ProProctor) or in person at a Prometric digital testing center.

For online testing, you’ll complete a system and ID check, clear your workspace, and be monitored by a live proctor; at a center, you check in with a valid photo ID and store personal items. There is no penalty for guessing, so you answer every question.

The unscored Argumentative Writing sample is completed separately online. Having simulated the full timing with practice tests makes that clock feel routine.

How to Use This LSAT Practice Test

  • Recreate exam conditions. Take the full test timed, with no notes.
  • Diagnose, then drill. Use a full LSAT simulation to find weak sections, then drill them.
  • Prioritize Logical Reasoning. It’s now two of three scored sections — the biggest score-mover.
  • Learn the why. Read every explanation — understanding the argument structure beats memorizing.
  • Answer everything. There’s no guessing penalty, so never leave a question blank.

Why the LSAT Matters

The LSAT is the most widely accepted admission test for law school, and your score is one of the two biggest factors — alongside GPA — in J.D. admissions decisions and scholarship offers.

[5] A higher score can open the door to more selective schools and substantial merit aid, so the points you gain in prep translate directly into options. These free LSAT practice tests are the most efficient way to build that score.

Conclusion

Scoring well on the LSAT comes down to mastering argument analysis and reading under time pressure — with Logical Reasoning now carrying about half your score. Use this free LSAT practice test to find your weak sections and drill them to mastery. Round out your prep with our free study guide, flashcards, and cheat sheet. Start with one full-length practice test to find your weakest section, then drill that section first.

LSAT Practice Test FAQ

The scored LSAT has three sections: two Logical Reasoning sections and one Reading Comprehension section. There is also one unscored experimental section (LR or RC) used to pilot future questions, plus a separate, unscored LSAT Argumentative Writing sample completed online. Analytical Reasoning ("Logic Games") was removed from the scored test in August 2024.

What changed on this page

Every real change, with the date.

  1. Interactive charts added. Built from the official outline and our question bank.
  2. 283 new practice questions. The bank now has 451 questions.
  3. 100 new practice questions. 31 questions retired. The bank now has 168 questions.

LSAT question bank

All 451 questions, by domain

A reference copy of every question in this practice test. Each answer stays hidden until you choose to show it. To practice with scoring, timing and your readiness score, use Start Test at the top of the page.

Logical Reasoning (225)

  1. If all poets are dreamers, and some dreamers are musicians, which of the following must be true?

    • A.Some dreamers aren't musicians.
    • B.Some musicians write poetry.
    • C.Some musicians are dreamers.
    • D.Every dreamer writes poetry.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Some musicians are dreamers.

    Since some dreamers are musicians, it must be true that some musicians are dreamers, because a 'some' statement can be reversed. It does not follow that some musicians write poetry: the musical dreamers could all lie outside the group of poets. The premises say every poet is a dreamer, not that every dreamer is a poet, and they never say whether any dreamer is not a musician, so neither of those claims is forced.

  2. A study shows that students who study logic improve their problem-solving skills more than those who study arithmetic. However, arithmetic study is more essential for everyday tasks. Which of the following conclusions can be logically drawn?

    • A.Problem-solving skill plays no real part at all in handling everyday chores.
    • B.Every student should take up arithmetic and drop the logic classes entirely.
    • C.A subject can sharpen problem-solving more but count less for routine tasks.
    • D.Arithmetic study can boost problem-solving skill even more than logic study can.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: A subject can sharpen problem-solving more but count less for routine tasks.

    The study says logic sharpens problem-solving more while arithmetic is more essential for everyday tasks, so a subject can sharpen problem-solving more and still count less for routine tasks. The premises only rank arithmetic higher for everyday use; they do not say problem-solving plays no part there. Nothing supports telling every student to drop logic, and the claim that arithmetic builds more problem-solving skill contradicts the study's own finding.

  3. If a law does not enhance public safety, it should not be enacted. Law X increases administrative burdens and does not enhance public safety. Which of the following conclusions follows logically?

    • A.Legislators should decline to enact Law X.
    • B.Law X would not affect public safety at all.
    • C.Any law adding red tape should be rejected.
    • D.Any law that aids safety should be enacted.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Legislators should decline to enact Law X.

    Law X does not enhance public safety, so the stated rule applies directly and legislators should decline to enact Law X. Not enhancing safety is different from having no effect on it, so the stem does not establish that Law X would leave safety entirely unaffected. The rule turns on safety, not paperwork, so it does not require rejecting every law that adds red tape, and saying any law that aids safety should be enacted reverses the conditional, which states only when a law should not be enacted.

  4. Only students who are disciplined and attentive can achieve high grades. Some disciplined students do not achieve high grades. Which of the following must be true?

    • A.Some of the disciplined students are not attentive.
    • B.Any disciplined and attentive student gets top marks.
    • C.Every student who achieves high grades is attentive.
    • D.No student who lacks attention is ever disciplined.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Every student who achieves high grades is attentive.

    'Only students who are disciplined and attentive can achieve high grades' makes both traits necessary for high grades, so every student who achieves high grades is attentive. The disciplined students who missed high grades may still be attentive, because the traits are required, not sufficient; so it does not follow that some disciplined students are inattentive, and having both traits does not guarantee top marks. Nothing in the stem ties a lack of attention to a lack of discipline.

  5. All items produced by Factory X must pass a quality test. Last month, 20% of its items failed the test. Which of the following can be inferred?

    • A.At least 20% of next month's items will fail it.
    • B.Factory X sold some items that had failed the test.
    • C.Four in five of the items tested that month passed.
    • D.Factory X's quality is lower than it was last year.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Four in five of the items tested that month passed.

    Every item must go through the test, and 20% failed last month, so the remaining 80%, or four in five, passed (100% minus 20%). Last month's rate does not fix next month's results. The stem says nothing about whether failed items were sold, and with no earlier figures there is no basis for comparing quality with last year.

  6. Every member of the book club enjoys either science fiction or mystery novels, but not both. If Sam, a member of the book club, enjoys science fiction, which of the following must be true?

    • A.Sam enjoys both science fiction and mystery.
    • B.Every book club member enjoys science fiction.
    • C.No book club member enjoys reading mysteries.
    • D.Sam does not enjoy reading mystery novels.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Sam does not enjoy reading mystery novels.

    Each member enjoys exactly one of the two genres, and Sam enjoys science fiction, so Sam does not enjoy mystery novels. Enjoying both genres is ruled out by the 'not both' condition. One member's taste tells us nothing about the rest of the club, so the stem cannot show that every member likes science fiction or that no member likes mysteries.

  7. In a survey, 90% of respondents said they prefer tea over coffee. If a respondent prefers tea, which of the following conclusions is least supported by the survey results?

    • A.This respondent is part of the survey's majority.
    • B.This person ranked tea above coffee when surveyed.
    • C.Numerous tea drinkers surveyed may still enjoy coffee.
    • D.Preferring tea means this person must dislike coffee.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Preferring tea means this person must dislike coffee.

    The least supported claim is that preferring tea means this person must dislike coffee, because ranking one drink above another says nothing about disliking the second. Since 90% preferred tea, this respondent is in the majority and did rank tea above coffee; both follow directly from the results. The results are also fully consistent with many tea drinkers still enjoying coffee, so that claim is not undercut.

  8. If a car is blue, then it must have been painted. A car at the dealership is not blue. Which of the following must be true?

    • A.Whether the car was ever painted is unknown.
    • B.The car at the dealership was never painted.
    • C.Every painted car at the dealership is blue.
    • D.The car at the dealership has been painted.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Whether the car was ever painted is unknown.

    Being blue is sufficient for having been painted, but this car is not blue, so the rule is silent about it and whether it was ever painted is unknown. Concluding that it was never painted denies the antecedent. The rule says blue cars are painted, not that painted cars are blue, and nothing in the stem establishes that this car was painted either.

  9. All successful entrepreneurs are risk-takers. No risk-averse person is a successful entrepreneur. Which of the following must be true?

    • A.Some risk-takers are not successful entrepreneurs.
    • B.No successful entrepreneur is ever risk-averse.
    • C.Every risk-taker is a successful entrepreneur.
    • D.Some risk-averse entrepreneurs are also risk-takers.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: No successful entrepreneur is ever risk-averse.

    No risk-averse person is a successful entrepreneur, so no successful entrepreneur is risk-averse; a 'no' statement can be reversed. The premises say all successful entrepreneurs are risk-takers but say nothing about risk-takers who are not entrepreneurs, so the claim that some risk-takers are not successful is possible rather than required, and the claim that every risk-taker succeeds reverses the conditional. Nothing in the premises shows that any risk-averse entrepreneur takes risks, and the second premise rules out risk-averse people succeeding as entrepreneurs.

  10. If increasing the price of an item results in fewer sales, decreasing the price will result in more sales. The store has not decreased the price of any item. Which of the following conclusions follows logically?

    • A.The store's sales have fallen while all its prices held.
    • B.The store's sales will rise even without any price cuts.
    • C.Only price cuts could ever raise the store's total sales.
    • D.None of the store's sales came from cutting its prices.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: None of the store's sales came from cutting its prices.

    The store has not lowered any price, so none of its sales can have come from a price cut. The conditional links price changes to sales but says nothing about how sales moved while prices held, so a fall in sales is not established, and neither is a future rise. The stem never claims price cuts are the only route to higher sales.

  11. A new law requires that for a product to be labeled "organic," it must contain 95% organic ingredients. Product X is labeled "organic" but contains 10% non-organic ingredients. Which of the following conclusions is logically supported?

    • A.Product X meets the new law's organic standard.
    • B.The law permits products to be 10% non-organic.
    • C.The new law exempts products like Product X.
    • D.Product X's organic label is in fact unlawful.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Product X's organic label is in fact unlawful.

    With 10% non-organic ingredients, Product X is 90% organic (100 minus 10), below the 95% the law requires, so its organic label is unlawful under the new law. For the same reason it does not meet the standard. A 95% requirement allows at most 5% non-organic content, not 10%, and nothing in the stem says Product X is exempt.

  12. If a government increases taxes on luxury goods, then sales of luxury goods decrease. The government has not increased taxes on luxury goods this year. Which of the following conclusions follows logically?

    • A.Luxury sales did not decline at all at any point this year.
    • B.No drop in these sales this year came from a tax increase.
    • C.Luxury sales this year fell below the totals of a year ago.
    • D.Only a tax increase can bring about a fall in luxury sales.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: No drop in these sales this year came from a tax increase.

    No tax increase happened this year, so no drop in luxury sales this year can have come from one. Concluding that sales did not decline at all denies the antecedent, since sales can fall for other reasons. Nothing in the stem shows sales actually fell below last year's totals, and the conditional names one sufficient cause, not the only one.

  13. In a certain town, anyone who owns a car must also own a parking permit. Sara does not own a parking permit. Which of the following must be true?

    • A.Sara owns a car kept out of town.
    • B.Anyone with a permit owns a car too.
    • C.Sara cannot be the owner of a car.
    • D.Sara needs a permit to drive a car.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Sara cannot be the owner of a car.

    Owning a car requires owning a parking permit, and Sara has no permit, so Sara cannot be the owner of a car. A car kept out of town would still be a car she owns, which the rule forbids without a permit. The rule runs one way, so it does not make every permit holder a car owner, and it governs owning a car, not driving one.

  14. Every member of the debate club has taken part in at least one debate this month. John has not taken part in any debate this month. Which of the following conclusions can be drawn?

    • A.John was excused from debating this month.
    • B.John does not belong to the debate club.
    • C.Members can go a month without a debate.
    • D.John will join in two debates next month.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: John does not belong to the debate club.

    Every club member has in fact taken part in at least one debate this month, and John has taken part in none, so John does not belong to the club. If he were a member, he would have debated this month, so being an excused member is ruled out. The stem reports what members actually did and gives no basis for saying members can go a month without a debate, and nothing in it predicts what John will do next month.

  15. If a student studies for more than five hours, they will pass the exam. Alex studied for four hours and did not pass the exam. Which of the following must be true?

    • A.Passing the exam requires more than five hours of study.
    • B.Anyone who studies for four hours will fail the exam.
    • C.Alex studied less than the time that guarantees a pass.
    • D.Alex would have passed with five hours of study time.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Alex studied less than the time that guarantees a pass.

    Only studying more than five hours is said to guarantee a pass, and Alex studied four, so Alex studied less than the time that guarantees a pass. The rule makes more than five hours sufficient, not necessary, so it does not say passing requires that much or that four hours always fails. Five hours is not more than five, so the rule would not have guaranteed Alex a pass at that amount either.

  16. Every person who has received the vaccine reports no side effects. Maria reports having side effects. Which of the following conclusions follows logically?

    • A.The vaccine gave Maria her side effects.
    • B.Maria has never been given the vaccine.
    • C.Maria's report of side effects is wrong.
    • D.Side effects bar people from the vaccine.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Maria has never been given the vaccine.

    Everyone who received the vaccine reports no side effects, and Maria reports side effects, so Maria has never been given the vaccine. Saying the vaccine caused her side effects contradicts that premise. The reasoning works from her report, so it offers no ground for calling the report wrong, and nothing says side effects disqualify anyone from vaccination.

  17. If a plant is watered daily, it grows to its full height. Plant X was not watered daily and did not grow to its full height. Which of the following can be inferred?

    • A.Plant X's result is fully consistent with the watering rule.
    • B.Skipping daily watering kept Plant X short of full height.
    • C.No plant can ever reach full height without daily watering.
    • D.Plant X needs more than just daily watering to flourish.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Plant X's result is fully consistent with the watering rule.

    The rule says daily watering is enough for full height; a plant that was not watered daily and fell short does not conflict with it, so Plant X's result is fully consistent with the watering rule. Blaming the missed watering, or claiming no plant reaches full height without daily watering, treats daily watering as necessary when the rule makes it only sufficient. Plant X was never watered daily, so nothing shows daily watering would fail to be enough for it.

  18. In a certain city, every library member has access to online resources. Tom does not have access to online resources. Which of the following must be true?

    • A.Tom prefers not to use online resources.
    • B.Few members use the library's online tools.
    • C.Tom does not hold any library memberships.
    • D.All people with online access are members.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Tom does not hold any library memberships.

    Every library member has access to online resources, and Tom lacks that access, so Tom does not hold any library membership. The stem is about having access, not choosing to use it, so Tom's preferences and how often members log on are beside the point. The rule runs from membership to access, so it does not make everyone with access a member.

  19. All products on sale have been discounted by at least 20%. Item Y has not been discounted. Which of the following conclusions is logically supported?

    • A.Item Y will be discounted at a later date.
    • B.Item Y is not among the products on sale.
    • C.Each item with a discount is now on sale.
    • D.No item off sale has ever had a discount.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Item Y is not among the products on sale.

    Every product on sale has been discounted by at least 20%, and Item Y has not been discounted at all, so Item Y is not among the products on sale. Nothing in the stem predicts a future discount. The rule runs from 'on sale' to 'discounted', so it does not show that every discounted item is on sale or that items off sale were never discounted.

  20. A new policy states that a student must maintain an A average to qualify for the honors program. Jane, who has a B average, argues that she should be admitted based on her extracurricular achievements. Which of the following conclusions follows logically?

    • A.Jane's activities win her a place anyway.
    • B.Activities count for more than grades do.
    • C.Jane would qualify with a B-plus average.
    • D.Jane does not meet the grade requirement.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Jane does not meet the grade requirement.

    The policy requires an A average and Jane has a B, so she does not meet the grade requirement for the honors program. Her extracurricular record does not override a stated requirement, and the policy never ranks activities above grades. A B-plus average is still not an A, so it would not qualify her either.

  21. If a book receives a literary award, it must be critically acclaimed. "Journey Through the Stars" did not receive a literary award. Which of the following must be true?

    • A."Journey Through the Stars" has not been acclaimed.
    • B."Journey Through the Stars" drew some poor reviews.
    • C."Journey Through the Stars" may still be acclaimed.
    • D."Journey Through the Stars" would win if acclaimed.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: "Journey Through the Stars" may still be acclaimed.

    Winning a literary award is sufficient for critical acclaim, but this book did not win one, so the rule says nothing about it and the book may still be acclaimed. Concluding that it has not been acclaimed denies the antecedent. The stem gives no information about its reviews, and saying it would win if acclaimed reverses the conditional, which runs from award to acclaim.

  22. All participants in the study who exercised daily showed improved health outcomes. Mark did not show improved health outcomes. Which of the following can be logically inferred?

    • A.Mark failed to exercise daily during the study.
    • B.Mark was not a participant who exercised daily.
    • C.Mark was never enrolled as a study participant.
    • D.All of the study participants did exercise daily.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Mark was not a participant who exercised daily.

    Every participant who exercised daily showed improved outcomes, and Mark did not, so Mark was not a participant who exercised daily. He could be a participant who skipped daily exercise or someone outside the study, so neither the claim that he failed to exercise daily during the study nor the claim that he was never enrolled is forced on its own. Nothing says all participants exercised daily.

  23. A certain type of tree blooms only if it receives adequate sunlight. The trees in area X are not blooming. Which of the following conclusions follows logically?

    • A.The trees in area X must be lacking sunlight.
    • B.Not blooming does not prove a lack of sunlight.
    • C.Every tree of this type in sunlight will bloom.
    • D.No variety of tree could bloom in shaded places.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Not blooming does not prove a lack of sunlight.

    'Blooms only if it receives adequate sunlight' makes sunlight necessary, not sufficient, so trees that are not blooming may lack sunlight or something else; not blooming does not prove a lack of sunlight. Concluding that the trees must be lacking sunlight treats the necessary condition as if it were sufficient. The rule does not promise that sunlit trees bloom, and it covers one type of tree, not every variety.

  24. If a vehicle is classified as an SUV, it must have four-wheel drive. Vehicle Y is classified as an SUV. Which of the following must be true?

    • A.Vehicle Y must be equipped with four-wheel drive.
    • B.Every vehicle with four-wheel drive is an SUV.
    • C.Only SUVs can be built with four-wheel drive.
    • D.Vehicle Y is its maker's only current SUV.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Vehicle Y must be equipped with four-wheel drive.

    Every SUV has four-wheel drive and Vehicle Y is an SUV, so Vehicle Y must be equipped with four-wheel drive. The rule runs from SUV to four-wheel drive, so it does not make every four-wheel-drive vehicle an SUV or limit four-wheel drive to SUVs. Nothing in the stem describes the rest of its maker's lineup.

  25. A law states that for a contract to be valid, it must be signed by both parties. The contract between Company A and Company B was not signed by Company B. Which of the following can be logically inferred?

    • A.The contract between the firms is not valid.
    • B.Company A also failed to sign the contract.
    • C.A single signature can make a contract valid.
    • D.Every contract that Company B signs is valid.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The contract between the firms is not valid.

    A valid contract needs both parties' signatures, and Company B did not sign, so the contract is not valid. The stem does not say whether Company A signed. One signature cannot make a contract valid because both are required, and a signature is only a necessary condition, so Company B signing would not by itself make a contract valid.

  26. If a movie is considered a blockbuster, it must have grossed over $100 million. "Epic Adventure" is considered a blockbuster. Which of the following must be true?

    • A.That blockbuster did gross more than $100 million.
    • B.Every film past $100 million is a blockbuster.
    • C."Epic Adventure" was the biggest film that year.
    • D."Epic Adventure" made exactly $100 million in all.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: That blockbuster did gross more than $100 million.

    Every blockbuster grossed over $100 million, and "Epic Adventure" is a blockbuster, so that blockbuster did gross more than $100 million. The rule does not make every film past that figure a blockbuster, and it gives no ranking against other films. Exactly $100 million is not more than $100 million, so that figure contradicts the rule.

  27. In City Z, all public transportation vehicles are equipped with GPS tracking. The bus route 5 in City Z has been experiencing delays. Which of the following conclusions follows logically?

    • A.The GPS tracking on route 5 has stopped working.
    • B.The GPS tracking on route 5 triggered the delays.
    • C.Every bus route in City Z suffers similar delays.
    • D.The buses on route 5 have GPS tracking installed.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The buses on route 5 have GPS tracking installed.

    All public transportation vehicles in City Z have GPS tracking, and route 5 is a City Z bus route, so its buses have GPS tracking installed. The stem gives no information about whether that tracking works or about what caused the delays. One delayed route says nothing about every other route in the city.

  28. All members of the chess club have won at least one chess match. Tina has never won a chess match. Which of the following can be logically inferred?

    • A.Tina does not belong to this chess club.
    • B.Tina is exempt from the rule on winning.
    • C.Members need not have won a chess match.
    • D.Each member except Tina has won a match.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Tina does not belong to this chess club.

    Every chess club member has won at least one match and Tina has never won one, so Tina does not belong to the club. The premise states what all members have done, which leaves no room for an exemption and contradicts the claim that members need not have won. Saying every member except Tina has won treats her as a member, which the premises rule out.

  29. A city council member argues: "Our proposed bike-lane network will reduce traffic congestion downtown. After all, every major city that has built an extensive bike-lane network has seen its downtown congestion fall." Which one of the following is an assumption required by the council member's argument?

    • A.The planned network will be as extensive as the cited cities' networks.
    • B.Bike lanes are the only effective way to cut traffic congestion downtown.
    • C.Most downtown drivers will switch to cycling soon after the lanes open.
    • D.Cutting congestion matters more to the city than any other council goal.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The planned network will be as extensive as the cited cities' networks.

    The evidence covers only cities that built extensive networks, so the argument needs the planned network to be as extensive as theirs; if it were small, the precedent would not carry over. The argument can stand even if other measures would also cut congestion, and it does not need most drivers to switch, since a smaller shift could be enough. How congestion ranks among the council's goals has no bearing on whether the lanes will reduce it.

  30. Manager: "We should switch to the new payroll software. The old system crashes about once a month, and the new system has never crashed in the year our partner company has used it." The manager's reasoning is most vulnerable to criticism on the grounds that it

    • A.Relies on testimony from a source with a stake in the eventual decision
    • B.Concludes that the new software will never crash after one year of use
    • C.Assumes that whatever works for one firm will work for every other firm
    • D.Fails to ask if the two firms use the software under similar conditions
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Fails to ask if the two firms use the software under similar conditions

    The manager predicts reliability here from the record at a partner company without asking whether the two firms use the software under similar conditions; heavier or different use could still cause crashes. The partner company is not shown to have any stake in the decision. The manager concludes only that switching is wise, not that the software will never crash, and the argument concerns this one company rather than every firm.

  31. All licensed electricians in the province have passed the safety certification exam. No one who has passed that exam is unfamiliar with the current wiring code. Tomas is a licensed electrician in the province. If the statements above are true, which one of the following must also be true?

    • A.Anyone who knows the code is licensed.
    • B.Tomas is familiar with the current code.
    • C.Tomas retook the safety exam many times.
    • D.Some who know the code aren't licensed.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Tomas is familiar with the current code.

    Tomas is a licensed electrician, so he passed the safety exam, and no one who passed it is unfamiliar with the current code, so Tomas is familiar with the current code. The premises run from licensing to knowing the code, so they do not make everyone who knows it licensed. They say nothing about whether some people who know the code lack a license, or about how many times Tomas sat the exam.

  32. Researcher: "Communities that adopted the new flood-warning system saw far fewer flood injuries than communities without it. Therefore, the warning system caused the reduction in injuries." Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the researcher's argument?

    • A.Installing the system cost very little in most of the communities.
    • B.The adopting communities also built new levees in that same period.
    • C.The system sometimes issued flood alerts when no flood was coming.
    • D.A few communities lacking the system saw fewer injuries one year.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The adopting communities also built new levees in that same period.

    If the adopting communities also built new levees in the same period, the levees could explain the fall in injuries, so the warning system need not be the cause. The system's low cost and its false alarms do not touch the causal claim at all. A drop in a few non-adopting communities in a single year is too thin to offset the consistent gap the researcher reports.

  33. Critic: "The new tax incentive cannot be the reason that local manufacturing output rose this year, because output also rose in the neighboring state, which did not offer any such incentive." The critic's argument proceeds by

    • A.Citing a case lacking the alleged cause in which the effect still occurred
    • B.Showing that the alleged cause arose only after the effect was in place
    • C.Arguing the incentive was too small to affect factory output in any way
    • D.Doubting the motives of the people who had first put forth the incentive
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Citing a case lacking the alleged cause in which the effect still occurred

    The critic notes that output also rose in the neighboring state, which had no incentive, so the argument cites a case lacking the alleged cause in which the effect still occurred. The critic says nothing about timing, so it does not show the incentive came after the rise. It never discusses the incentive's size, and it does not question anyone's motives.

  34. If a restaurant uses only locally sourced produce, then it can display the regional-farm certification badge. The Maple Table displays the regional-farm certification badge. Which one of the following can be properly inferred from these statements?

    • A.The Maple Table must use nothing but locally sourced produce.
    • B.Every restaurant that uses only local produce shows the badge.
    • C.Whether the Maple Table uses only local produce is unknown.
    • D.No restaurant that lacks the badge uses only local produce.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Whether the Maple Table uses only local produce is unknown.

    Using only local produce makes a restaurant eligible to display the badge, but the badge may be available for other reasons, so whether the Maple Table uses only local produce is unknown. Concluding that it must use nothing but local produce affirms the consequent. Being eligible is not the same as displaying, so the rule does not say every all-local restaurant shows the badge, and a restaurant without the badge might still use only local produce.

  35. Editorial: "Whenever the central bank raises interest rates, consumer borrowing declines within six months. The bank raised rates last month. So consumer borrowing will decline within six months." Which one of the following arguments is most similar in its reasoning to the editorial's argument?

    • A.Whenever it rains heavily, the river rises. The river has risen today, so it must have rained heavily.
    • B.Most students who study hard pass the exam. Dana studied hard this term, so Dana will probably pass it.
    • C.Whenever the store runs a sale, foot traffic rises. Foot traffic fell today, so the store ran no sale.
    • D.Whenever the team practices at dawn, it wins that night. It practiced at dawn today, so it wins tonight.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Whenever the team practices at dawn, it wins that night. It practiced at dawn today, so it wins tonight.

    The editorial applies a 'whenever X, then Y' rule to a case where X has happened and concludes Y, and the team argument does the same with dawn practice and a win. The river argument runs backward from the effect to the cause. The study argument rests on 'most' and concludes only 'probably', and the store argument reasons from the absence of the effect to the absence of the cause, which is a different form.

  36. Columnist: "My opponent claims the new zoning law will hurt small businesses. But she owns a large commercial real estate firm that profits from the current rules, so her claim should be dismissed." The columnist's reasoning is flawed because it

    • A.Dismisses a claim only by pointing to the motives of its source
    • B.Treats the failure of a claim as proof that its opposite holds
    • C.Assumes that what helps one firm must also help every other firm
    • D.Draws a sweeping conclusion about every firm from a small sample
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Dismisses a claim only by pointing to the motives of its source

    The columnist rejects the opponent's claim only by pointing to her financial motives, an ad hominem move; who profits says nothing about whether the zoning law will hurt small businesses. The columnist does not conclude that the opposite claim is true, does not generalize from one firm to every firm, and draws no conclusion from a sample of any size.

  37. Survey results show that employees who exercise regularly report higher job satisfaction than those who do not. A consultant concludes that encouraging exercise will raise job satisfaction across the company. Which one of the following, if true, would most strengthen the consultant's argument?

    • A.Contented staff are no likelier than unhappy ones to begin exercise
    • B.Staff who exercise often also earn higher salaries than other staff
    • C.Staff tend to overstate on surveys how often they actually exercise
    • D.Several rival firms already pay for gym access to motivate exercise
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Contented staff are no likelier than unhappy ones to begin exercise

    The argument infers that exercise causes satisfaction, so it is strengthened by ruling out the reverse direction: if contented staff are no likelier than unhappy ones to begin exercising, satisfaction is not what produces the exercise. Higher salaries among frequent exercisers suggest a different cause of satisfaction, which weakens the argument. Overstated survey answers undermine the data rather than support it, and what rival firms pay for says nothing about whether exercise raises satisfaction.

  38. Principle: "A public official should recuse herself from any decision in which a member of her immediate family stands to gain financially." Which one of the following judgments most closely conforms to this principle?

    • A.A treasurer may rightfully vote to deposit funds in her son's bank
    • B.A mayor should recuse herself when her brother owns a bidding firm
    • C.A judge should recuse herself when her old roommate is a plaintiff
    • D.A senator should recuse herself when her party profits from a bill
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: A mayor should recuse herself when her brother owns a bidding firm

    The principle requires recusal when an immediate family member stands to gain financially, and a brother who owns a bidding firm fits exactly, so the mayor should recuse herself. The treasurer's son also stands to gain from the deposit, so calling her vote rightful contradicts the principle. A former roommate is not family, and a political party's gain is not a family member's financial gain, so the principle does not call for recusal in either of those cases.

  39. Naturalist: "The cave salamander is blind, so it cannot rely on vision to find prey. Yet it captures prey with remarkable precision in total darkness." Which one of the following, if true, most helps to resolve the apparent discrepancy?

    • A.It hunts prey that are sightless and dwell in these caverns
    • B.It needs to feed far less often than do surface salamanders
    • C.It senses faint ripples that moving prey make in cave water
    • D.It is descended from surface kin that once had working eyes
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: It senses faint ripples that moving prey make in cave water

    The puzzle is how a blind animal locates prey precisely, and a sense that picks up the faint ripples moving prey make in the water answers it directly. Prey that are also blind would explain why the prey cannot flee by sight, not how the salamander finds them. How often it feeds and whether its ancestors had eyes say nothing about how it detects prey now.

  40. Advocate: "The library should extend its weekend hours. A recent poll found that 70 percent of respondents support longer weekend hours, so the community clearly wants this change." The argument is most vulnerable to the objection that

    • A.the poll surveyed library staff instead of the general public
    • B.the argument never specifies how many more hours are proposed
    • C.the poll results are too outdated to reflect current opinions
    • D.those polled might not reflect the views of residents overall
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: those polled might not reflect the views of residents overall

    The advocate moves from what poll respondents said to what the whole community wants, so the argument is most exposed if those polled do not represent residents generally, for instance if they were mostly frequent library users. Nothing in the argument says the poll surveyed library staff, and the poll is described as recent, so neither of those objections fits. The exact number of added hours is a detail the conclusion about community wishes does not depend on.

  41. Two analysts disagree. Analyst One: "The factory's emissions are within legal limits, so the factory is not harming the surrounding ecosystem." Analyst Two: "Legal limits were set decades ago and do not account for the cumulative effects we now understand; the factory may well be harming the ecosystem." The point at issue between the two analysts is whether

    • A.the factory's emissions currently rise well above the legal limits
    • B.regulators ought to amend the limits to reflect cumulative effects
    • C.staying within legal limits ensures that the ecosystem is unharmed
    • D.cumulative effects of emissions on the ecosystem are clearly known
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: staying within legal limits ensures that the ecosystem is unharmed

    Analyst One reasons that because emissions are within legal limits there is no harm, and Analyst Two rejects exactly that step, so they disagree about whether staying within the limits ensures the ecosystem is unharmed. Both treat the emissions as within the limits, so whether they rise above them is not in dispute. Analyst One says nothing about amending the limits or about how well cumulative effects are known, so neither can be a point on which the two disagree.

  42. Economist: "Raising the minimum wage will not increase unemployment. Critics say it will, but they have said the same thing about every past minimum-wage increase, and unemployment did not rise after those increases." The claim that critics said the same thing about past increases functions in the argument to

    • A.state the main conclusion that the economist defends
    • B.concede a fact that weakens the economist's position
    • C.give reason to doubt the critics' current prediction
    • D.attack the critics' motives rather than their claims
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: give reason to doubt the critics' current prediction

    The critics' record of failed predictions is offered as a reason to doubt their current prediction, which supports the economist's conclusion that unemployment will not rise. The main conclusion is the claim about unemployment, not the critics' history. The record helps the economist rather than weakening the position, and it targets how reliable the critics' forecasts have been, not their motives.

  43. Some of the volunteers at the shelter are trained in first aid. All of the volunteers trained in first aid are also certified lifeguards. Which one of the following must be true?

    • A.Each certified lifeguard at the shelter knows first aid well
    • B.No volunteer lacking first aid training is a lifeguard there
    • C.Most of the volunteers at the shelter are trained lifeguards
    • D.At least one shelter volunteer is also a certified lifeguard
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: At least one shelter volunteer is also a certified lifeguard

    Some volunteers are trained in first aid, and every such volunteer is a certified lifeguard, so at least one volunteer must be a certified lifeguard. The premises do not say that every lifeguard knows first aid; that reverses the conditional. Volunteers without first aid training could still be lifeguards, and nothing establishes that most volunteers are lifeguards, since 'some' may be only a few.

  44. Every applicant who is hired must have a valid teaching license. Maria was not hired. Which one of the following can be validly concluded?

    • A.Maria surely lacks a valid teaching license for the post
    • B.Whether Maria holds a valid license cannot be worked out
    • C.Maria would surely have been hired given a valid license
    • D.Some applicant who lacked a valid license was then hired
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Whether Maria holds a valid license cannot be worked out

    A valid license is necessary for being hired, not sufficient, so learning that Maria was not hired tells us nothing about her license: whether she holds one cannot be worked out. Concluding that she lacks a license treats the necessary condition as if it were sufficient, and so does claiming a license would have got her hired. An applicant hired without a license would contradict the premise that every hired applicant has one.

  45. If the museum receives the grant, then it will open the new wing. The museum will not open the new wing. Which one of the following follows logically from these statements?

    • A.The museum won the grant but has paused the plan
    • B.The grant will fall short of what the wing costs
    • C.The museum will open another wing in place of it
    • D.The museum is not going to be securing the grant
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The museum is not going to be securing the grant

    Receiving the grant guarantees the new wing opens, and the wing will not open, so by the contrapositive the museum is not going to secure the grant. Winning the grant while the wing stays unopened is exactly what the conditional rules out. Nothing in the statements concerns the size of the grant compared with the wing's cost, or any other wing the museum might open.

  46. Letter to the editor: "The new highway should be approved because it is the right thing to do, and it is the right thing to do because approving it is clearly justified." The reasoning in this argument is flawed because it

    • A.mistakes an effect of the decision for that decision's cause
    • B.draws a general rule about highways from one particular case
    • C.relies on popular sentiment in place of any genuine evidence
    • D.presupposes the very conclusion that it is supposed to prove
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: presupposes the very conclusion that it is supposed to prove

    The highway is said to be right because approving it is justified, and justified because it is right, so the argument presupposes the very conclusion it is supposed to prove. No cause and effect are mixed up, since the argument names no effects at all. It makes no general claim about highways, and it cites no popular sentiment; it simply restates its own conclusion.

  47. Botanist: "This fertilizer must be effective at promoting growth. In our trial, every plant given the fertilizer grew taller than it had the previous season." Which one of the following is an assumption on which the argument depends?

    • A.Height offers the only reliable measure of a plant's health
    • B.Each test plant received exactly the same dose of nutrients
    • C.Left untreated, the plants would not have shown that growth
    • D.No rival product supports greater growth than this one does
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Left untreated, the plants would not have shown that growth

    The botanist credits the fertilizer for growth over last season, which only works if the plants would not have shown that growth without it; if they grow taller every year anyway, the trial shows nothing. The argument is about growth, not overall health, so it need not treat height as the only measure of health. It also does not require equal doses for every plant or a comparison with rival products, since its claim is only that this fertilizer is effective.

  48. Health official: "People who take the supplement report fewer colds than people who do not. Clearly, the supplement prevents colds." Which one of the following describes a reasoning error in the official's argument?

    • A.It infers causation from a mere correlation of two findings
    • B.It treats the supplement's popularity as proof of its worth
    • C.It depends on a sample of patients that is unrepresentative
    • D.It shifts the meaning of a significant term halfway through
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: It infers causation from a mere correlation of two findings

    The official moves from the fact that supplement users report fewer colds to the claim that the supplement prevents colds, inferring causation from a mere correlation; users might simply be more health-conscious in other ways. The argument says nothing about how popular the supplement is. No sample of patients is described, and no key term changes meaning partway through.

  49. A sufficient assumption is one that, if added to an argument's premises, guarantees the conclusion. Argument: "Anyone who finishes the marathon receives a medal. Priya trained for six months. Therefore, Priya will receive a medal." Which one of the following, if assumed, allows the conclusion to be properly drawn?

    • A.Priya needed six months of training to finish the marathon
    • B.Most people training for six months do finish the marathon
    • C.Six months of training will get Priya through the marathon
    • D.Some of the past marathon medalists trained for six months
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Six months of training will get Priya through the marathon

    The premises say anyone who finishes the marathon gets a medal, so the conclusion is guaranteed once we add that Priya's six months of training will get her through the race. Saying she needed six months of training to finish makes the training necessary, not sufficient, so she could still fail to finish. 'Most people' only makes her finishing likely, and what some past medalists did says nothing about whether Priya will finish.

  50. A necessary assumption must be true for the argument to succeed, while a sufficient assumption would by itself make the conclusion follow. Argument: "The bridge will be safe to reopen, because the inspection found no structural cracks." Which one of the following is a necessary assumption of this argument?

    • A.The inspectors closely examined every last part of the bridge
    • B.Having no structural cracks bears at least somewhat on safety
    • C.Cracks are the only conceivable threat to the bridge's safety
    • D.The bridge was closed over fears of serious structural cracks
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Having no structural cracks bears at least somewhat on safety

    For the inspection result to support the conclusion at all, the absence of structural cracks must bear at least somewhat on whether the bridge is safe; if it were irrelevant, the premise would give no support. The argument need not assume cracks are the only conceivable threat, which is far stronger than required. An inspection of every last part and the reason for the original closure are not things the argument must take for granted.

  51. Politician: "Either we cut the education budget or we raise taxes. We will not raise taxes. So we must cut the education budget." Which one of the following arguments has a reasoning structure most parallel to the politician's?

    • A.The meal is spicy or sweet. It is sweet, so it is not spicy.
    • B.If the bell rings, we all go. We all went, so the bell rang.
    • C.Most of the crew back the plan. So the plan is sure to pass.
    • D.The shipment is late or lost. It is not lost, so it is late.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The shipment is late or lost. It is not lost, so it is late.

    The politician offers two alternatives, rules one out, and concludes the other, and the shipment argument does the same: late or lost, not lost, so late. The meal argument affirms one alternative and denies the other, which is a different and invalid move. The bell argument affirms the consequent of a conditional, and the crew argument jumps from majority support to a sure result.

  52. Sociologist: "Communities with more public parks tend to have lower crime rates." Which one of the following, if true, most undermines the conclusion that building more parks would reduce crime?

    • A.Several towns saw crime decline after creating further parks
    • B.Wealth independently drives both park building and low crime
    • C.Most local residents say they would welcome additional parks
    • D.Maintaining public parks costs towns a large amount annually
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Wealth independently drives both park building and low crime

    If wealth independently drives both park building and low crime, the link between parks and crime can be explained without parks doing anything, so building more parks may not lower crime. Towns whose crime declined after creating more parks would support the conclusion. Residents' wishes and the cost of upkeep bear on whether parks are worth building, not on whether they reduce crime.

  53. Which one of the following questions would be most useful to answer in evaluating the argument: "The company's profits rose after it adopted the four-day workweek, so the shorter week must have boosted productivity"?

    • A.Whether the staff enjoyed having a longer weekend each week
    • B.Whether other rival firms have also adopted a four-day week
    • C.Whether a new product launch or other change raised profits
    • D.Whether the firm had more workers than its main competitors
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Whether a new product launch or other change raised profits

    The argument credits the four-day week for the rise in profits, so the most useful thing to learn is whether a new product launch or some other change raised profits instead; either answer bears directly on that causal claim. Whether staff enjoyed the longer weekend does not show what drove profits. What rival firms adopted, and how the firm's headcount compared with theirs, say nothing about why this firm's profits rose.

  54. Economist: "A tariff on imported steel will protect domestic steel jobs. However, it will also raise costs for domestic manufacturers that use steel, which could eliminate even more jobs in those industries." Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the economist's argument?

    • A.A steel tariff would shield jobs in the steel mills
    • B.The tariff may well destroy more jobs than it saves
    • C.Tariffs on steel always do much more harm than good
    • D.Firms that use steel ought to seek other raw inputs
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The tariff may well destroy more jobs than it saves

    The economist grants that the tariff protects steel jobs and then stresses that it could eliminate even more jobs elsewhere, so the main point is that the tariff may well destroy more jobs than it saves. Shielding jobs in the steel mills is a concession on the way to that point, not the point itself. The economist says the tariff could do net harm, not that steel tariffs always do, and gives no advice about switching inputs.

  55. Coach: "Players who visualize their performance before a game perform better than those who do not. Therefore, our team should add a visualization session before each game to improve results." Which one of the following is an assumption the coach's argument requires?

    • A.The team's players are capable of visualizing their play well
    • B.Visualization would aid the players more than extra drills do
    • C.Visualization is the greatest single factor in how teams play
    • D.No rival club in the league already runs visualization drills
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The team's players are capable of visualizing their play well

    The coach's recommendation only works if this team's players are capable of visualizing their play well; if they cannot, the added sessions will not produce the benefit. The argument does not need visualization to beat extra drills or to be the greatest single factor, only to help. What rival clubs do is irrelevant to whether the sessions would help this team.

  56. Geologist: "This rock layer contains fossils of marine organisms. Marine organisms live only in seawater. Therefore, the area where this layer formed was once covered by sea." The reasoning in the geologist's argument is most similar to that in which one of the following?

    • A.This room smells of smoke. Only fire makes smoke. So a fire burned.
    • B.The lawn is soaked. Rain soaks lawns. So it must have rained there.
    • C.This coin is metal. Some metals are magnetic. So this coin is also.
    • D.This bird flies south. Most birds migrate. So it is a typical bird.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: This room smells of smoke. Only fire makes smoke. So a fire burned.

    The geologist notes a marker that arises only under one condition and concludes that condition existed, which matches the smoke argument: smoke comes only from fire, so a fire burned. The lawn argument looks similar but only says rain soaks lawns, not that only rain does, so it affirms the consequent. The coin argument draws a conclusion from 'some', and the bird argument rests on 'most'.

  57. Reviewer: "The film cannot be a masterpiece, because masterpieces are universally praised, and several prominent critics have panned this film." The reviewer's argument depends on assuming which one of the following?

    • A.Majority critical praise suffices to make a film a masterpiece
    • B.Prominent critics are reliable judges of a film's true quality
    • C.The reviewer personally disliked the film when it was released
    • D.Universal praise would demand the backing of these critics too
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Universal praise would demand the backing of these critics too

    The conclusion follows only if the critics who panned the film count among those whose praise universal acclaim requires; if their opinions fall outside that group, the film could still be universally praised. Whether majority praise suffices for masterpiece status reverses the premise and is not needed. The argument relies on the critics' pans breaking universal praise, not on their being reliable judges, and the reviewer's own taste plays no role in it.

  58. Which one of the following exhibits a flaw in reasoning most similar to the flaw in this argument: "Every member of the championship team is an excellent athlete. Dev is an excellent athlete. Therefore, Dev is a member of the championship team"?

    • A.All squares are rectangles. This is a square, so it is one too.
    • B.No fish are mammals. Every whale is a mammal, so none are fish.
    • C.Some bakers are wealthy. Sam is a baker, so Sam is wealthy too.
    • D.All pilots hold licenses. Ana has a license, so she is a pilot.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: All pilots hold licenses. Ana has a license, so she is a pilot.

    The original argument takes a trait every team member has and concludes that anyone with the trait is a member, and the pilot argument makes the same error: holding a license does not make Ana a pilot. The square and whale arguments are valid. The baker argument is flawed, but differently, since it treats 'some bakers' as if it covered every baker.

  59. Manager: "We received zero complaints about the new checkout system last week. The system is clearly working perfectly." Which one of the following points to a weakness in the manager's reasoning?

    • A.Some cashiers admit they prefer working with the earlier system
    • B.Shoppers who had trouble may have just left without complaining
    • C.This new system proved costlier to install than its predecessor
    • D.Several complaints about the parking lot arrived that same week
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Shoppers who had trouble may have just left without complaining

    The manager treats zero complaints as proof that the system works perfectly, but shoppers who had trouble may have just left without complaining, so silence does not show the absence of problems. Cashiers' preference for the earlier system and its installation cost say nothing about whether customers had problems with it. Complaints about the parking lot concern a different matter and do not touch the checkout system.

  60. Which one of the following must be FALSE if the statement "All certified arborists in the county have passed the climbing exam" is true, together with "Wendell is a certified arborist in the county"?

    • A.Wendell has never managed to pass the climbing exam
    • B.Wendell has at some stage passed this climbing exam
    • C.Only an arborist has ever passed this climbing exam
    • D.Some arborists in the area passed the climbing exam
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Wendell has never managed to pass the climbing exam

    All certified arborists in the county have passed the exam and Wendell is one, so he must have passed; the claim that he never managed to pass must be false. That he has passed is therefore true, not false. Whether only arborists have passed is left open by the statements, and that some arborists passed is supported by Wendell's own case, so neither must be false.

  61. Editorial: "Opponents of the new transit tax argue it will burden low-income residents. But these opponents own cars and would simply prefer not to pay for public transit they don't use." The editorial's argument is flawed because it

    • A.targets the opponents' motives instead of the case they make
    • B.concludes that a claim is untrue because it remains unproven
    • C.relies on figures about local renters that it never provides
    • D.confuses what the law permits with what is morally justified
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: targets the opponents' motives instead of the case they make

    The editorial answers the claim that the tax burdens low-income residents by saying opponents own cars and want to avoid paying, which targets their motives instead of the case they make. It never argues that the claim is untrue merely because it is unproven. It cites no figures at all, and it draws no line between what the law permits and what is morally justified.

  62. Most of the students who attended the review session passed the exam. Most of the students who passed the exam also completed the practice set. Which one of the following can be properly inferred?

    • A.Most of those at the review session completed the practice set
    • B.At least one participant at the review session passed the exam
    • C.Most who completed the practice set were at the review session
    • D.Each person who finished the practice set also passed the exam
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: At least one participant at the review session passed the exam

    If most attendees passed, more than half did, so at least one participant at the review session passed. Two 'most' statements do not chain: the attendees who passed and the passers who did the practice set may be different people, so it does not follow that most attendees completed it. Nothing links practice-set completers back to the session, and 'most passers completed the set' does not mean every completer passed.

  63. Engineer: "The dam either has a design defect or was built with substandard materials. A design defect typically produces cracks near the base. The cracks appear near the top. Therefore, the dam was built with substandard materials." The engineer's argument relies on which one of the following assumptions?

    • A.A design defect and poor materials cannot both be involved
    • B.Poor materials will always create cracks near the very top
    • C.Top cracks could not plausibly result from a design defect
    • D.The inspector had tested the materials in each dam section
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Top cracks could not plausibly result from a design defect

    The engineer rules out a design defect only because such defects typically crack the base and these cracks are near the top, so the argument relies on top cracks not plausibly resulting from a design defect; if they could, the defect would not be ruled out. The conclusion only says the materials were substandard, so it does not need to deny that both flaws are involved. It also does not need poor materials to always crack the top, and it says nothing about any testing of the materials.

  64. Advertisement: "Our toothpaste is recommended by four out of five dentists. So it is the best toothpaste available." The reasoning is most vulnerable to criticism because it

    • A.appeals to the emotions of shoppers rather than to evidence
    • B.takes a dentist recommendation to show it beats every rival
    • C.treats dentists as experts on a topic beyond their training
    • D.attacks the makers of rival brands rather than their merits
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: takes a dentist recommendation to show it beats every rival

    The ad moves from 'recommended by four out of five dentists' to 'the best toothpaste available', taking a recommendation as proof that it beats every rival; dentists might recommend several brands, or recommend it for reasons that do not make it the best. The ad cites a survey of dentists, so it does not rest on emotional appeal. Toothpaste is within a dentist's expertise, and the ad says nothing about rival makers.

  65. Which one of the following most accurately describes the role played in the argument by the claim that 'the policy reduced emissions in the test region'? Argument: "Critics doubt the emissions policy works. But the policy reduced emissions in the test region. Therefore, expanding it nationally is likely to reduce emissions nationally."

    • A.It is a premise cited in support of the argument's conclusion
    • B.It is the main conclusion that the argument aims to establish
    • C.It is a position the argument describes in order to discredit
    • D.It is an interim conclusion the argument draws from the facts
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: It is a premise cited in support of the argument's conclusion

    The test-region result is a premise cited in support of the conclusion that expanding the policy nationally will likely reduce emissions. That national prediction, not the test result, is the main conclusion the argument aims to establish. The position the argument sets out to discredit is the critics' doubt, and nothing else in the argument supports the test-region claim, so it is not an interim conclusion.

  66. Teacher: "To graduate, a student must complete the thesis. To complete the thesis, a student must have a faculty advisor. Rosa has no faculty advisor." Which one of the following follows logically?

    • A.Rosa has not yet begun writing her own thesis
    • B.Rosa is not going to graduate as things stand
    • C.Rosa will find an advisor in time to graduate
    • D.Rosa may graduate by a route besides a thesis
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Rosa is not going to graduate as things stand

    Graduating requires completing the thesis, and completing it requires a faculty advisor; Rosa has none, so as things stand she is not going to graduate. The premises say nothing about whether she has started writing, only that she cannot complete the thesis. Nothing predicts that she will find an advisor, and the thesis is required for graduation, so no other route is available.

  67. Two scientists discuss a result. Scientist A: "The drug improved memory in the trial, so it should be approved for treating memory loss." Scientist B: "The trial included only healthy young adults, so we cannot yet say the drug helps the elderly patients it is meant to treat." Scientist B responds to Scientist A by

    • A.denying that the drug helped memory among the trial subjects
    • B.doubting that findings in young adults apply to old patients
    • C.asserting that the drug poses safety risks for some patients
    • D.contending that the drug trial enrolled too few young adults
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: doubting that findings in young adults apply to old patients

    Scientist B accepts the trial result but doubts that findings in healthy young adults apply to the older patients the drug is meant for, which challenges the inference rather than the data. B does not deny that the drug helped memory among the subjects, and raises no safety concern. B's complaint is that the trial included only young adults, not that it enrolled too few of them.

  68. Consultant: "Companies that offer remote work attract more applicants. We want to attract more applicants. Therefore, we should offer remote work." Which one of the following, if true, most strengthens this argument?

    • A.Several firms that offer remote work suffer heavy staff turnover
    • B.Remote work has grown far more widespread across many industries
    • C.Remote work would carry no costs outweighing its hiring benefits
    • D.Applicants usually rank salary above the chance to work remotely
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Remote work would carry no costs outweighing its hiring benefits

    The consultant moves from 'remote work attracts applicants' to 'we should offer it', which assumes the benefit is not outweighed; saying remote work would carry no costs outweighing its hiring benefits closes that gap. Heavy turnover at firms that offer remote work points to a cost and weakens the case. How widespread remote work has become and how applicants rank salary do not show that this company should offer it.

  69. Naturalist: "Songbirds in the reserve have declined sharply, yet their primary food source, insects, has become more abundant. How can the birds be declining when food is plentiful?" Which one of the following, if true, best explains this apparent paradox?

    • A.A new predator of songbirds has recently colonized the reserve
    • B.The reserve's insects are now more nutritious than ever before
    • C.Songbirds in an adjacent reserve have also declined in numbers
    • D.Insect-eating bats in the reserve have also become more common
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: A new predator of songbirds has recently colonized the reserve

    A new predator of songbirds in the reserve can drive their numbers down even while food is plentiful, which resolves the paradox. More nutritious insects make the decline harder to explain, not easier. A decline in an adjacent reserve only shows the puzzle exists elsewhere, and more bats competing for insects cannot explain a shortage when insects are more abundant than before.

  70. Which one of the following most accurately states the conclusion of this argument? "The new vaccine produced strong antibody levels in trial participants. Antibody levels are a reliable indicator of protection against the virus. So the vaccine will likely protect recipients from the virus."

    • A.The vaccine will likely protect recipients from the virus
    • B.Antibody levels serve to signal protection from the virus
    • C.The vaccine generated strong antibody levels in the trial
    • D.The trial enrolled a remarkably large group of recipients
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The vaccine will likely protect recipients from the virus

    The word 'so' marks the claim that the vaccine will likely protect recipients as the conclusion. That antibody levels signal protection from the virus and that the vaccine generated strong levels in the trial are the two premises offered in support. The argument never mentions how large the trial group was.

  71. Critic: "This novel must be poorly written. After all, it sold very few copies, and novels that sell well are well written." The critic's argument is flawed because it

    • A.assumes that every novel is written primarily to sell widely
    • B.relies solely upon the judgment of a single unnamed reviewer
    • C.confuses the novel's marketing with the quality of its prose
    • D.treats selling well as a prerequisite for being well written
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: treats selling well as a prerequisite for being well written

    The premise says novels that sell well are well written, which makes good sales enough to show good writing, not a requirement for it. The critic treats selling well as a prerequisite for being well written, concluding from poor sales that the writing is poor, which ignores that a well-written novel might sell poorly. The argument does not assume every novel is written mainly to sell, cites no reviewer, and does not discuss the novel's marketing.

  72. Which one of the following is an example of conditional reasoning correctly applied? Premise: "If the package is fragile, it is marked with a red label. This package is not marked with a red label."

    • A.Therefore, the package in question must be fragile.
    • B.Therefore, the package in question could be fragile.
    • C.Therefore, the package in question cannot be fragile.
    • D.Therefore, the package in question must be mislabeled.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Therefore, the package in question cannot be fragile.

    Being fragile guarantees a red label, so a package with no red label cannot be fragile; this is the contrapositive. Concluding that it must be fragile reverses the logic, and saying it could be fragile ignores that the contrapositive rules this out. Nothing in the premises suggests a labeling error, since an unlabeled package that is not fragile fits the rule perfectly.

  73. Policy analyst: "The proposed law would ban a chemical used in pesticides because the chemical is harmful in high concentrations. But the law would do more harm than good, since the chemical poses no measurable risk at the low concentrations actually used in agriculture, while banning it would sharply reduce crop yields." The analyst's argument proceeds primarily by

    • A.showing that the cited harm is absent under actual conditions
    • B.citing statistics proving the chemical is safe in all amounts
    • C.denying that the chemical would be harmful at greater dosages
    • D.questioning the motives of the officials who proposed the law
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: showing that the cited harm is absent under actual conditions

    The analyst grants that the chemical is harmful in high concentrations but shows that this harm is absent under actual conditions, where it is used at low concentrations, which undercuts the reason for the ban. The analyst cites no statistics and never claims the chemical is safe in all amounts. Far from denying harm at greater dosages, the analyst concedes it, and the motives of those behind the law are never discussed.

  74. Archaeologist: The settlement was abandoned no later than 200 BCE, because no coins minted after that date have been found there, and coins of every prior decade are abundant at the site. The argument's reasoning is most vulnerable to criticism on the grounds that it

    • A.confuses a sufficient condition for leaving with a needed one
    • B.relies on a sample of coins which is unrepresentatively small
    • C.draws a conclusion about the whole region from one settlement
    • D.treats missing later coins as proof that occupation had ended
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: treats missing later coins as proof that occupation had ended

    The archaeologist treats missing post-200 BCE coins as proof that occupation had ended, but people could have stayed on while using older coins, bartering, or leaving no surviving coins. The argument does not turn on sufficient and necessary conditions for leaving. The coins are described as abundant, so the sample is not shown to be small, and the conclusion concerns only this settlement, not the whole region.

  75. Consultant: Firms that hold weekly strategy meetings report higher employee morale than firms that do not. So if our firm begins holding weekly strategy meetings, morale here will improve. Which one of the following is an assumption required by the consultant's argument?

    • A.Meeting firms had high morale well before they began meeting
    • B.Weekly meetings lift morale more than any other work habit
    • C.Each firm with high morale also holds weekly strategy meetings
    • D.Other factors do not wholly explain the meeting firms' morale
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Other factors do not wholly explain the meeting firms' morale

    The consultant moves from a correlation to a causal prediction, so the argument needs the morale difference to owe something to the meetings themselves; if other factors wholly explained it, adopting meetings would change nothing. Saying meeting firms had high morale before they began meeting would undercut the argument, not support it. The claim that meetings beat every other work habit is far stronger than the argument needs, and the claim that every high-morale firm holds meetings is a reversal the argument never relies on.

  76. Curator: This canvas can be authenticated as a genuine Verre only if its pigment contains lead-tin yellow, a compound found in every authenticated Verre. Laboratory analysis confirms the canvas contains lead-tin yellow. Therefore the canvas is a genuine Verre. The reasoning is flawed because it

    • A.treats the lab result as if it were beyond doubt
    • B.treats a precondition for being genuine as settling it
    • C.treats a sure sign of authenticity as just a requirement
    • D.treats its conclusion as if it were among its premises
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: treats a precondition for being genuine as settling it

    The phrase 'only if' makes lead-tin yellow a requirement for authenticity, and the curator treats meeting that requirement as if it settled the question. The argument does the reverse of treating a sure sign as a mere requirement. It takes the lab result as a premise, which is not a reasoning flaw, and its conclusion is not stated among its premises, so it is not circular.

  77. To pass the licensing board, an applicant must complete the clinical hours and also pass the written exam. Dana passed the written exam. From this a reviewer concludes that Dana passed the licensing board. The reviewer's error is best described as

    • A.Treating one of two joint requirements as if it sufficed
    • B.Inferring that an outcome fails since its antecedent is false
    • C.Generalizing from a lone applicant's record to all the applicants
    • D.Assuming within a premise the conclusion it seeks to show
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Treating one of two joint requirements as if it sufficed

    Passing the board requires two things jointly, clinical hours and the written exam, and the reviewer treats one of them as if it alone sufficed. The argument does not infer anything from a false antecedent, so it is not denying the antecedent. It draws a conclusion about Dana only, not about every applicant, and its conclusion does not appear among its premises.

  78. Suppose it is true that no member of the orchestra is permitted to record solo albums. Which one of the following must also be true?

    • A.Some people outside the orchestra may record their solo albums
    • B.Anyone who may record solo albums is outside the orchestra
    • C.Every single person outside the orchestra may record solo albums
    • D.Some members of the orchestra may record their own albums
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Anyone who may record solo albums is outside the orchestra

    'No orchestra member may record solo albums' converts validly: anyone who may record solo albums is outside the orchestra. The statement says nothing about whether anyone outside the orchestra actually has permission, so neither 'some people outside' nor 'every person outside' must be true. Saying some orchestra members may record their own albums does not follow, and if those albums are solo albums it contradicts the original statement.

  79. Hydrologist: When the reservoir is below its safe minimum, the spillway gates are kept closed. Right now the spillway gates are open. Which one of the following can be properly concluded?

    • A.The reservoir is rising past its safe minimum level
    • B.The reservoir is not below its safe minimum level
    • C.The reservoir is far over its safe minimum level
    • D.The reservoir is near its safe maximum level now
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The reservoir is not below its safe minimum level

    The rule says a below-minimum reservoir means closed gates; the gates are open, so by the contrapositive the reservoir is not below its safe minimum. That allows the reservoir to sit exactly at the minimum, so 'far over' the minimum does not follow. Nothing in the statement tells us the level is rising or how it compares with any safe maximum.

  80. Survey analyst: Most residents who attended the town hall favored the new park, and most residents who favored the new park live downtown. Based only on these statements, which one of the following must be true?

    • A.Some town hall attendees favored the new park proposal
    • B.Some town hall attendees live in the downtown district
    • C.Most residents who live downtown favored the new park
    • D.Most town hall attendees live in the downtown district
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Some town hall attendees favored the new park proposal

    Because most town hall attendees favored the park, at least some of them did. The two 'most' statements cannot be chained: the majority who favored the park and the majority of supporters who live downtown need not overlap, so we cannot conclude that any, let alone most, attendees live downtown. The statements also say nothing about what most downtown residents think, since park supporters could be a small share of all downtown residents.

  81. Botanist: Every fern in this greenhouse needs indirect light, and some plants that need indirect light are not ferns. Which one of the following can be properly inferred from these statements?

    • A.Every plant needing indirect light is a greenhouse fern
    • B.Some greenhouse ferns can thrive without any indirect light
    • C.Ferns are a minority of plants needing indirect light
    • D.Some plants that need indirect light are not ferns
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Some plants that need indirect light are not ferns

    The second premise states directly that some plants needing indirect light are not ferns, so that claim can be inferred. Saying every such plant is a fern contradicts that premise, and saying some ferns need no indirect light contradicts the first premise. Nothing tells us how many non-fern plants there are, so we cannot conclude that ferns are a minority.

  82. Epidemiologist: Counties that fluoridated their water saw childhood cavity rates drop sharply over the following decade, so water fluoridation reduces childhood cavities. Which one of the following, if true, most weakens this argument?

    • A.Those counties had more cavities than others before fluoridating
    • B.The equipment for fluoridation in those counties needed upkeep
    • C.Free school dental programs began there that same decade
    • D.Most residents there drank tap water during the decade
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Free school dental programs began there that same decade

    A free school dental program reaching children in the same decade is a rival explanation for the falling cavity rates, so it weakens the claim that fluoridation caused the drop. Higher cavity rates before fluoridation leave the before-and-after drop intact. Equipment upkeep says nothing about effectiveness, and widespread tap-water drinking means more children received fluoride, which if anything supports the argument.

  83. Planner: Adding a dedicated bus lane to Main Street will shorten the average commute, because buses currently lose time stuck behind cars. Which one of the following, if true, most strengthens the planner's argument?

    • A.In like cities, bus lanes cut commutes without slowing cars
    • B.Bus ridership on Main Street has held steady for years
    • C.Many Main Street commuters say they prefer driving over buses
    • D.The planned lane would be painted red to deter cars
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: In like cities, bus lanes cut commutes without slowing cars

    The obvious worry is that giving buses a lane slows cars enough to raise the overall average commute, and evidence from similar cities where bus lanes cut commutes without slowing cars removes that worry. Steady ridership does not show that the lane will save anyone time. Commuters preferring to drive slightly weakens the plan, and painting the lane red to deter cars does not show that commutes will get shorter.

  84. Manager: We should switch to the cheaper supplier. No one on the team has shown that the cheaper supplier delivers lower-quality parts. The manager's reasoning is most vulnerable to criticism because it

    • A.Treats the failure to show lower quality as showing equality
    • B.Confuses a link between price and quality with a cause
    • C.Presumes the team members value low costs over high quality
    • D.Draws a broad conclusion about all suppliers from one case
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Treats the failure to show lower quality as showing equality

    The manager concludes the cheaper parts are fine because no one has shown they are worse, treating the failure to show lower quality as if it showed equal quality. The argument draws no causal link between price and quality. It says nothing about what the team members value, and it generalizes about no supplier beyond the one being considered.

  85. Critic: The novelist's new book is bound to be shallow. After all, she earns most of her income from advertising endorsements rather than from serious literary work. The critic's argument is most vulnerable to criticism on the grounds that it

    • A.Treats a condition necessary for shallowness as if it sufficed
    • B.Judges the book by the author's income, not its content
    • C.Assumes within its premises the conclusion it aims to reach
    • D.Generalizes about all her novels from a single new release
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Judges the book by the author's income, not its content

    The critic judges the book by how the author earns her income, which has nothing to do with the book's content; that is an attack on the source, not the work. No conditional relationship about shallowness is stated, so there is no necessary condition being treated as sufficient. The conclusion is not assumed in the premises, and the critic makes a claim about one new book, not about all her novels.

  86. Geologist: This basin must have once held a lake, since its floor is lined with fine clay, and clay of this kind is deposited only in standing water. Which one of the following, if assumed, allows the conclusion to be properly drawn?

    • A.The basin's clay was laid down in place, not washed in
    • B.Standing water always leaves a layer of fine clay behind it
    • C.Most basins of similar size and age once held a lake
    • D.Fine clay of this kind is rarer than any coarse sediment
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The basin's clay was laid down in place, not washed in

    The clay proves standing water only if it settled where it now lies; clay washed in from elsewhere would say nothing about this basin, so assuming it was laid down in place makes the conclusion follow. Saying standing water always leaves clay reverses the needed conditional. What most similar basins once held cannot guarantee anything about this basin, and how rare fine clay is has no bearing on where it formed.

  87. Editorial board member: A city ordinance is just only if it applies equally to wealthy and poor residents. The proposed curfew applies equally to wealthy and poor residents, so it is just. The reasoning is questionable because it

    • A.Assumes that the curfew is going to be enforced fairly
    • B.Treats a requirement of justice as if it ensured justice
    • C.Uses the word 'just' in two different senses at once
    • D.Draws a sweeping conclusion about city laws from one ordinance
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Treats a requirement of justice as if it ensured justice

    The board member's premise makes equal application a requirement for justice ('only if'), yet the conclusion treats meeting that one requirement as if it ensured justice. The argument says nothing about how the curfew will be enforced. 'Just' keeps the same meaning throughout, and the conclusion concerns only this one curfew, not city laws in general.

  88. Advocate: The library should extend its weekend hours. Doing so would serve students who work weekday jobs, cost little given existing staff, and respond to repeated patron requests. Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main conclusion of the advocate's argument?

    • A.Longer weekend hours would serve students with weekday jobs
    • B.Longer weekend hours would cost little given existing staff
    • C.Many patrons have repeatedly asked for longer weekend hours
    • D.The library ought to lengthen its weekend opening schedules
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The library ought to lengthen its weekend opening schedules

    The advocate's main conclusion is the recommendation that the library extend its weekend hours. Serving students with weekday jobs, costing little given existing staff, and repeated patron requests are the three reasons offered for that recommendation, so each is a premise rather than the conclusion.

  89. Teacher: Reducing class sizes would improve test scores, the union claims. But smaller classes require hiring more teachers, and the district has no money to do so. The teacher responds to the union's claim by

    • A.Denying that smaller classes would raise students' test scores
    • B.Noting that the district cannot afford the proposed change
    • C.Questioning the reasons the union is advancing its proposal
    • D.Offering a counterexample to the union's claim about scores
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Noting that the district cannot afford the proposed change

    The teacher does not dispute the union's claim; the teacher notes that the district cannot afford the extra teachers smaller classes would need, so the response is about feasibility. The teacher never denies that smaller classes would raise scores and never offers a counterexample to that claim. The union's reasons for proposing the change are not discussed at all.

  90. Speaker X: The downtown plaza should be converted into a parking garage, because the neighborhood badly needs more parking. Speaker Y: The neighborhood actually has hundreds of unused spaces in existing lots every evening. The point at issue between Speaker X and Speaker Y is whether

    • A.The plaza gets enough daily use to justify keeping
    • B.A parking garage would be an attractive downtown structure
    • C.Drivers would rather use garages than open surface lots
    • D.The neighborhood really needs more parking than it has
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The neighborhood really needs more parking than it has

    Speaker X's case rests on the neighborhood needing more parking, and Speaker Y replies with hundreds of empty evening spaces, so they disagree about whether there is a parking shortage. Neither speaker says how much the plaza is used, whether a garage would look attractive, or whether drivers prefer garages to surface lots.

  91. Astronomer: This star is a red giant. All red giants have exhausted the hydrogen in their cores. Therefore this star has exhausted the hydrogen in its core. In the argument, the statement that all red giants have exhausted the hydrogen in their cores functions as

    • A.An objection that the argument goes on to reject
    • B.The main conclusion that the argument aims to establish
    • C.A general premise that works with a specific observation
    • D.A subsidiary conclusion drawn from the first stated claim
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: A general premise that works with a specific observation

    The general statement about all red giants works with the specific observation that this star is a red giant, and together they yield the conclusion. It is not the main conclusion, which is the claim about this particular star. It is not a subsidiary conclusion drawn from anything, since nothing supports it, and the argument raises no objection to reject.

  92. Argument: If the bridge inspection had passed, the road would have reopened by noon. The road did not reopen by noon. So the inspection did not pass. Which one of the following arguments is most similar in its reasoning to the argument above?

    • A.If the alarm is set, it rings. It is unset, so it will not ring
    • B.If the dough was kneaded, it stretches. It does not, so it was not kneaded
    • C.If the seed has sprouted, a stem shows. A stem shows, so it has sprouted
    • D.If the box shipped, it comes on Friday. It has shipped, so it comes then
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: If the dough was kneaded, it stretches. It does not, so it was not kneaded

    The original argument is valid contrapositive reasoning: if passed, then reopened; not reopened, so not passed. The dough argument has the same form: if kneaded, then it stretches; it does not stretch, so it was not kneaded. The alarm argument denies the antecedent, and the seed argument affirms the consequent, both invalid. The shipping argument is valid but affirms the antecedent, a different form.

  93. Pundit: The challenger's tax plan will surely fail, because the last challenger who promised tax cuts lost the election. Which one of the following contains reasoning most similar to the flawed reasoning in the pundit's argument?

    • A.Every strand in this bundle is copper, so the strand removed is copper too
    • B.This recipe requires two cups of flour, so a half batch requires one cup
    • C.The last mayor to raise fees lost, so this mayor raising fees will lose
    • D.No critic has yet disproved the theory, so the theory must surely be correct
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The last mayor to raise fees lost, so this mayor raising fees will lose

    The pundit predicts failure because an earlier figure who shared one feature failed, and the mayor argument does the same: the last mayor to raise fees lost, so this fee-raising mayor will lose. The copper-wire argument is valid reasoning from a rule to a case, and the flour argument is valid proportional reasoning. The theory argument is flawed in a different way, treating a lack of disproof as proof.

  94. Lab technician: This water sample tested positive for the marker compound. The marker compound is present in a sample only if the sample was drawn downstream of the plant. Which one of the following must be true?

    • A.Every sample drawn downstream of the plant will test positive
    • B.No sample drawn upstream of the plant has any compound
    • C.This sample was drawn from somewhere downstream of the plant
    • D.The plant itself releases the marker compound into the water
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: This sample was drawn from somewhere downstream of the plant

    'Only if' makes being drawn downstream a requirement for the marker, so a positive sample must have come from downstream water. The statement does not say every downstream sample tests positive, since a requirement is not a guarantee. It also does not rule out other compounds in upstream samples, and it never says who or what releases the marker.

  95. Argument: Whenever the night frost is severe, the citrus blossoms drop. The blossoms have not dropped. Which one of the following CANNOT be true?

    • A.A severe wind swept across the orchard last night
    • B.A light frost settled on the orchard last night
    • C.The frost the trees endured last night was severe
    • D.The orchard was watered a day before last night
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The frost the trees endured last night was severe

    A severe frost always makes the blossoms drop, and they have not dropped, so last night's frost cannot have been severe. A severe wind, a light frost, or watering a day earlier are all consistent with the blossoms staying on the trees, so any of them could be true.

  96. Argument: We can trust the audit because it was performed by the most reputable firm in the city, and we know the firm is reputable because it would never approve a flawed audit like this one. The argument is flawed because it

    • A.Supports each of two claims solely by appeal to the other
    • B.Mistakes a mere link between two events for a causal one
    • C.Draws a broad claim about all audits from a single case
    • D.Relies on the judgment of one firm rather than of many
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Supports each of two claims solely by appeal to the other

    The argument trusts the audit because of the firm's reputation, then defends the reputation by assuming this audit is sound, so each claim is supported only by the other. No correlation is treated as a cause. The argument reaches no conclusion about audits in general, and relying on one firm is not the problem, since the trouble is that its support runs in a circle.

  97. Apparent puzzle: A coffee shop raised the price of its house blend, expecting sales of that blend to fall. Instead, sales of the house blend rose the following month. Which one of the following, if true, most helps to resolve the discrepancy?

    • A.Buyers took the higher price as a sign of quality
    • B.A nearby competitor lowered the prices of all its coffees
    • C.The shop's total number of customers fell during that month
    • D.The house blend had been the shop's least popular coffee
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Buyers took the higher price as a sign of quality

    If customers took the higher price as a sign of better quality, demand for the blend could rise, which explains why sales went up. A competitor cutting its prices would make the jump harder to explain, as would a drop in total customers. The blend's past unpopularity gives no reason why a price increase would raise its sales.

  98. Principle: A reviewer should call a film 'derivative' only if the reviewer can name an earlier film it closely copies. Which one of the following judgments conforms most closely to this principle?

    • A.Reyes called the thriller derivative, since thrillers are so common
    • B.Vega called the thriller derivative after noting its low budget
    • C.Wells called the thriller derivative of films he can't name
    • D.Tan called the thriller derivative, naming the film it copies
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Tan called the thriller derivative, naming the film it copies

    The principle allows the label 'derivative' only when the reviewer can name an earlier film the movie closely copies, and Tan both uses the label and names the copied film. Reyes and Vega use the label for reasons unrelated to copying. Wells uses it while unable to name any film, which is exactly what the principle forbids.

  99. Argument: This wine cannot be a true ice wine, because true ice wines are pressed from grapes frozen on the vine, and these grapes were frozen in a commercial freezer. Which one of the following is required for the argument's conclusion to follow?

    • A.Ice wines always cost more than any wine from other grapes
    • B.Industrial freezers get grapes as cold as frost on a vine
    • C.Grapes put in a commercial freezer were not frozen on vines
    • D.Freezing method is the sole factor in classing any given wine
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Grapes put in a commercial freezer were not frozen on vines

    True ice wine requires grapes frozen on the vine, so the conclusion follows only if the freezer-frozen grapes were not frozen on vines. How cold a freezer gets does not matter, because the requirement is about where the grapes froze, not how cold they got. Cost is irrelevant, and the argument does not need freezing method to be the only factor in classifying wine, since failing one requirement is enough.

  100. Argument: Adding a sufficient assumption should make a conclusion follow with certainty. A debate coach claims that adding the statement 'every student who attends the workshop will pass the mock trial' guarantees the conclusion 'Lena will pass the mock trial.' For that to be a sufficient assumption, the argument's stated premise must be that

    • A.Most students who attend the workshop pass the mock trial
    • B.Passing the mock trial requires that one attend the workshop
    • C.Lena has passed every mock trial she has entered before
    • D.Lena is among those students who are attending this workshop
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Lena is among those students who are attending this workshop

    Combined with 'every student who attends the workshop will pass,' the premise that Lena is attending the workshop guarantees that she passes. 'Most attendees pass' leaves room for Lena to fail. A rule that passing requires attending runs in the wrong direction, and Lena's past results cannot make the conclusion certain.

  101. Argument: People who drink green tea daily report fewer afternoon energy crashes than people who do not. So drinking green tea daily prevents afternoon energy crashes. Which one of the following points to a flaw in this reasoning?

    • A.Afternoon energy crashes are hard to measure with real precision
    • B.Some brands of green tea contain more caffeine than others
    • C.Many people who try green tea strongly dislike its taste
    • D.Daily tea drinkers also tend to sleep at regular times
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Daily tea drinkers also tend to sleep at regular times

    The argument infers causation from a correlation, and a rival factor such as regular sleep among daily tea drinkers could explain both the habit and the fewer crashes. Measurement difficulty applies to both groups and does not explain the gap. Differences in caffeine between brands and dislike of the taste do not show that something other than tea is preventing the crashes.

  102. What does an LSAT 'evaluate the argument' question ask the test-taker to do?

    • A.Find the statement that must be true given the stimulus
    • B.Find the question whose answer bears on the argument's force
    • C.Find the persuasive technique the author employs to win readers
    • D.Find the claim that, if added, would guarantee the conclusion
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Find the question whose answer bears on the argument's force

    An evaluate question asks for the question whose answer bears on the argument's force: one answer would strengthen it and the other would weaken it. Finding what must be true is an inference task. Finding a claim that guarantees the conclusion is a sufficient-assumption task, and finding the persuasive technique is a method-of-reasoning task.

  103. Which one of the following best describes the task in an LSAT 'flaw in the reasoning' question?

    • A.Name the error keeping the premises from proving the conclusion
    • B.Name the premise that, if added, would prove the conclusion
    • C.Name the fact that would make the conclusion more probable
    • D.Name the unstated premise that the conclusion silently depends on
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Name the error keeping the premises from proving the conclusion

    A flaw question asks you to name the error that keeps the premises from establishing the conclusion, usually in abstract terms such as treating a necessary condition as sufficient. Naming a premise that would prove the conclusion is a sufficient-assumption task, and naming a fact that makes the conclusion more probable is a strengthen task. Naming an unstated premise the conclusion depends on is a necessary-assumption task.

  104. Argument: A novel deserves the prize only if it shows originality. The judges agreed that this novel shows striking originality, so the judges should award it the prize. The reasoning is most vulnerable to criticism because it

    • A.Treats originality as sufficient when it is merely required
    • B.Appeals to the novel's popularity among its many readers
    • C.Relies on the subjective impressions of the prize judges
    • D.Treats what guarantees the prize as merely a requirement
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Treats originality as sufficient when it is merely required

    'Only if' makes originality a requirement for the prize, yet the argument treats originality as sufficient to win. It never does the reverse of treating a guarantee as a mere requirement. It does not mention the novel's popularity with readers, and relying on the judges' agreement is not the flaw, since the gap remains even if they are right about originality.

  105. Argument: Surveys mailed to our gym's members showed that 95 percent rate the facility excellent, so the community clearly views our gym favorably. The argument's reasoning is most flawed because it

    • A.Concludes that a claim holds because nobody has refuted it
    • B.Uses the word 'favorably' in two different senses at once
    • C.Treats the gym's own members as typical of the community
    • D.Assumes that an excellent facility is what causes high ratings
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Treats the gym's own members as typical of the community

    The survey went only to the gym's own members, who are likely to rate it more highly than the wider community, so treating them as typical of the community is the flaw. The argument does not rely on any claim going unrefuted. 'Favorably' keeps one meaning throughout, and the argument makes no claim about why members rate the facility highly.

  106. Argument: Many commuters believe the new express train is slower than the old local train. But the express makes fewer stops, runs on a dedicated track, and arrives ten minutes earlier on average. So the belief that the express is slower is mistaken. Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main conclusion of the argument?

    • A.The express train stops at fewer stations than the local
    • B.Commuters who believe the express is slower are in error
    • C.The express train arrives about ten minutes earlier on average
    • D.The express train runs on its own dedicated rail track
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Commuters who believe the express is slower are in error

    The main conclusion is that commuters who believe the express is slower are wrong. The fewer stops, the dedicated track, and the arrival about ten minutes earlier on average are the evidence offered for that conclusion, so each is a premise.

  107. Anyone admitted to the honors program must maintain a high grade average, and anyone who maintains a high grade average is invited to the awards dinner. Priya was admitted to the honors program. Which one of the following must be true?

    • A.Priya keeps a high average but is not invited
    • B.Priya is among those invited to the awards dinner
    • C.Only honors students ever keep a high grade average
    • D.Each person invited to the dinner is in honors
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Priya is among those invited to the awards dinner

    Priya was admitted to honors, so she keeps a high average, and anyone with a high average is invited to the dinner, so she is invited. Saying she keeps a high average yet is not invited contradicts the second rule. Claiming that only honors students keep a high average, or that each person invited is in honors, reverses the given conditionals.

  108. Which one of the following best describes what 'formal logic' tests on the LSAT, as opposed to substantive content?

    • A.The clarity and precision of an author's style of writing
    • B.The force of an argument's appeals to a reader's emotions
    • C.The accuracy of the actual facts that a stimulus cites
    • D.The validity of inferences that rest on a statement's form
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The validity of inferences that rest on a statement's form

    Formal logic on the LSAT tests whether inferences are valid given the form of the statements involved, such as conditionals and quantifiers like all, some, and most, whatever the topic. It does not assess an author's writing style or emotional appeals. It also does not ask whether real-world facts are accurate, since the premises are accepted as given.

  109. Argument: A treaty is binding only if both nations ratify it. The eastern nation ratified the treaty. Therefore the treaty is binding. The flaw in this argument is that it

    • A.Treats one ratification as if both nations had ratified it
    • B.Appeals to the authority of the legislature that ratified it
    • C.Assumes without warrant that the treaty is fair to everyone
    • D.Relies on a single treaty as evidence about treaties generally
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Treats one ratification as if both nations had ratified it

    The treaty is binding only if both nations ratify, but the argument cites one ratification and treats it as if both nations had ratified. No legislature's authority is invoked. The argument makes no assumption about whether the treaty is fair, and it draws no conclusion about treaties in general.

  110. Argument: Most volunteers at the shelter have completed first-aid training, and everyone who has completed first-aid training carries a certification card. Which one of the following can be properly inferred?

    • A.Every volunteer at the shelter carries a certification card
    • B.Only volunteers at the shelter hold a certification card
    • C.Everyone with a certification card volunteers at the shelter
    • D.Most volunteers at the shelter carry a certification card
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Most volunteers at the shelter carry a certification card

    Most volunteers completed first-aid training, and everyone with that training carries a card, so at least those same volunteers, a majority, carry a card. The premises do not reach every volunteer, since some may lack the training. They also do not limit cards to volunteers or say that every cardholder volunteers, since trained people outside the shelter can carry cards too.

  111. Argument: A scholarship is merited only if the applicant demonstrates financial need. This applicant has clearly demonstrated financial need. So this applicant merits the scholarship. Which one of the following is an assumption necessary for the conclusion to follow?

    • A.Most applicants who show financial need receive the scholarship
    • B.The scholarship fund has enough money for this applicant
    • C.The applicant meets every other requirement the scholarship sets
    • D.Financial need is the scholarship's single most important requirement
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The applicant meets every other requirement the scholarship sets

    Financial need is only one requirement ('only if'), so concluding that the applicant merits the scholarship requires that the applicant also meet every other requirement the scholarship sets. Whether most needy applicants receive it, whether the fund has enough money, or how financial need ranks against other requirements has no bearing on whether this applicant merits it.

  112. Chef: Our restaurant's revenue rose 15 percent after we added the new dessert menu. The dessert menu is clearly responsible for the increase. Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the chef's argument?

    • A.At the same time a new ad campaign doubled the restaurant's weeknight diners.
    • B.Dessert sales account for most of the increased revenue since the menu began.
    • C.A neighboring restaurant that added a dessert menu also saw its revenue rise.
    • D.The desserts were designed by a pastry chef recruited from a renowned bakery.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: At the same time a new ad campaign doubled the restaurant's weeknight diners.

    An ad campaign that doubled weeknight diners at the same time is another cause for the 15 percent rise, which weakens the claim that the desserts were responsible. If dessert sales made up most of the new revenue, that would support the chef. A neighbor's revenue rising after it added desserts also points toward desserts as the cause. Who designed the desserts says nothing about what drove the increase.

  113. To receive the scholarship, an applicant must submit a portfolio and also pass an interview. Devon submitted a portfolio. Which one of the following can be properly inferred?

    • A.If Devon fails the interview, Devon will not receive the scholarship.
    • B.If Devon passes the interview, Devon will surely win the scholarship.
    • C.Devon has by now passed the interview which the scholarship requires.
    • D.Anyone who passes the interview will then be awarded the scholarship.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: If Devon fails the interview, Devon will not receive the scholarship.

    Passing the interview is a necessary condition, so failing it rules out the scholarship whatever else Devon has done. The rule lists requirements, not a guarantee, so passing does not ensure Devon wins. Nothing says Devon has taken or passed the interview. And the rule never makes passing the interview enough for anyone.

  114. Columnist: The city's recycling program must be ineffective, because the amount of waste sent to landfills has not decreased since the program began. The argument is most vulnerable to the criticism that it overlooks the possibility that:

    • A.most residents backed the recycling plan when it was first launched
    • B.landfill waste had been holding steady for years before the program
    • C.other cities with similar programs saw no decline in landfill waste
    • D.garbage bound for dumps would have soared had recycling never begun
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: garbage bound for dumps would have soared had recycling never begun

    Flat landfill totals are consistent with an effective program if waste would otherwise have grown, and the columnist never considers that. Resident support says nothing about whether the program works. Waste that was already steady before the program would fit the columnist's conclusion rather than expose a gap in it. Similar flat results in other cities would add to the case for ineffectiveness, not answer it.

  115. All of the paintings in the east gallery are landscapes, and none of the landscapes in the museum are for sale. Which one of the following must be true?

    • A.Each landscape in the museum is in the east gallery.
    • B.No painting in the east gallery is offered for sale.
    • C.Every painting which is not for sale is a landscape.
    • D.Every painting in the museum is in fact a landscape.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: No painting in the east gallery is offered for sale.

    Every east-gallery painting is a landscape and no landscape is for sale, so no east-gallery painting is for sale. The premises do not put every landscape in the east gallery; that reverses the first statement. Paintings not for sale could include works that are not landscapes. And nothing says the museum holds only landscapes.

  116. Nutritionist: People who eat breakfast tend to weigh less than people who skip it. Therefore, skipping breakfast causes weight gain. Which one of the following, if true, most undermines the nutritionist's reasoning?

    • A.Those who skip breakfast tend to eat larger lunches than breakfast eaters do.
    • B.The weight gap between these two groups also appears in many other countries.
    • C.Most of the breakfast eaters surveyed reported that they eat cereal or fruit.
    • D.People who already weigh more often skip breakfast in hopes of losing weight.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: People who already weigh more often skip breakfast in hopes of losing weight.

    If heavier people skip breakfast to lose weight, the weight may cause the skipping rather than the reverse, which undercuts the causal conclusion. Larger lunches among skippers would suggest a way skipping could cause gain, which helps the nutritionist. A gap that shows up in many countries strengthens the correlation. What breakfast eaters eat says nothing about which way the cause runs.

  117. If the experiment is valid, then its results can be replicated. The results of this experiment cannot be replicated. Which one of the following can be properly concluded?

    • A.Any replicable test is valid.
    • B.This experiment is not valid.
    • C.Its hypothesis must be false.
    • D.Its figures must be mistaken.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: This experiment is not valid.

    Validity requires replicable results, and these results cannot be replicated, so the experiment is not valid. Saying any replicable test is valid reverses the conditional. An invalid experiment tells us nothing either way about its hypothesis, so the hypothesis need not be false. And the premises never say why replication failed, so nothing shows that its figures were mistaken.

  118. Editorial: We should not adopt the proposed traffic plan, because the consultant who designed it once worked for a company that builds toll roads. The editorial's reasoning is most vulnerable to which one of the following criticisms?

    • A.It assumes that the conclusion it sets out to demonstrate is already true.
    • B.It treats a condition needed for success as one that alone brings success.
    • C.It rejects the plan because of its designer's past rather than its merits.
    • D.It draws a broad conclusion about each traffic plan from a single example.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: It rejects the plan because of its designer's past rather than its merits.

    The editorial dismisses the plan because its designer once worked for a toll-road company, attacking the source instead of the proposal. Its premise is about the consultant, not a restatement of its conclusion, so it is not circular. No necessary or sufficient condition appears in the argument. And it draws no general conclusion about traffic plans; it rejects this one plan only.

  119. Some employees in the marketing department speak French. All employees who speak French attended the international training. Which one of the following must be true?

    • A.Every member of the marketing department attended the training.
    • B.Some marketing personnel were present at that training session.
    • C.Every French-speaking person at the company works in marketing.
    • D.All staff who attended the international training speak French.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Some marketing personnel were present at that training session.

    The marketing employees who speak French all attended the training, so at least some marketing employees attended. The premises cover only the French speakers, so not every member of the department must have gone. Only some marketing employees are said to speak French; French speakers elsewhere in the company are not ruled out. And the premises never say that only French speakers attended the training.

  120. Researcher: Our new teaching method must work, since every school that adopted it saw test scores rise. Which one of the following, if true, would most strengthen the researcher's argument?

    • A.The method costs less to implement than most other teaching methods now used.
    • B.Comparable schools lacking the method saw no rise in scores over that period.
    • C.Teachers at the adopting schools said they liked working with the new method.
    • D.Schools adopted the method in the very year that state funding was increased.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Comparable schools lacking the method saw no rise in scores over that period.

    If comparable schools without the method saw no rise over the same period, a general cause is less likely and the method looks responsible. Low cost and teachers' liking for the method say nothing about whether it raised scores. A funding increase in the adoption year offers a rival explanation, which weakens rather than strengthens the argument.

  121. A contract is enforceable only if it is supported by consideration. The agreement between Ana and Lee is not supported by consideration. Which one of the following follows logically?

    • A.The agreement reached by Ana and Lee is unenforceable as written.
    • B.The agreement could be enforced if consideration was added to it.
    • C.Any contract with consideration behind it can be enforced by law.
    • D.Neither Ana nor Lee intended the agreement to be legally binding.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The agreement reached by Ana and Lee is unenforceable as written.

    Only if marks consideration as necessary, so an agreement without it cannot be enforced. A necessary condition is not a sufficient one, so adding consideration would not by itself make the agreement enforceable, and having consideration does not make every contract enforceable. The premises say nothing about what Ana and Lee intended.

  122. Advertisement: More doctors choose Brand Z pain reliever than any other brand, so Brand Z must be the most effective pain reliever. The advertisement's reasoning is flawed because it:

    • A.It draws its conclusion from a sample of physicians that is clearly too limited
    • B.It contradicts one of its own premises in the course of reaching its conclusion
    • C.It appeals to the emotions of patients instead of offering evidence of any kind
    • D.It treats doctors' preference for a brand as evidence that the brand works best
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: It treats doctors' preference for a brand as evidence that the brand works best

    Doctors may choose Brand Z for cost, habit, or availability, so being chosen most often does not show it works best; the ad treats that preference as evidence of effectiveness. No sample is described, so it cannot be faulted as too limited. The premise and conclusion do not contradict each other. And the ad does offer evidence, the doctors' choices, rather than an emotional appeal.

  123. If a flight is delayed by weather, passengers are not entitled to compensation. Flight 88 was delayed, and its passengers are entitled to compensation. Which one of the following can be properly inferred?

    • A.The weather played no part in Flight 88's delay.
    • B.Passengers on any late flight are owed a refund.
    • C.Flight 88 was held up by a mechanical breakdown.
    • D.A weather delay can get its passengers a refund.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The weather played no part in Flight 88's delay.

    A weather delay rules out compensation, and Flight 88's passengers are entitled to it, so weather played no part in the delay. The premises do not say every late flight brings compensation. They rule out weather but never name the real cause, so a mechanical breakdown is unsupported. And the rule says a weather delay never earns compensation.

  124. Two commentators disagree. Commentator One: The economy improved because the new trade policy took effect. Commentator Two: That cannot be right, since the economy also improved in the year before the policy existed. Commentator Two responds to Commentator One by:

    • A.arguing that the new trade policy actually slowed the economy's growth
    • B.casting doubt on whether Commentator One knows very much about finance
    • C.citing a case where the improvement happened without the alleged cause
    • D.citing a well-known economist who rejects the arguments for the policy
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: citing a case where the improvement happened without the alleged cause

    Commentator Two points out that the economy improved before the policy existed, a case of the effect without the alleged cause. Two never says the policy hurt growth. No doubt is cast on Commentator One's knowledge. And Two relies on the record of the prior year, not on any economist's authority.

  125. Every novel shortlisted for the prize was published this year. Some books published this year are translations. Which one of the following could be true but need not be true?

    • A.Every shortlisted novel was published this year.
    • B.No translated editions were published this year.
    • C.Some of the shortlisted novels are translations.
    • D.Some shortlisted novels were released last year.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Some of the shortlisted novels are translations.

    The shortlist comes from this year's books and some of those are translations, so an overlap is possible but not required. That every shortlisted novel was published this year is a premise, so it must be true and fails the need-not-be-true condition. No translations this year contradicts the second premise. And a shortlisted novel from last year contradicts the first.

  126. Manager: Productivity rose after we installed standing desks, so the standing desks improved productivity. Which one of the following questions would be most useful to answer in evaluating the manager's argument?

    • A.How much did the company end up paying for every standing desk?
    • B.Do most employees say they would rather stand than sit at work?
    • C.Were other changes such as new deadlines made at the same time?
    • D.Do rival firms plan to order the same standing desks next year?
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Were other changes such as new deadlines made at the same time?

    If other changes such as new deadlines arrived along with the desks, they could explain the productivity rise, so the answer bears directly on the causal claim. What the desks cost does not affect whether they raised productivity. Employees' preference for standing is not evidence about their output. Other firms' plans say nothing about what happened at this workplace.

  127. No reptiles are warm-blooded. All mammals are warm-blooded. Which one of the following must be true?

    • A.Each warm-blooded animal is a mammal.
    • B.No mammal belongs among the reptiles.
    • C.Some reptiles are classed as mammals.
    • D.Any cold-blooded animal is a reptile.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: No mammal belongs among the reptiles.

    Every mammal is warm-blooded and no reptile is, so nothing is both, and no mammal belongs among the reptiles. The premises never say only mammals are warm-blooded, so that converse fails. A reptile that is a mammal would have to be both warm-blooded and not, which is impossible. And reptiles not being warm-blooded does not make every cold-blooded animal a reptile.

  128. Politician: My opponent's healthcare plan is unworkable, because no plan that raises taxes has ever succeeded in this state. The argument depends on which one of the following assumptions?

    • A.The politician's own plan would not raise any taxes in the state.
    • B.Most voters in this state oppose any plan that would raise taxes.
    • C.Every plan that has cut taxes in the state has proven successful.
    • D.The opponent's plan is one that would lead to higher tax burdens.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The opponent's plan is one that would lead to higher tax burdens.

    The generalization about tax-raising plans applies to the opponent's plan only if that plan raises taxes, so the argument depends on it. The politician's own plan plays no role in the reasoning. Voter opinion is never part of the argument. And the argument concerns plans that raise taxes; whether tax-cutting plans succeeded does not matter to it.

  129. Apparent puzzle: A bookstore moved its bestsellers from the front window to the back of the store, expecting sales of those titles to drop. Instead, sales of the bestsellers rose. Which one of the following, if true, best resolves this surprising result?

    • A.The bestsellers received a much larger display at the back than in the window.
    • B.After the move the bestsellers were sold at exactly the same prices as before.
    • C.The store cut its ad spending for the bestsellers during that very same month.
    • D.Many of the shop's regulars say they look at the front window before entering.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The bestsellers received a much larger display at the back than in the window.

    A much larger display at the back would make the bestsellers more visible than before, which explains why their sales rose after the move. Unchanged prices leave the rise unexplained. Less ad spending on the bestsellers would make the rise more surprising. And shoppers checking the front window first suggests the move should have hurt sales, which deepens the puzzle.

  130. If a candidate is endorsed by the union, then the candidate supports the wage proposal. Candidate Reyes does not support the wage proposal. Which one of the following must be true?

    • A.Any backer of the proposal is union-endorsed.
    • B.Reyes opposes every measure the union favors.
    • C.Reyes has not gained the union's endorsement.
    • D.The union itself supports this wage proposal.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Reyes has not gained the union's endorsement.

    Union endorsement guarantees support for the wage proposal, and Reyes does not support it, so Reyes has not been endorsed. The premise does not say every backer of the proposal is endorsed; that reverses it. Nothing says Reyes opposes other measures the union favors. And the premises describe endorsed candidates, not the union's own position on the proposal.

  131. Critic: The symphony's recent concerts have sold out every night, so the orchestra must be playing better than ever. Which one of the following exhibits the most similar flawed reasoning?

    • A.The novel topped every bestseller list, so it must be the finest novel this decade.
    • B.The bakery sells out every morning, so it must bake more loaves than nearby rivals.
    • C.Every student passed the final exam, so the grading must have been far too lenient.
    • D.The arena sold out every night, so the season's ticket prices must have been cheap.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The novel topped every bestseller list, so it must be the finest novel this decade.

    The critic infers quality from popularity, and so does the claim that the best-selling novel must be the finest of the decade. The bakery case infers output, not quality, from selling out. The exam case infers lenient grading from results, which is not a judgment of quality from popularity. The arena case infers a cause, cheap tickets, rather than superior quality.

  132. Survey: Among people who visited the new park, 80 percent said they exercise regularly. The park planner concluded that building the park caused people to exercise more. Which one of the following, if true, most weakens this conclusion?

    • A.The new park has walking trails as well as several outdoor fitness stations.
    • B.Citywide exercise rates rose slightly in the year after the new park opened.
    • C.Most of the surveyed visitors live within easy walking distance of the park.
    • D.People who already exercise regularly are much likelier to visit a new park.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: People who already exercise regularly are much likelier to visit a new park.

    If regular exercisers are the ones who visit parks, the 80 percent reflects who came, not what the park caused, which weakens the conclusion. Trails and fitness stations would, if anything, support the planner. A citywide rise after the opening also leans toward the planner. Visitors living nearby says nothing about whether the park changed their habits.

  133. All certified guides have completed the wilderness course, and anyone who has completed the wilderness course knows basic first aid. Which one of the following must be true?

    • A.Anyone knowing basic first aid is certified.
    • B.Each certified guide knows simple first aid.
    • C.Some certified guides never took the course.
    • D.Only certified guides have taken the course.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Each certified guide knows simple first aid.

    Certified guides all completed the course and everyone who completed it knows first aid, so every certified guide knows basic first aid. The premises do not say that only certified guides know first aid, so the reversed claim fails. A guide who never took the course contradicts the first premise. And nothing limits the course to certified guides.

  134. Scientist: Sea levels and global temperatures have both risen over the past century. Therefore, rising temperatures cause sea levels to rise. The reasoning is most vulnerable to criticism on the ground that it:

    • A.rests its conclusion on the claim of an unnamed expert
    • B.presumes the very conclusion that it sets out to prove
    • C.treats a condition an outcome needs as one ensuring it
    • D.infers a cause just from two trends that rose together
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: infers a cause just from two trends that rose together

    The scientist sees sea levels and temperatures rising together and concludes that one causes the other, without ruling out coincidence or a shared cause. No expert is cited, so reliance on an unnamed authority is not the problem. The conclusion does not appear among the premises, so the argument is not circular, and no conditional is stated, so there is no confusion of necessary and sufficient conditions.

  135. For a building to be designated historic, it must be at least 75 years old and architecturally significant. The Carlton Building is 120 years old. Which one of the following can be properly concluded?

    • A.If the Carlton Building lacks any real architectural significance, it cannot be designated historic.
    • B.If the Carlton Building clearly has architectural significance, then it will be designated historic.
    • C.If the Carlton Building were sixty and architecturally significant, it could be designated historic.
    • D.If the Carlton Building is designated historic, its longevity will have satisfied both requirements.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: If the Carlton Building lacks any real architectural significance, it cannot be designated historic.

    Age of at least 75 years and architectural significance are each required, so without significance the building cannot be designated, whatever its age. The requirements are stated as necessary, not sufficient, so having significance does not guarantee designation. A sixty-year-old building would fail the age requirement even if significant, and age can never satisfy the separate significance requirement.

  136. Advocate: The town should fund the new community center, because residents overwhelmingly want better recreation options. Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the advocate's argument?

    • A.Most residents surveyed said they would use the new center once a week.
    • B.A similar center in a neighboring town has been active since it opened.
    • C.The county would cover a portion of the costs of building the facility.
    • D.Funding it will force the town to cut recreation aid people value more.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Funding it will force the town to cut recreation aid people value more.

    The advocate's reason is that residents want better recreation options. If paying for the center means cutting recreation aid that people value more, the town ends up with worse recreation by the residents' own standard, which undercuts the argument. Heavy expected use, a busy center nearby, and county help with costs all make the proposal look better, so none of them weakens it.

  137. Either the package was lost or it was delivered to the wrong address. If it was delivered to the wrong address, the tracking system would show a completed delivery. The tracking system does not show a completed delivery. Which one of the following must be true?

    • A.The package reached the right address.
    • B.The tracking information was in error.
    • C.The package was lost during transport.
    • D.The package reached the wrong address.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The package was lost during transport.

    If the package had gone to the wrong address, tracking would show a completed delivery. It does not, so the wrong-address possibility is ruled out, and because the package was either lost or misdelivered, it was lost. Reaching the right address is not one of the two possibilities the premises allow, and nothing in the premises says the tracking system made or logged any error.

  138. Botanist: This soil sample must be acidic, because the only plants growing in it are species that thrive in acidic soil. The argument's reasoning is questionable because it overlooks the possibility that:

    • A.those species are even able to thrive in soil lacking acidity
    • B.acidic soil is common across the whole region around the site
    • C.other acid-loving species could also do well in the same soil
    • D.the soil has become more acidic over the past several decades
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: those species are even able to thrive in soil lacking acidity

    The botanist infers acidity from the presence of acid-loving species, which works only if those species grow in acidic soil alone. If they also thrive in soil that is not acidic, their presence proves nothing about this sample. Acidic soil being common nearby, other acid-loving species fitting in, or the soil growing more acidic over time are all consistent with the conclusion, so overlooking them is no weakness.

  139. Most of the runners who trained at high altitude finished the marathon, and most of the runners who finished the marathon set personal records. Which one of the following must be true?

    • A.Most of the high-altitude trainers posted a personal record.
    • B.Most of the personal-record setters had trained at altitude.
    • C.At least one high-altitude trainer completed the whole race.
    • D.At least one high-altitude trainer posted a personal record.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: At least one high-altitude trainer completed the whole race.

    Since most high-altitude trainers finished, at least one of them finished. The two 'most' statements cannot be chained: the high-altitude finishers could all fall in the minority of finishers who missed a personal record, so not even one high-altitude trainer is guaranteed a record, let alone most. Nothing says how many record setters trained at altitude either, since most finishers may never have done so.

  140. Consultant: Firms that offer flexible schedules report lower turnover. So if our firm offers flexible schedules, our turnover will drop. The argument assumes which one of the following?

    • A.Most of the firm's employees would favor a flexible schedule.
    • B.No firm without flexible schedules has ever had low turnover.
    • C.Turnover is the most serious staffing problem the firm faces.
    • D.The firm's turnover would react to flexibility as theirs did.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The firm's turnover would react to flexibility as theirs did.

    The consultant applies a pattern seen at other firms to this firm, which works only if this firm's turnover would react to flexible schedules the way theirs did. Employee preference is not required, since turnover could fall without a majority favoring the change. The argument does not need low turnover to be impossible without flexible schedules, and whether turnover is the firm's worst problem has no bearing on whether it will drop.

  141. Principle: A journalist should publish an accusation only if at least two independent sources confirm it. Application: The journalist published the accusation, so it was confirmed by at least two independent sources. The application most closely conforms to the principle if which one of the following is assumed?

    • A.The journalist does not publish claims from anonymous sources.
    • B.Two independent sources are enough to justify any publication.
    • C.The journalist followed the stated principle in this instance.
    • D.The accusation was serious enough to deserve public attention.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The journalist followed the stated principle in this instance.

    The principle makes two-source confirmation a requirement for publishing, so the act of publishing shows that confirmation occurred only if the journalist actually followed the principle this time. Avoiding anonymous sources says nothing about whether two independent sources confirmed the claim. Treating two sources as enough reverses the principle's direction, and the seriousness of the accusation does not bear on whether it was confirmed.

  142. Geologist: This canyon was carved by a river, since canyons with smooth, rounded walls are always formed by flowing water, and this canyon has smooth, rounded walls. Which one of the following has reasoning most parallel to this argument?

    • A.Every lake that lies in a cold climate freezes; this lake freezes, so it lies in a cold climate.
    • B.Lakes that freeze mostly lie in a cold climate; this lake freezes, so it lies in a cold climate.
    • C.Every lake that freezes lies in a cold climate; this lake doesn't, so it lies in a mild climate.
    • D.Every lake that freezes lies in a cold climate; this lake freezes, so it lies in a cold climate.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Every lake that freezes lies in a cold climate; this lake freezes, so it lies in a cold climate.

    The geologist argues that everything with a feature has a property, this thing has the feature, so it has the property; the argument that every freezing lake lies in a cold climate and this lake freezes has exactly that valid form. Starting from every cold-climate lake freezing reverses the conditional. A premise that freezing lakes only mostly lie in cold climates gives a merely probable conclusion, unlike the original's 'always'. Concluding a mild climate because the lake does not freeze denies the antecedent.

  143. Doctor: Patients who received the new therapy recovered faster than those who received the standard treatment. Therefore, the new therapy is more effective. Which one of the following, if true, most weakens this conclusion?

    • A.The new therapy costs far more than the standard treatment does.
    • B.Patients in both groups got the same care after their treatment.
    • C.A few patients on the standard treatment recovered just as fast.
    • D.The patients on the new therapy started out with milder illness.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The patients on the new therapy started out with milder illness.

    If the new-therapy patients were less sick from the start, their faster recovery could reflect their condition rather than the therapy, so the comparison no longer shows the therapy works better. Cost bears on value, not effectiveness. Identical aftercare removes a rival explanation and so helps the doctor. A few fast recoveries in the standard group do not change the overall difference between the groups.

  144. Whenever the alarm is armed, the entry light turns red. The entry light is not red. Which one of the following must be true?

    • A.The alarm is not armed at present.
    • B.The entry light is broken for now.
    • C.The alarm is armed but has failed.
    • D.A guard has flipped the alarm off.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The alarm is not armed at present.

    Arming the alarm always turns the entry light red, and the light is not red, so the alarm cannot be armed. A broken light is never mentioned and need not be true. An armed alarm that failed contradicts the rule that arming always turns the light red. A guard turning the alarm off assumes it was on earlier, which the premises do not establish.

  145. Editorial: The proposal to add bike lanes downtown should be rejected. Its supporters claim it will reduce car accidents, but those same supporters predicted that the new bus system would reduce congestion, and congestion actually increased. The editorial's reasoning is flawed because it:

    • A.dismisses a claim because its backers erred on an unrelated matter
    • B.infers a cause from a link between two distinct traffic statistics
    • C.treats a condition required for fewer accidents as one ensuring it
    • D.generalizes from a set of accidents too small to be representative
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: dismisses a claim because its backers erred on an unrelated matter

    The editorial rejects the bike-lane claim because its supporters were wrong about the bus system, but their past error has no bearing on whether bike lanes would reduce accidents. The editorial never argues that one traffic trend caused another, so a causal criticism does not fit. It states no conditional about accidents and cites no set of accidents, so the remaining criticisms do not describe it.

  146. An employee may take parental leave only if employed for at least one year. Jordan has been employed for two years. Which one of the following can be properly inferred?

    • A.Jordan is entitled to take parental leave today.
    • B.Jordan meets the tenure rule for parental leave.
    • C.Jordan has met each standard for parental leave.
    • D.Jordan is barred from taking parental leave now.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Jordan meets the tenure rule for parental leave.

    'Only if' marks one year of employment as a necessary condition, and Jordan's two years satisfy it. Because the condition is necessary rather than sufficient, nothing follows about whether Jordan is actually entitled to leave or whether other standards exist and are met. Nothing in the premises bars Jordan either, since the only requirement mentioned is one Jordan meets.

  147. Activist: The factory should be shut down because it is the largest employer in a town with serious environmental problems. Which one of the following is the most useful question to answer in evaluating the activist's argument?

    • A.How many jobs does the factory offer at present?
    • B.Do other towns have factories of a similar size?
    • C.Is the factory the oldest workplace in the town?
    • D.Does the factory cause much of the local damage?
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Does the factory cause much of the local damage?

    The activist's case for closure rests on the town's environmental problems, so it depends on whether the factory actually causes much of that harm; if it does not, closing it would not help. The exact number of jobs adds little, since the factory is already said to be the largest employer. Factories in other towns and the factory's age do not bear on whether it is causing the damage.

  148. All published studies in the journal were peer-reviewed, and no peer-reviewed study contained fabricated data. Which one of the following must be true?

    • A.Every peer-reviewed study was published in the journal.
    • B.Every study clear of fabricated data was peer-reviewed.
    • C.No study the journal printed contained fabricated data.
    • D.Some studies the journal rejected used fabricated data.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: No study the journal printed contained fabricated data.

    Every published study was peer-reviewed, and no peer-reviewed study contained fabricated data, so no published study did. Saying every peer-reviewed study was published reverses the first premise. Saying every clean study was peer-reviewed reverses the second. The premises say nothing about studies the journal rejected, so nothing follows about their data.

  149. Speaker: We should trust the new climate model because it was developed by the most prestigious research institute in the country. The speaker's argument is most vulnerable to the criticism that it:

    • A.presupposes the model's accuracy in its effort to show it
    • B.cites the author's fame rather than any proof of accuracy
    • C.attacks the critics of the model instead of their reasons
    • D.draws a conclusion about all models from one single model
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: cites the author's fame rather than any proof of accuracy

    The speaker offers only the institute's prestige as a reason to trust the model, an appeal to authority in place of evidence about the model's accuracy. The model's accuracy is not used as a premise, so the argument is not circular. No critics are mentioned, so none are attacked. The conclusion concerns this one model, so it does not generalize to all models.

  150. If the museum extends its hours, attendance will increase. If attendance increases, ticket revenue will rise. Which one of the following can be properly concluded?

    • A.If ticket revenue rises, then the museum must have extended its hours.
    • B.If the museum doesn't extend its hours, its ticket revenue won't rise.
    • C.If the museum's hours are extended, then its ticket revenue will rise.
    • D.If attendance goes up, then the museum must have lengthened its hours.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: If the museum's hours are extended, then its ticket revenue will rise.

    Extended hours lead to higher attendance, and higher attendance leads to higher revenue, so chaining the two links extended hours to higher revenue. Inferring longer hours from rising revenue or from rising attendance reverses a conditional. Concluding that revenue will not rise without longer hours denies the antecedent, since revenue or attendance could rise for other reasons.

  151. Marketing director: Sales of our energy drink rose 30 percent in cities where we sponsored sporting events. We should therefore sponsor events in every city. Which one of the following, if true, most strengthens the director's recommendation?

    • A.Sales also rose in several other cities that had no sponsored events.
    • B.Sales did not rise in that period in similar cities lacking sponsors.
    • C.The drink's maker has a far larger sponsorship budget than rivals do.
    • D.The drink is already selling in nearly all cities across the country.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Sales did not rise in that period in similar cities lacking sponsors.

    If comparable cities without sponsored events saw no sales gain over the same period, the rise in sponsored cities is more likely due to the sponsorships, which supports expanding them. Sales rising in cities with no sponsored events points to some other cause and so weakens the recommendation. A large budget and wide distribution show the plan is possible, not that it works.

  152. Nutritionist: People who eat breakfast tend to weigh less than those who skip it. Therefore, skipping breakfast causes weight gain. Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the nutritionist's argument?

    • A.People who eat breakfast are likelier to work out and eat better.
    • B.Some people who skip breakfast weigh less than others who eat it.
    • C.Breakfast foods tend to carry more sugar than the other meals do.
    • D.People who skip breakfast tend to eat a heavier lunch and dinner.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: People who eat breakfast are likelier to work out and eat better.

    If breakfast eaters are also likelier to work out and eat better, those habits could explain their lower weight, which undermines the claim that skipping breakfast causes weight gain. A few light breakfast skippers do not change a trend about groups. Sugary breakfast foods would, if anything, make breakfast eaters heavier, so that does not explain the pattern away. Heavier later meals among skippers would support the nutritionist rather than weaken the argument.

  153. Consultant: Our client's sales rose 12 percent after we launched the new ad campaign, so the campaign must be responsible for the increase. The reasoning above is most vulnerable to which one of the following criticisms?

    • A.It uses a sampling of sales figures too small to be dependable
    • B.It takes mere timing as proof that the campaign drove sales up
    • C.It shifts between two different senses of one of its key terms
    • D.It treats a condition needed for growth as one that ensures it
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: It takes mere timing as proof that the campaign drove sales up

    The consultant concludes the campaign caused the sales rise only because the rise came after the campaign, ignoring other possible causes such as seasonal demand. The argument relies on one sales figure, not a sample, so a sampling criticism does not apply. No term changes meaning during the argument, and no conditional relationship is stated, so the remaining criticisms misdescribe the reasoning.

  154. If the proposal is funded, the lab will be expanded. If the lab is expanded, three new researchers will be hired. The lab will not be expanded. Which one of the following can be properly inferred?

    • A.The three new researchers will not get hired.
    • B.The proposal was funded but is still pending.
    • C.The proposal will not end up receiving funds.
    • D.The lab will expand if researchers are hired.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The proposal will not end up receiving funds.

    Funding guarantees expansion, and there will be no expansion, so the proposal will not be funded. Hiring follows from expansion, but nothing says it happens only then, so we cannot conclude that the researchers will not be hired. A funded proposal would have meant an expansion, which contradicts the premises. Expansion following from hiring reverses the second conditional.

  155. Editor: Every article we publish is fact-checked before release. The piece on city budgets was published. Therefore it was fact-checked. Which one of the following arguments is most similar in its reasoning to the editor's argument?

    • A.Most dogs at the shelter are vaccinated. Rex is at the shelter. So Rex probably is also.
    • B.Every dog at the shelter is vaccinated. Rex is vaccinated now. So Rex is at the shelter.
    • C.Each dog at the shelter is vaccinated. Rex is not at the shelter. So he is unvaccinated.
    • D.Every dog at the shelter is vaccinated. Rex is at the shelter. So Rex is vaccinated too.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Every dog at the shelter is vaccinated. Rex is at the shelter. So Rex is vaccinated too.

    The editor argues that every member of a group has a property, this item is a member, so it has the property; the argument that every shelter dog is vaccinated and Rex is at the shelter has that same valid form. The 'most' version reaches only a probable conclusion. Concluding Rex is at the shelter because he is vaccinated affirms the consequent, and concluding he is unvaccinated because he is not at the shelter denies the antecedent.

  156. Scientist: Our new alloy resists corrosion better than the standard alloy in laboratory tests. We should therefore use it for the coastal bridge. Which one of the following is an assumption required by the scientist's argument?

    • A.The new alloy would be no costlier than the conventional option.
    • B.The lab tests reflect the conditions that the bridge would meet.
    • C.Corrosion is the only factor that matters when choosing a metal.
    • D.The standard alloy has corroded on a few nearby coastal bridges.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The lab tests reflect the conditions that the bridge would meet.

    The argument moves from laboratory results to a recommendation for a coastal bridge, which fails if the lab conditions do not reflect what the bridge would face. Equal cost is not required, since better corrosion resistance could justify a higher price. Corrosion need not be the only factor, only one that favors the new alloy. Past corrosion of the standard alloy is not needed for the new one to be the better choice.

  157. Survey: Among people who own pets, 80 percent report feeling less lonely than they did before owning a pet. Which one of the following can be most reliably concluded from this statement alone?

    • A.Owning a pet makes most people feel less lonely than before.
    • B.Pet owners are less lonely than individuals who own no pets.
    • C.Most surveyed pet owners said that they are now less lonely.
    • D.The other fifth of pet owners now feel lonelier than before.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Most surveyed pet owners said that they are now less lonely.

    The survey reports that 80 percent of pet owners say they feel less lonely than before, so most surveyed owners say so. Treating the pet as the cause goes beyond self-reports, which could reflect other changes in their lives. No one without a pet was surveyed, so no comparison with non-owners is possible. The remaining fifth may feel the same rather than lonelier, so nothing follows about them feeling worse.

  158. Politician: We must either build the new reservoir or impose strict water rationing. Strict rationing would devastate local farms, which would be intolerable. Therefore we must build the reservoir. The argument's conclusion follows logically if which one of the following is assumed?

    • A.No policy whose effects would be intolerable should be adopted.
    • B.Building the reservoir would cause no hardship for local farms.
    • C.Strict rationing is the only policy that could devastate farms.
    • D.Most voters would rather build the reservoir than ration water.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: No policy whose effects would be intolerable should be adopted.

    The premises already say the choice is between the reservoir and rationing and that rationing's effects would be intolerable; what is missing is the link that an option with intolerable effects must be rejected. With that link, rationing is ruled out and building the reservoir follows. Whether the reservoir would hurt farms, whether anything else could devastate them, and what voters prefer do not rule out rationing.

  159. Critic: The restaurant's new chef must be talented, since the restaurant has been fully booked every night since the chef arrived. Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the critic's argument?

    • A.The new chef trained at a highly respected culinary academy.
    • B.Food critics have praised several of the new chef's recipes.
    • C.The restaurant introduced a cheaper menu as the chef joined.
    • D.The restaurant raised its dinner prices as the chef arrived.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The restaurant introduced a cheaper menu as the chef joined.

    A cheaper menu introduced at the same moment offers another explanation for the full bookings, so they no longer point to the chef's talent. Strong training and praise from critics both support the critic's conclusion. Higher dinner prices with every night still booked would make demand look stronger, which also supports the claim instead of weakening it.

  160. All certified guides know the trail. Some certified guides also speak French. Which one of the following must be true on the basis of these statements?

    • A.Everyone who knows the trail is also a certified guide.
    • B.At least one French speaker is familiar with the trail.
    • C.Some people who know the trail cannot speak any French.
    • D.Not all of the certified guides are speakers of French.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: At least one French speaker is familiar with the trail.

    Some certified guides speak French, and every certified guide knows the trail, so those guides are French speakers who know the trail. That everyone who knows the trail is a certified guide reverses the first premise. Nothing rules out every trail-knower, or every certified guide, speaking French, so neither claim about people who do not speak French must be true.

  161. Manager: Productivity declined last quarter only in the departments that adopted the new scheduling software. So the software must be reducing productivity. Which one of the following, if true, most strengthens the manager's argument?

    • A.Buying and installing the software cost much more than projected.
    • B.Groups with and without it had comparable workloads and staffing.
    • C.The departments using it saw much heavier workloads that quarter.
    • D.Overall company productivity was lower than in the previous year.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Groups with and without it had comparable workloads and staffing.

    If the departments that adopted the software were otherwise like those that did not in workload and staffing, the software becomes the most likely cause of the drop. What the software cost has nothing to do with productivity. Much heavier workloads in the adopting departments give a rival explanation and so weaken the argument. A company-wide decline says nothing about why the adopting departments fell.

  162. Which one of the following best describes the task in an LSAT 'parallel reasoning' question?

    • A.Find the choice that supplies a premise the argument assumes.
    • B.Find the choice that most weakens the stated main conclusion.
    • C.Find the choice that says what the argument mainly concludes.
    • D.Find the choice that follows the stated pattern of inference.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Find the choice that follows the stated pattern of inference.

    Parallel reasoning questions ask for the answer choice whose logical structure matches the stimulus, regardless of topic. Supplying a premise the argument assumes describes an assumption question. Weakening the conclusion describes a weaken question. Stating what the argument mainly concludes describes a main point question.

  163. Researcher: The medication reduced symptoms in 70 percent of patients who took it, compared with 30 percent of patients who took a placebo. Therefore the medication is effective. Which one of the following, if true, most weakens this argument?

    • A.The placebo group had a few more patients enrolled than the drug group.
    • B.Patients on the drug also got counseling the placebo group did not get.
    • C.A rival drug helped 75 percent of patients in a separate ongoing trial.
    • D.Some patients on the drug had mild side effects that quickly went away.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Patients on the drug also got counseling the placebo group did not get.

    If only the medication group received counseling, the counseling rather than the drug could explain the better results, which weakens the claim that the medication works. A slightly larger placebo group does not distort a comparison of percentages. Another drug's results in a different trial say nothing about this one. Mild, brief side effects bear on tolerability, not effectiveness.

  164. No reptiles are warm-blooded. All snakes are reptiles. Which one of the following follows logically?

    • A.Some reptiles are not actually snakes.
    • B.No snake is a warm-blooded vertebrate.
    • C.Each cold-blooded animal is a reptile.
    • D.Some snakes are in truth warm-blooded.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: No snake is a warm-blooded vertebrate.

    Every snake is a reptile and no reptile is warm-blooded, so no snake is warm-blooded, and therefore no snake is a warm-blooded vertebrate. The premises allow every reptile to be a snake, so it need not be true that some reptiles are not snakes. Nothing says every cold-blooded animal is a reptile. Some snakes being warm-blooded contradicts the premises.

  165. Columnist: The mayor's transportation plan should be rejected. After all, the mayor has never personally used public transit. Which one of the following most accurately describes the flaw in the columnist's reasoning?

    • A.It assumes what holds for a group holds for each individual member
    • B.It faults the backer's habits rather than the merits of the policy
    • C.It treats two facts that merely occur together as cause and effect
    • D.It generalizes from a sample too small to represent the whole city
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: It faults the backer's habits rather than the merits of the policy

    Whether the mayor rides public transit has no bearing on whether the transportation plan is sound, so the columnist attacks the person rather than the plan. The argument says nothing about a group and its members, so there is no part-to-whole error. It claims no causal link between two facts and cites no sample, so those criticisms do not fit.

  166. Apparent discrepancy: A bakery doubled the size of its retail space, yet its total monthly sales stayed exactly the same. Which one of the following, if true, most helps to resolve this apparent discrepancy?

    • A.The bakery shut for weeks while expanding and lost regulars to a rival.
    • B.The larger space let the bakery put out many more products than before.
    • C.The sourdough and the rye loaves have long been its most popular items.
    • D.The owner has been running the bakery for more than ten years straight.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The bakery shut for weeks while expanding and lost regulars to a rival.

    A closure during the expansion that drove regular customers to a competitor explains why monthly sales did not grow despite the larger space. More room to display products would be expected to raise sales, which deepens the puzzle. The bakery's most popular items and the owner's long tenure say nothing about why the expansion failed to increase sales.

  167. Principle: A company should disclose a product defect to customers whenever the defect could endanger their safety. Application: TechCo did not disclose a defect in its heater. Which one of the following, if true, would make TechCo's conduct consistent with the principle?

    • A.The defect would have been costly for TechCo to repair.
    • B.Few customers would have found the defect on their own.
    • C.A competitor also hid a similar defect in its products.
    • D.The defect posed no possible risk to any user's safety.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The defect posed no possible risk to any user's safety.

    The principle requires disclosure only when a defect could endanger safety, so if this defect could not, staying silent is consistent with it. Repair cost does not remove a safety-based duty. Whether customers would find the defect themselves is irrelevant to that duty. A competitor's silence does not make TechCo's silence acceptable under the principle.

  168. Some board members support the merger. All who support the merger have reviewed the financial report. Therefore, some board members have reviewed the financial report. Which one of the following arguments has a reasoning structure most similar to the argument above?

    • A.Some hikers carry maps. All who carry maps studied the route. So some hikers studied it.
    • B.Some hikers carry maps. Few who carry maps studied the route. So some hikers studied it.
    • C.Some hikers carry maps. All who studied the route carry maps. So some hikers studied it.
    • D.All chefs taste their dishes. Some cooks are chefs. So all cooks taste their own dishes.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Some hikers carry maps. All who carry maps studied the route. So some hikers studied it.

    The original runs: some As are Bs, all Bs are Cs, so some As are Cs, which is valid, and the hiker argument whose second premise is that all map carriers studied the route matches it. If only a few map carriers studied the route, the hikers with maps may not be among them. If everyone who studied the route carries a map, the hikers with maps may still not have studied it. The chef argument draws an 'all' conclusion from a 'some' premise, which is invalid.

  169. Advertisement: Customers who switched to our internet service report download speeds 40 percent faster than their old service. Switch today for the fastest internet available. Which one of the following points to a flaw in the advertisement's reasoning?

    • A.It does not state the monthly fees that the service charges.
    • B.It does not explain how the service achieves its top speeds.
    • C.It does not rule out services faster than the ones replaced.
    • D.It does not report how dependable the service is over years.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: It does not rule out services faster than the ones replaced.

    The evidence compares the service only with what each customer used before, so it cannot show the service is the fastest available unless other services are no faster; the advertisement never rules that out. Fees and long-term dependability are omitted facts, not gaps in the reasoning toward the speed claim. How the service achieves its speed does not affect whether the 'fastest' claim follows from the evidence.

  170. Everyone who qualifies for the grant has submitted a portfolio. Dana has submitted a portfolio. Which one of the following is the most that can be concluded about Dana?

    • A.Whether Dana qualifies for the grant cannot be judged here.
    • B.Surely Dana qualifies for the grant owing to the portfolio.
    • C.Dana does not qualify for the grant despite that portfolio.
    • D.Dana likely qualifies for the grant owing to the portfolio.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Whether Dana qualifies for the grant cannot be judged here.

    Submitting a portfolio is necessary for qualifying but not stated to be sufficient, so Dana's submission leaves open whether she qualifies. Concluding that she surely qualifies affirms the consequent. Nothing in the premises shows she fails to qualify. No information about how many submitters qualify supports calling it likely, either.

  171. Economist: Countries that lowered their corporate tax rate experienced higher business investment the following year. So lowering the corporate tax rate boosts business investment. Which one of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the economist's conclusion?

    • A.The rate cuts came during a world boom that raised investment everywhere.
    • B.Some countries that kept their tax rates saw investment climbing as well.
    • C.The tax cuts reduced government revenue in all of the countries involved.
    • D.Countries do not all measure business investment in exactly the same way.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The rate cuts came during a world boom that raised investment everywhere.

    A global boom that raised investment on its own gives an alternative cause for the increase, which seriously undercuts the claim that the tax cuts produced it. Rising investment in some countries that kept their rates is a much weaker challenge and does not explain the larger pattern. Lost revenue is a separate consequence, and differences in measurement do not explain why investment rose after the cuts.

  172. Which one of the following most accurately states the conclusion of this argument? Architect: Glass facades make buildings harder to cool in summer, and they reflect glare onto neighboring streets. For these reasons, the city should not approve the proposed all-glass tower.

    • A.The city should decline to permit the glass tower
    • B.The glass tower would throw glare on city streets
    • C.The planned tower would have outer walls of glass
    • D.The glass tower would grow hot inside each summer
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The city should decline to permit the glass tower

    The main conclusion is the recommendation that the city not approve the tower; 'for these reasons' marks everything before it as support. The tower growing hot in summer and the glare it would throw on nearby streets are the two premises given for that recommendation, not the point being argued. That the tower would have glass walls is background the argument takes for granted rather than something it tries to prove.

  173. Teacher: Students who read for pleasure score higher on writing assessments. To raise our students' writing scores, we should require them to read for pleasure. Which one of the following best identifies a questionable assumption in the teacher's plan?

    • A.Writing tests fairly capture the actual skill of every student
    • B.Required reading yields the same gains as reading chosen freely
    • C.Higher writing scores matter more than gains in other subjects
    • D.Pleasure reading is the sole source of students' writing skill
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Required reading yields the same gains as reading chosen freely

    The evidence is about students who read for pleasure by choice, but the plan forces reading on everyone, so it takes for granted that compelled reading brings the same gain as freely chosen reading. Nothing in the plan ranks writing scores above other subjects. The plan does not need pleasure reading to be the sole source of writing skill; a partial cause would still justify it. Its goal is higher scores, so whether the tests fairly capture real skill is beside the point.

  174. If a candidate is endorsed by the union, then the candidate supports the wage increase. Candidate Ruiz does not support the wage increase. Which one of the following must be true?

    • A.The union did not grant its endorsement to Ruiz
    • B.Most union members will refuse to vote for Ruiz
    • C.Anyone backing the raise is backed by the union
    • D.The union endorsed no one who favored the raise
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The union did not grant its endorsement to Ruiz

    The conditional says union endorsement guarantees support for the wage increase, so by the contrapositive anyone who does not support the increase lacks the endorsement; Ruiz does not support it, so the union did not endorse Ruiz. How union members will vote is never addressed. The premises allow the union to have endorsed candidates who favor the raise, so it need not have endorsed no one of that kind. Saying anyone who backs the raise has union backing reverses the conditional.

  175. Two debaters disagree. Debater A: We should fund the after-school program because it keeps teenagers off the streets. Debater B: But studies show most of its participants would have stayed home anyway. Debater B responds to Debater A by doing which one of the following?

    • A.Charging that A's facts come from a skewed sample
    • B.Saying that A's conclusion is at odds with itself
    • C.Disputing a factual claim on which A's case rests
    • D.Offering an example that defies a rule A endorses
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Disputing a factual claim on which A's case rests

    A's case rests on the factual claim that the program keeps teenagers off the streets, and B disputes exactly that claim by citing studies showing participants would have stayed home anyway. A offered no sample at all, so B cannot be charging that one is skewed. B never says A's conclusion is inconsistent with itself. A endorsed no general rule for B to counter with an example.

  176. Most of the novels on the prize shortlist were published by independent presses. Most novels published by independent presses sell fewer than a thousand copies. Which one of the following is NOT properly supported by these statements?

    • A.Most of the shortlisted novels were put out by independent presses
    • B.Some novels from independent presses sell under a thousand copies
    • C.At least one shortlisted novel came out from an independent press
    • D.Most shortlisted novels have sales of fewer than a thousand copies
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Most shortlisted novels have sales of fewer than a thousand copies

    The claim that most shortlisted novels sell fewer than a thousand copies is not supported, because two 'most' statements do not chain: the independent-press titles on the shortlist could all belong to the minority of independent-press books that sell well. Each other statement is supported. That most shortlisted novels came from independent presses is the first premise itself, and it guarantees that at least one did. 'Most independent-press novels sell fewer than a thousand copies' guarantees that some do.

  177. Official: Crime fell after the city installed streetlights in the park, so the lights reduced crime. Which one of the following questions would be most useful to answer in evaluating the official's argument?

    • A.Were most of the crimes in the park committed late at night?
    • B.How much did the city spend to install the new lights there?
    • C.Did crime also drop in similar parks that got no new lights?
    • D.Did the new lights use less power than the old fixtures did?
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Did crime also drop in similar parks that got no new lights?

    The official infers that the lights caused the drop in crime just because it came after they went in. Learning whether crime also fell in similar parks with no new lights tests that directly: if it did, some wider cause is likely; if it did not, the lights look responsible. Knowing when park crimes usually happened still leaves open whether the drop came from the lights or from some wider cause. Power use and installation cost say nothing about the lights' effect on crime.

  178. Gardener: This soil must be acidic, because the hydrangeas growing in it have blue flowers, and hydrangeas produce blue flowers only in acidic soil. Which one of the following is an assumption on which the argument depends?

    • A.Every hydrangea in an acidic soil is sure to bear blue blooms
    • B.The blue color came from the plants, not from dye added later
    • C.No other plant in this soil bears blossoms of that vivid blue
    • D.Hydrangeas are the only kind of plant that grows in this soil
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The blue color came from the plants, not from dye added later

    The premise says hydrangeas produce blue flowers only in acidic soil, so the inference works only if the blue was actually produced by the plants; if the flowers had been dyed, their color would say nothing about the soil. Whether other plants grow in the soil, or share the same blue, has no bearing on what the hydrangeas reveal. The argument needs blue to signal acidic soil, not the reverse claim that acidic soil always yields blue blooms.

  179. Which one of the following best describes what an LSAT 'point at issue' (disagreement) question asks the test-taker to identify?

    • A.A conclusion that both of the speakers end up granting
    • B.A logical slip that the second of the speakers commits
    • C.A claim that one speaker accepts and the other rejects
    • D.A premise that both speakers rely upon but never state
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: A claim that one speaker accepts and the other rejects

    A point-at-issue question asks for the specific claim the two speakers disagree about, meaning one would accept it and the other would reject it. A premise both rely on and a conclusion both grant are points of agreement, the opposite of what is asked. Spotting a reasoning error by one speaker is the task of a flaw question, not a disagreement question.

  180. All the documents in the secure archive are encrypted. None of the encrypted documents can be opened without a password. Therefore, none of the documents in the secure archive can be opened without a password. The argument is best characterized as which one of the following?

    • A.Invalid, since it generalizes from a few sample documents
    • B.Valid, but only if the archive's passwords remain private
    • C.Valid, since its conclusion follows from its two premises
    • D.Invalid, since it treats a sufficient condition as needed
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Valid, since its conclusion follows from its two premises

    Every archive document is encrypted, and no encrypted document can be opened without a password, so every archive document has that property; the conclusion follows necessarily. The argument does not reason from a sample; its premises cover all archive documents. Its validity does not depend on passwords staying private, because validity concerns only whether the conclusion follows from the premises. No sufficient condition is mistaken for a necessary one, since the argument simply chains two universal claims.

  181. Coach: Our team lost every game in which our starting goalkeeper did not play. Therefore, the goalkeeper is the reason we win. Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the coach's reasoning?

    • A.The squad scored fewer goals this season than last year
    • B.The backup goalkeeper trains with the team on most days
    • C.Every game the goalkeeper missed was against a top team
    • D.The goalkeeper started most games in the past two years
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Every game the goalkeeper missed was against a top team

    If every missed game came against a top team, the strength of the opponents explains those losses without crediting the goalkeeper, which weakens the coach's causal claim. That the goalkeeper started most games says nothing about why the team lost without him. Scoring fewer goals this season does not account for the losses in the games he missed. How often the backup trains with the team offers no other reason for those losses.

  182. Letter: The new building code requires sprinkler systems in all apartment buildings taller than four stories. The Larkin Building has sprinklers, so it must be taller than four stories. Which one of the following most accurately describes the flaw in this reasoning?

    • A.It relies on the testimony of a witness with a financial interest
    • B.It treats a feature required of tall buildings as proof of height
    • C.It infers that one thing caused the other from a mere correlation
    • D.It uses the word 'building' in two senses within the same argument
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: It treats a feature required of tall buildings as proof of height

    The code makes sprinklers required for buildings over four stories, but shorter buildings may install them too, so having sprinklers does not prove the Larkin Building is tall; the letter treats a required feature as proof of the condition that triggers the requirement. The word 'building' keeps one meaning throughout. No causal claim is drawn from a correlation. No witness or interested party is cited.

  183. Either the shipment was delayed at customs or the supplier missed the deadline. If the supplier missed the deadline, the invoice would show a late fee. The invoice shows no late fee. Which one of the following follows logically?

    • A.The shipment got held up clearing customs
    • B.The shipment reached the buyer on schedule
    • C.The bill omitted the supplier's customs fee
    • D.The supplier did miss the buyer's deadline
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The shipment got held up clearing customs

    A missed deadline would put a late fee on the invoice, and there is none, so the supplier met the deadline; since one of the two alternatives must hold, the shipment was held up at customs. Nothing establishes an on-schedule arrival, and a customs hold-up makes it doubtful. Saying the supplier missed the deadline contradicts the inference from the missing late fee. Nothing in the premises mentions a customs fee, so its omission does not follow.

  184. Reviewer: This smartphone has the best camera on the market, as proven by the fact that it has the most megapixels. Which one of the following is an assumption required by the reviewer's argument?

    • A.This phone carries a steeper price than every rival model
    • B.A higher megapixel count always makes for a better camera
    • C.Its megapixel lead over rival phones will keep on growing
    • D.Most shoppers pick a phone mainly for its camera quality
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: A higher megapixel count always makes for a better camera

    The reviewer moves from 'most megapixels' to 'best camera', which works only if more megapixels make a better camera; if lenses, sensors or software mattered more, the conclusion would fail. The phone's price is never part of the reasoning. What most shoppers care about has no bearing on which camera is best. The claim is about the camera today, so it does not need the megapixel lead to keep growing.

  185. Anyone who finishes the marathon receives a medal. Anyone who receives a medal is listed on the website. Priya is not listed on the website. Which one of the following must be true?

    • A.Priya ran the marathon but got no medal
    • B.Priya earned a medal but did not finish
    • C.Priya did not finish the marathon at all
    • D.Priya began the run but then dropped out
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Priya did not finish the marathon at all

    Finishing guarantees a medal and a medal guarantees a website listing, so by the chained contrapositive Priya, who is not listed, got no medal and did not finish. She may never have started, so it need not be true that she began and dropped out or that she ran the marathon at all. Earning a medal is ruled out, since any medal winner would be listed.

  186. Sociologist: Neighborhoods with more community gardens report stronger feelings of social connection among residents. Therefore, building community gardens would strengthen social connection in any neighborhood. Which one of the following, if true, most strengthens the sociologist's argument?

    • A.Areas randomly given new gardens later reported closer ties
    • B.Some areas without gardens also report strong social bonds
    • C.Residents who feel connected tend to volunteer more widely
    • D.Community gardens have become popular in many crowded areas
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Areas randomly given new gardens later reported closer ties

    Random assignment rules out the reverse explanation that already close-knit neighborhoods are the ones that build gardens, so closer ties after randomly assigned gardens support the causal claim. How popular gardens are in crowded areas says nothing about their effect. Volunteering by connected residents does not link gardens to connection. Strong bonds in areas without gardens, if anything, suggests gardens are not needed for connection.

  187. Which one of the following most accurately describes the role played in the argument by the claim that 'the bridge has not been inspected in over a decade'? Argument: The bridge has not been inspected in over a decade. Structures that go that long without inspection often develop hidden weaknesses. Therefore the bridge should be closed until it is inspected.

    • A.It is an objection to closing the bridge that the argument rebuts
    • B.It is a general principle that the argument applies to the bridge
    • C.It is the main conclusion that the argument draws about the bridge
    • D.It is a premise used to support closing the bridge until inspected
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: It is a premise used to support closing the bridge until inspected

    The claim that the bridge has gone over a decade without inspection is a factual premise; combined with the point about hidden weaknesses, it supports closing the bridge until it is inspected. The main conclusion is that closure recommendation, not this claim. The general principle is the separate statement about structures left uninspected, and this claim is a fact about one bridge. The argument raises no objection to rebut.

  188. Botanist: Every plant in the rooftop garden requires full sun. Some plants that require full sun are succulents. Therefore, every plant in the rooftop garden is a succulent. Which one of the following most accurately describes the flaw in the botanist's reasoning?

    • A.It ascribes to a whole group what holds for only some of a related group
    • B.It relies on a premise that does nothing more than restate its conclusion
    • C.It infers that one thing causes another from what is merely a correlation
    • D.It attacks the person who makes a claim rather than the claim itself
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: It ascribes to a whole group what holds for only some of a related group

    All rooftop plants need full sun, and only some full-sun plants are succulents, so nothing follows about every rooftop plant being a succulent; the botanist assigns to a whole group a trait that holds for only some of a related group. No causal claim or correlation is involved. No person is attacked. The premises are about sunlight and succulents in general, so neither one restates the conclusion.

  189. Principle: One should not criticize a colleague's work publicly unless one has first raised the concern privately. Which one of the following actions conforms to this principle?

    • A.Tom raised the errors with Mara alone, then cited them at the meeting
    • B.Tom emailed the staff about Mara's errors, then met with her in private
    • C.Tom told Mara the report looked fine, then faulted it at the meeting
    • D.Tom cited Mara's errors at the meeting, then raised them with her later
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Tom raised the errors with Mara alone, then cited them at the meeting

    The principle allows public criticism only after the concern has been raised privately, and raising the errors with Mara alone before citing them at the meeting meets that condition. Citing the errors at the meeting first, or emailing the staff before meeting her privately, puts the public criticism ahead of the private talk. Telling Mara the report looked fine raised no concern with her at all, so faulting it at the meeting afterward also breaks the principle.

  190. Pollster: In our phone survey, 65 percent of respondents said they plan to vote for the incumbent. So the incumbent will likely win the election. Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the pollster's prediction?

    • A.The incumbent has already served two full terms in this very same high office
    • B.A few of the people polled would not say whom they planned to vote for
    • C.The challenger has raised more campaign money so far than the incumbent has
    • D.The poll reached only landlines, which the incumbent's backers more often own
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The poll reached only landlines, which the incumbent's backers more often own

    If only landlines were called and the incumbent's backers are more likely than others to own one, the sample overrepresents the incumbent, so the 65 percent figure probably overstates support. Having served two terms says nothing about whether the poll is accurate. Fundraising does not show the poll misreads voters. A few people declining to answer is far too small a gap to undo a 65 percent result.

  191. Which one of the following best describes the task in an LSAT 'method of reasoning' question?

    • A.Determine whether the argument's central claim is actually true
    • B.Pinpoint the answer that most seriously undermines the argument
    • C.Describe in broad terms how the argument reaches its conclusion
    • D.Identify the premise that, if assumed, makes the argument valid
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Describe in broad terms how the argument reaches its conclusion

    A method-of-reasoning question asks for an abstract account of how the argument proceeds, such as 'rejects a claim by citing a counterexample'. LSAT questions never ask whether an argument's claims are actually true. Identifying a premise that would make the argument valid is a sufficient-assumption task, and pinpointing what most undermines the argument is a weaken task.

  192. Researcher: Office workers who keep a small plant on their desk report lower stress than those who do not. Therefore, placing plants on desks reduces worker stress. Which one of the following, if true, most strengthens the argument?

    • A.Before getting plants, the owners were as stressed as others.
    • B.Some workers find watering their desk plants an annoying chore.
    • C.Stress can be measured only by workers' own written responses.
    • D.Many offices now place large plants in their shared lunchrooms.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Before getting plants, the owners were as stressed as others.

    If plant owners were just as stressed as everyone else before getting plants, their lower stress afterward cannot be explained by calmer people choosing plants, which supports the causal claim. Finding watering a chore does not show plants reduce stress. Plants in shared lunchrooms say nothing about desk plants. Relying only on self-reports, if anything, casts doubt on the measurement.

  193. Columnist: Sales of our city's morning newspaper have fallen every year for a decade, so residents are clearly losing interest in local news. Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the columnist's argument?

    • A.Online readership of its local news coverage rose sharply in that span.
    • B.Morning papers in several other cities also lost sales over the decade.
    • C.Most of the paper's subscribers have lived in the city for many decades.
    • D.The paper still features local news stories on the front page daily.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Online readership of its local news coverage rose sharply in that span.

    If online readership of the paper's local coverage rose sharply over the same span, residents are still reading local news, just in a new format, so falling print sales do not show lost interest. Where the paper places local stories says nothing about whether readers still want them. How long subscribers have lived in the city does not explain the decline. Similar losses elsewhere are consistent with the columnist's claim and do not show residents still follow local news.

  194. Marketing director: Our new logo will increase brand recognition, because every focus-group participant who saw it remembered it the next day. Which one of the following is an assumption required by the argument?

    • A.Members of the focus group strongly disliked the company's old logo.
    • B.Brand recognition is the only thing that drives the company's sales.
    • C.All consumers will encounter the new logo within the following year.
    • D.The focus group roughly resembles the public that the brand targets.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The focus group roughly resembles the public that the brand targets.

    The argument moves from what a focus group remembered to a claim about recognition among the public, which works only if the group roughly resembles that public. The conclusion is about recognition, not sales, so it needs no claim about what drives sales. Whether the group disliked the old logo has no bearing on whether the new one will be recognized. Recognition can rise without every consumer seeing the logo within a year, so that is not required either.

  195. Argument: All of the building's tenants who recycle also compost. Therefore, tenant Reyes composts. Which one of the following, if assumed, allows the conclusion to be properly drawn?

    • A.Most of the tenants there also recycle.
    • B.All the tenants who compost also recycle.
    • C.Reyes is among the tenants that recycle.
    • D.Reyes has lived there for several years.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Reyes is among the tenants that recycle.

    The premise says every tenant who recycles composts, so adding that Reyes is among the recycling tenants guarantees that Reyes composts. The claim that all composting tenants recycle reverses the premise and tells us nothing about Reyes. Knowing most tenants recycle leaves open that Reyes is in the minority. How long Reyes has lived there does not place Reyes among the recyclers.

  196. Pundit: The senator's proposal to fund after-school programs must be unwise, because the senator could not answer a single reporter's question about the program's budget. The reasoning is most vulnerable to the criticism that it

    • A.confuses a condition needed for a result with one that ensures the result
    • B.assumes that a whole plan is unwise because one of its parts is unwise
    • C.relies on the word of an expert speaking outside his or her own field
    • D.treats an advocate's weak defense of a plan as proof the plan is unwise
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: treats an advocate's weak defense of a plan as proof the plan is unwise

    The senator's failure to answer budget questions reflects on the senator, not on the merits of after-school funding, so the pundit wrongly treats a weak defense as proof that the proposal is unwise. No expert is cited. The pundit never singles out any part of the plan as unwise, so the reasoning does not move from a part to the whole. It states no condition that is needed for or ensures a result, so no such confusion occurs.

  197. All of the apartments on the third floor have balconies. None of the apartments with balconies face the courtyard. Which one of the following must be true?

    • A.Some units that face the courtyard have balconies.
    • B.Every courtyard-facing unit is on the third floor.
    • C.Some third-floor units have no balconies at all.
    • D.No third-floor unit faces out onto the courtyard.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: No third-floor unit faces out onto the courtyard.

    Every third-floor apartment has a balcony and no apartment with a balcony faces the courtyard, so no third-floor unit faces the courtyard. A courtyard-facing unit with a balcony would break the second premise. A third-floor unit without a balcony would break the first. The premises put no courtyard unit on the third floor, so they cannot place every courtyard unit there.

  198. Which one of the following arguments is most similar in its reasoning to the following? 'Every cake on the dessert cart contains sugar. This dish contains no sugar, so it is not a cake on the dessert cart.'

    • A.Every novel in the series has a map. This book has none, so it is outside the series.
    • B.No reptile in the zoo is warm-blooded. This animal is not a reptile, so it must be warm-blooded.
    • C.All licensed pilots have passed a medical exam. Sana has passed one, so Sana is a licensed pilot.
    • D.Most marathon runners train every day. Lee trains every day, so Lee must be a marathon runner.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Every novel in the series has a map. This book has none, so it is outside the series.

    The original states that every member of a group has a feature and concludes that something lacking the feature is not a member, a valid contrapositive. The map argument has exactly that form. The pilot argument infers membership from having the feature, which reverses the rule. The runner argument does the same from only a 'most' claim. The reptile argument infers a trait from not being a reptile, which its premise cannot support.

  199. Principle: A journalist should grant a source anonymity only if revealing the source's name would expose that source to serious harm. Which one of the following judgments conforms to this principle?

    • A.A journalist shields a mayor who wants to dodge mild teasing.
    • B.A journalist shields an aide who would rather not be quoted.
    • C.A journalist shields a donor who merely wants to seem humble.
    • D.A journalist shields a clerk who would get fired if revealed.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: A journalist shields a clerk who would get fired if revealed.

    The principle allows anonymity only when naming the source would expose that source to serious harm, and losing one's job is serious harm, so shielding the clerk conforms. Preferring not to be quoted is a preference, not a harm. Mild teasing falls well short of serious harm. Wanting to seem humble involves no harm at all, so each of those grants of anonymity breaks the principle.

  200. Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main conclusion of the argument? 'The committee should not adopt the proposed bylaw. It would require a two-thirds vote for routine decisions, which would paralyze ordinary business. And measures that paralyze ordinary business serve no one's interest.'

    • A.Bylaws that stall committee business help no one.
    • B.The committee should not pass the proposed bylaw.
    • C.The proposed bylaw would halt all ordinary business.
    • D.Even routine decisions would need a two-thirds vote.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The committee should not pass the proposed bylaw.

    Everything else in the passage is offered as a reason for not passing the bylaw, so that recommendation is the main conclusion. The two-thirds requirement for routine decisions is the first premise, the claim that the bylaw would halt ordinary business is drawn from it, and the claim that measures stalling business help no one is the general premise linking that effect to the recommendation.

  201. A bakery switched from butter to a cheaper margarine in its croissants to cut costs, yet its overall profits fell the following month. Which one of the following, if true, most helps to resolve this apparent discrepancy?

    • A.The bakery also sells various kinds of pastry beyond croissants.
    • B.Many regulars disliked the new flavor and quit buying croissants.
    • C.The bakery's rent stayed exactly the same throughout that month.
    • D.Margarine and butter are both readily bought from big suppliers.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Many regulars disliked the new flavor and quit buying croissants.

    If regulars disliked the new taste and stopped buying croissants, the lost sales could outweigh the savings on ingredients, which explains how a cost cut lowered profits. Unchanged rent could not have pushed profits down. Easy access to both fats does not touch the drop in profit. Selling other pastries does not explain why profits fell after the switch.

  202. Speaker: The new rule banning skateboards in the plaza is justified, since skateboards endanger pedestrians, and any activity that endangers pedestrians should be banned from the plaza. The argument proceeds by

    • A.appealing to an authority who has publicly endorsed the new rule
    • B.drawing an analogy between the plaza and some similar public space
    • C.rejecting a counterexample that a critic has raised against the rule
    • D.applying a stated general principle to one specific kind of activity
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: applying a stated general principle to one specific kind of activity

    The speaker states a general principle, that any activity endangering pedestrians should be banned from the plaza, and applies it to skateboarding to justify the ban. No authority is cited. The plaza is never compared with any other space. No critic or counterexample appears in the argument.

  203. Manager: Switching our delivery fleet to electric vans will save money, because electricity costs less per mile than diesel fuel. Which one of the following would be most useful to know in order to evaluate the manager's argument?

    • A.Whether the firm's rivals currently pay less for fuel than the firm does
    • B.Whether the vans' higher upfront and upkeep costs erase the fuel savings
    • C.Whether electric vans produce much less road noise than do diesel vans
    • D.Whether the company's drivers would prefer driving the new electric vans
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Whether the vans' higher upfront and upkeep costs erase the fuel savings

    The conclusion is about overall savings, but the premise covers only fuel cost per mile, so the argument stands or falls on whether higher purchase and upkeep costs erase those fuel savings. What rivals pay for fuel now does not show whether this company's switch saves money. Road noise and driver preference do not bear on the cost comparison the argument makes.

  204. Editorialist: Towns that built new sports stadiums saw their downtown restaurant revenues rise the next year. So building a stadium causes downtown restaurant revenues to rise. The reasoning is flawed because it

    • A.infers causation from the fact that one event came after another
    • B.reaches a conclusion that conflicts with one of its own premises
    • C.mistakes a condition sufficient for a result for a necessary one
    • D.attacks the motives of the claim's authors rather than the claim
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: infers causation from the fact that one event came after another

    That restaurant revenues rose after stadiums were built does not show the stadiums caused the rise; a growing local economy, for instance, could explain both. The editorialist attacks no one's motives. No sufficient or necessary condition is stated, so none is confused. The conclusion is consistent with the premise, merely unsupported by it.

  205. If the statement 'Every winning entry in the contest used recycled materials' is true, which one of the following must be false?

    • A.Some of the entries that used recycled material lost.
    • B.None of the losing entries used any recycled material.
    • C.The entries that won top prize used recycled material.
    • D.One of the winning entries used no recycled material.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: One of the winning entries used no recycled material.

    If every winning entry used recycled materials, a winning entry that used none cannot exist, so that statement must be false. The universal claim covers winners only and says nothing about losers, so entries with recycled material could have lost, and it could also be that no losing entry used any. Top-prize entries using recycled material is exactly what the claim predicts, so none of these must be false.

  206. Biologist: Frogs in the polluted pond are smaller than frogs in the clean pond, so the pollution is stunting the frogs' growth. Which one of the following, if true, most strengthens the biologist's conclusion?

    • A.Frogs generally grow more slowly in colder water than warmer water.
    • B.The two ponds match closely in temperature, food, and frog species.
    • C.Several frogs living in the clean pond are also rather undersized.
    • D.The polluted pond holds beetles, gnats, and many other small insects.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The two ponds match closely in temperature, food, and frog species.

    If the ponds match in temperature, food and frog species, those factors cannot explain the size difference, leaving pollution as the likeliest cause. The insects in the polluted pond do not rule out any rival explanation. Slower growth in cold water raises a possible rival cause rather than supporting the biologist. Undersized frogs in the clean pond, if anything, weaken the contrast.

  207. Critic: The director's latest film will win the festival's top prize, because it has received the most enthusiastic reviews of any film entered. Which one of the following is an assumption on which the argument depends?

    • A.The festival's top prize has never gone to films with mixed reviews.
    • B.Reviews' praise bears on the qualities by which the prize is judged.
    • C.The director has won the festival's top prize at least once before.
    • D.No other film in the festival got even a single enthusiastic review.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Reviews' praise bears on the qualities by which the prize is judged.

    Enthusiastic reviews predict the prize only if the praise bears on the qualities by which the prize is judged; if judges used unrelated criteria, the most praised film would have no special claim. The argument does not need a record of the prize never going to films with mixed reviews. It allows other films some praise, so it does not need them to have none. The director's past wins play no part in the reasoning.

  208. In the argument, the claim that 'untreated wood rots within a few years in this climate' plays which role? Argument: 'The fence posts were installed five years ago and are still solid. So the posts must have been treated, because untreated wood rots within a few years in this climate.'

    • A.It is an unstated assumption linking treated posts to their long life.
    • B.It is a counterexample the argument raises against the claim that posts rot.
    • C.It is a premise backing the inference that the posts were treated.
    • D.It is the argument's main conclusion, drawn from the posts still being solid.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: It is a premise backing the inference that the posts were treated.

    The argument concludes that the posts were treated, and the claim that untreated wood rots within a few years is offered as evidence for that conclusion, so it is a premise. It is not the main conclusion; that is the claim that the posts were treated. The argument accepts the claim rather than raising it as a counterexample. It is stated outright, so it cannot be an unstated assumption.

  209. Which one of the following contains a flaw in reasoning most similar to that in the argument below? 'This medicine must be safe, because no one in our study reported any side effects.'

    • A.This route must be the fastest, since it covers the shortest distance.
    • B.This restaurant must be superb, since no critic has ever panned it.
    • C.This bridge must be sturdy, since a renowned engineer had designed it.
    • D.This plant must be a weed, since it spreads rapidly across flowerbeds.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: This restaurant must be superb, since no critic has ever panned it.

    The original treats the absence of reported side effects as proof of safety, and the restaurant argument likewise treats the absence of bad reviews as proof of excellence; both take a lack of negative reports as positive proof. The route argument equates distance with speed, the bridge argument rests on the designer's reputation, and the plant argument infers a category from a single trait, so none of these repeats the original flaw.

  210. If the alarm is working, then it sounds whenever smoke is present. The alarm did not sound even though smoke was present. Which one of the following must be true?

    • A.The alarm needs thicker smoke to go off.
    • B.The alarm was out of order at the time.
    • C.The alarm sounds only if smoke is present.
    • D.The alarm has never sounded for smoke.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The alarm was out of order at the time.

    The rule says a working alarm sounds whenever smoke is present, and here smoke was present with no sound, so by the contrapositive the alarm was out of order. A working alarm sounds whenever any smoke is present, so it cannot need thicker smoke than was there. The rule never says the alarm sounds only when there is smoke. One silent episode does not show the alarm has never sounded for smoke.

  211. Nutritionist: People who eat breakfast tend to weigh less than people who skip it, so eating breakfast helps control weight. Which one of the following, if true, most weakens this argument?

    • A.People who eat breakfast are also more likely to work out on most days.
    • B.People who skip breakfast tend to eat a larger lunch later in the day.
    • C.Some people who eat breakfast every day still gain weight over the years.
    • D.People who eat breakfast tend to feel more alert later in the day.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: People who eat breakfast are also more likely to work out on most days.

    If breakfast eaters are also more likely to work out on most days, exercise could explain their lower weight, so the link need not run through breakfast. Skippers eating a larger lunch fits the nutritionist's view that skipping breakfast works against weight control. Some breakfast eaters gaining weight does not touch a claim about what tends to happen across groups. Feeling alert later in the day has no bearing on weight.

  212. All certified guides at the park have completed wilderness first-aid training, and some certified guides also speak a second language. The information above most strongly supports which one of the following?

    • A.Most certified guides at the park speak a second language.
    • B.All park guides with first-aid training are certified guides.
    • C.Some bilingual guides at the park have no first-aid training.
    • D.Some people with first-aid training speak a second language.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Some people with first-aid training speak a second language.

    The certified guides who speak a second language all have first-aid training, so at least some first-aid-trained people speak a second language. 'Some' certified guides being bilingual does not mean most are. The premise says certified guides have the training, not that everyone with the training is certified. Any bilingual guides without the training would have to be uncertified, and nothing says such guides exist.

  213. Speaker: A good knife is one that cuts well. A good person is one who is morally upright. Therefore, a good person cuts well. The reasoning is flawed because it

    • A.Draws a broad conclusion from a sample that is far too small
    • B.Assumes that what is true of each part is true of the whole
    • C.Takes for granted the very conclusion it sets out to prove
    • D.Shifts the sense of one key term partway through the argument
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Shifts the sense of one key term partway through the argument

    'Good' means effective for a knife but morally upright for a person, and the argument slides from one sense to the other to reach its odd conclusion. No sample or survey is involved. The argument does not move from parts to a whole; it moves between two different things called good. Its conclusion is not hidden in its premises, which is why it fails to follow from them.

  214. Argument: The proposal will be approved only if it has the support of the chairperson. The chairperson supports it, so the proposal will be approved. Which one of the following, if assumed, would make the conclusion follow with certainty?

    • A.That no proposal is approved without the chairperson's support
    • B.That the chairperson keeps her support, even during the vote
    • C.That most proposals the chairperson supports get approved
    • D.That the chairperson's support is enough to secure approval
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: That the chairperson's support is enough to secure approval

    The first premise makes the chairperson's support necessary for approval, not sufficient, so her support alone does not guarantee the outcome; adding that her support is enough to secure approval closes that gap and makes the conclusion certain. Saying no proposal is approved without her support only restates the necessary condition already given. Her keeping her support during the vote still leaves support short of a guarantee, and a claim about most proposals yields only probability, not certainty.

  215. Ana: The factory should install the new filters, since clean air is worth any reasonable cost. Boris: The filters cost more than the factory earns in a year, so installing them is not a reasonable cost. Ana and Boris are committed to disagreeing about whether

    • A.The price of the new filters is a reasonable cost
    • B.Clean air is worth any reasonable cost to a factory
    • C.The factory earns enough in a year to buy the filters
    • D.The air near the factory would be cleaner with filters
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The price of the new filters is a reasonable cost

    Ana's case needs the filter price to be a reasonable cost, and Boris says it is not, so that is the point they must disagree on. Boris never denies that clean air is worth a reasonable cost; he denies only that this cost is reasonable. Boris says the filters cost more than a year's earnings, but Ana says nothing about earnings, so she is not committed to the opposite view. Neither speaker questions whether the filters would clean the air.

  216. Principle: A penalty is fair only if those subject to it were warned in advance. A driver was fined for parking in a zone marked by a clearly posted sign. Which one of the following, if true, most supports the conclusion that the fine was fair?

    • A.The sign was plainly visible well before the driver pulled in.
    • B.The sign was put up shortly after the driver had parked there.
    • C.The fine matched the amount charged in other zones of the city.
    • D.The driver had parked in that zone often without being fined.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The sign was plainly visible well before the driver pulled in.

    The principle makes advance warning the condition for a fair penalty, and a sign plainly visible before the driver pulled in supplies that warning. A sign put up after the driver parked gave no advance warning and so cuts against fairness. Matching other fines says nothing about warning. Parking there often without a fine shows only that the rule was not enforced, not that the driver was warned.

  217. No reptiles in the exhibit are venomous. All of the snakes in the exhibit are reptiles. Which one of the following must be true?

    • A.No snake in the exhibit is venomous.
    • B.No animal in the exhibit is venomous.
    • C.Each reptile in the exhibit is a snake.
    • D.Some reptile in the exhibit is a snake.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: No snake in the exhibit is venomous.

    Every snake in the exhibit is a reptile and no reptile there is venomous, so no snake there is venomous. The premises cover only reptiles, so a non-reptile animal in the exhibit could still be venomous. Snakes being reptiles does not make each reptile a snake. The premises never say the exhibit holds any snakes at all, so it does not follow that some reptile there is a snake.

  218. Advisor: To be admitted to the program, an applicant must submit a portfolio. Therefore, anyone who submits a portfolio will be admitted to the program. The reasoning is flawed because it

    • A.Treats a requirement for admission as a guarantee of entry
    • B.Draws a rule about all applicants from one admitted case
    • C.Confuses a link between two events with a proof of cause
    • D.Relies on an advisor's authority in place of evidence
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Treats a requirement for admission as a guarantee of entry

    The premise makes a portfolio a requirement for admission, but the conclusion treats submitting one as a guarantee of getting in. No admitted applicant is offered as a case, so there is no hasty generalization. The argument makes no causal claim from a link between events. The advisor states a requirement rather than resting on personal authority.

  219. Official: Crime in the downtown district fell after we added more streetlights, so the new lights are reducing crime. Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the official's conclusion?

    • A.Crime rose slightly in a district next to downtown with no new lights.
    • B.Residents downtown say they have felt safer since new lights went up.
    • C.The city doubled the police patrols downtown in those exact same months.
    • D.The new downtown lights cost more than city officials had first planned.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The city doubled the police patrols downtown in those exact same months.

    Doubled police patrols downtown in the same months give another cause for the drop, so the lights may not be what reduced crime. Crime rising next door, where no lights were added, if anything makes the downtown lights look more effective. Residents feeling safer fits the official's view rather than weakening it. What the lights cost has nothing to do with whether they cut crime.

  220. Which one of the following is the main conclusion of the argument? 'Since interest rates are expected to rise, borrowing will become more expensive. For that reason, the company should secure its loan now rather than wait. Waiting would only cost it more.'

    • A.Borrowing is going to cost the company more in the near future.
    • B.Interest rates are widely expected to climb over the next months.
    • C.The company should lock in its loan now rather than wait further.
    • D.Delaying the loan would only end up costing the company more.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The company should lock in its loan now rather than wait further.

    The recommendation to secure the loan now is what everything else supports, so it is the main conclusion. Higher borrowing costs are an intermediate step offered as a reason for that recommendation. The expected rise in rates is the starting premise that supports the cost claim. The remark that waiting costs more restates support for acting now rather than being the point itself.

  221. A library reduced its late-return fines to zero, expecting books to be returned later than before. Instead, books were returned sooner on average. Which one of the following, if true, best explains this result?

    • A.Patrons with overdue books had stayed away to avoid a mounting fine.
    • B.Patrons had been returning books early mainly to avoid paying fines.
    • C.Patrons borrowed more books per visit once the fines had been dropped.
    • D.Patrons mostly did not know the library had ever charged late fines.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Patrons with overdue books had stayed away to avoid a mounting fine.

    If patrons with overdue books had stayed away to avoid a mounting fine, dropping fines removed the reason to hold books back, so returns sped up. Patrons who returned early only to avoid fines would have had less reason to hurry once fines ended, which predicts the opposite result. Borrowing more books per visit says nothing about how fast books came back. If patrons never knew about fines, removing them should have changed nothing.

  222. Which one of the following arguments is most similar in its reasoning to the following? 'If the shipment arrives today, the store will restock by evening. The shipment arrived today, so the store will restock by evening.'

    • A.If the gate is open, the dog gets out. The gate is open, so the dog gets out.
    • B.If the gate is open, the dog gets out. The dog got out, so the gate is open.
    • C.If the gate is open, the dog gets out. The gate is shut, so the dog stays in.
    • D.If the gate is open, the dog gets out. The dog stays in, so the gate is shut.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: If the gate is open, the dog gets out. The gate is open, so the dog gets out.

    The original affirms the condition of an if-then statement and concludes its result, and the argument that the gate is open so the dog gets out does exactly that. Concluding the gate is open because the dog got out reasons from the result back to the condition, which is invalid. Concluding the dog stays in because the gate is shut denies the condition, also invalid. Concluding the gate is shut because the dog stays in is valid but runs from a denied result, a different form from the original.

  223. Argument: This painting was created after 1850, so it cannot be by the artist Velasco. Which one of the following is an assumption required by the argument?

    • A.Velasco painted only in styles popular before 1850.
    • B.Velasco's later works were all signed and dated by him.
    • C.Velasco completed no paintings of any kind beyond 1850.
    • D.Velasco's works before 1850 are all well documented.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Velasco completed no paintings of any kind beyond 1850.

    The argument moves from 'made after 1850' to 'not by Velasco', which works only if Velasco produced no paintings after 1850; deny that and the argument collapses. The argument rests on the date alone, so his styles do not matter. Whether his later works were signed is beside the point, since the argument needs there to be no later works at all. How well his pre-1850 works are documented plays no role in the reasoning.

  224. Pollster: We surveyed shoppers leaving the city's luxury department store and found that most support raising the sales tax to fund parks. So most city residents support the tax increase. The reasoning is most vulnerable to criticism because it

    • A.Assumes that a cause of one effect must cause a second effect
    • B.Takes a majority view as proof that the view must be correct
    • C.Draws a conclusion about all residents from an atypical sample
    • D.Treats a lack of evidence against a claim as proof of it
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Draws a conclusion about all residents from an atypical sample

    Luxury-store shoppers are likely wealthier than the average resident and may see a sales tax differently, so their views cannot stand in for the whole city. The argument makes no causal claim. It concludes only what most residents support, not that the tax is a good idea, so it does not treat popularity as proof of truth. It relies on survey results, not on a lack of contrary evidence.

  225. Which one of the following correctly applies conditional reasoning? Premise: 'A student qualifies for the award only if she has perfect attendance.'

    • A.Tara has perfect attendance, so she qualifies for the award.
    • B.Tara qualifies for the award, so her attendance record is perfect.
    • C.Tara does not qualify for the award, so she lacks perfect attendance.
    • D.Tara lacks perfect attendance, so another student wins the award.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Tara qualifies for the award, so her attendance record is perfect.

    'Only if' makes perfect attendance necessary for the award, so if Tara qualifies, her attendance record must be perfect. Having perfect attendance does not guarantee the award, since other conditions may apply. Failing to qualify can happen for other reasons, so it says nothing about her attendance. Tara's own record tells us nothing about whether another student wins.

Reading Comprehension (226)

  1. In a passage discussing the evolution of constitutional law, what would most likely represent a primary source?

    • A.A legal scholar's essay critiquing a major court ruling
    • B.A textbook chapter surveying a century of court rulings
    • C.An encyclopedia entry that recaps a recent court ruling
    • D.The official opinion published in a famous court ruling
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The official opinion published in a famous court ruling

    A primary source is firsthand material from the event itself, and the court's own published opinion is the ruling in its original form. A legal scholar's critical essay is a secondary source because it interprets the ruling from outside. A textbook chapter surveying a century of rulings and an encyclopedia entry recapping one are tertiary summaries built from other accounts, not the decision itself.

  2. When analyzing a passage about economic theories, which of the following clues would indicate the author's bias?

    • A.Allowing the rival schools equal space and a fair hearing
    • B.Openly noting the limits of the numbers behind each point
    • C.Leaving out the results that tell against the chosen view
    • D.Using the common terms that specialists in the field know
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Leaving out the results that tell against the chosen view

    Bias shows when an author drops the results that would weaken the view the author prefers, so the reader sees only the supporting side of the record. Using the standard terms of the field is normal in technical writing and says nothing about slant. Giving rival schools a fair hearing and openly admitting the limits of one's numbers are signs of balance, the opposite of bias.

  3. In a passage discussing environmental conservation efforts, what would be considered an example of a counterargument?

    • A.An expert praising the value of species diversity in forests
    • B.A case study of a marshland initiative achieving its targets
    • C.Data showing that pollution in the rivers has fallen sharply
    • D.A claim that sweeping rules impose heavy costs on landowners
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: A claim that sweeping rules impose heavy costs on landowners

    A counterargument pushes against the passage's main position, and a claim that sweeping rules impose heavy costs on landowners challenges the case for conservation. A wetland initiative that met its targets, falling river pollution, and an expert praising species diversity all support conservation, so none of them argues against it.

  4. What inferential reasoning is necessary to understand an author's implied stance in a passage about historical events?

    • A.Tracking the precise order in which the events occurred
    • B.Reading the connotations of the words the writer favors
    • C.Recording only the stated facts and nothing beyond them
    • D.Memorizing the dates and numbers that the passage gives
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Reading the connotations of the words the writer favors

    An implied stance is never stated outright, so the reader infers it from word choice, and the connotations of the words a writer favors reveal attitude. Tracking the order of events and memorizing dates and numbers are literal comprehension, not inference about the author. Recording only stated facts and refusing to go beyond them rules out the very inference the question asks about.

  5. In a passage analyzing the impact of technology on society, which type of evidence would most effectively support the author's thesis?

    • A.Stories from the author's own life with phones and tablets
    • B.Careful data tying device use to shifts in social behavior
    • C.A timeline of major inventions from the last hundred years
    • D.Guesses about which new gadgets will sell best next decade
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Careful data tying device use to shifts in social behavior

    A thesis about technology's effect on society is best supported by data that ties device use to measurable shifts in social behavior, because that tests the claimed effect directly. Stories from the author's own life are a sample of one and cannot show a social pattern. A timeline of inventions describes the technology rather than its effect, and guesses about which gadgets will sell best are speculation, not evidence.

  6. When evaluating a passage about the philosophical concept of free will, which aspect is critical to understand the argument's structure?

    • A.The era when the debate first began among early thinkers
    • B.Tales of people making minor decisions over a normal day
    • C.How the premises lead step by step toward the conclusion
    • D.The career of the philosopher who first posed the puzzle
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: How the premises lead step by step toward the conclusion

    An argument's structure is the way its premises connect to support its conclusion, so tracing how they lead step by step to that conclusion is what reveals the structure. The philosopher's career and the era in which the debate began are background, not structure. Everyday stories about small decisions are illustrations at most and do not show how the reasoning is built.

  7. In a critique of a modern art movement, how might the author subtly express a negative opinion?

    • A.Choosing faintly mocking words when describing the works
    • B.Listing the museums that display the best-known holdings
    • C.Quoting critics who lauded the artists' strongest pieces
    • D.Recounting a balanced history of the school's beginnings
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Choosing faintly mocking words when describing the works

    A subtle negative opinion is usually carried by word choice, so faintly mocking words let the author disapprove without saying so directly. A balanced history of the school's beginnings expresses no judgment. Quoting critics who praised the artists pushes the reader toward a favorable view, and listing the museums that display the best-known works signals prestige rather than disapproval.

  8. What technique is commonly used in passages to illustrate the practical application of a scientific theory?

    • A.Describing a scenario where the idea fixes a real-world problem
    • B.Explaining in detail how the scientific method works in general
    • C.Listing the credentials of the researchers who endorse the idea
    • D.Recounting how the idea was first formulated and then confirmed
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Describing a scenario where the idea fixes a real-world problem

    To show a theory's practical use, a writer applies it to a concrete case, so a scenario in which the idea fixes a real-world problem illustrates application. Explaining how the scientific method works in general describes science as a whole, not this theory's use. The researchers' credentials are an appeal to authority, and the story of how the idea was formulated and confirmed is history rather than application.

  9. When a passage presents a series of studies on a psychological phenomenon, what should the reader assess to evaluate the argument's strength?

    • A.How often the effect is covered in glossy outlets and blogs
    • B.How well known the lead researchers are to the wider public
    • C.How large the samples were and how the trials were designed
    • D.Whether the results fit what the reader believes to be true
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: How large the samples were and how the trials were designed

    An argument built on studies is only as strong as those studies, and sample size and design are the core measures of their quality. Coverage in glossy outlets and blogs reflects media interest, not reliability. Whether the results fit the reader's existing beliefs has no bearing on whether the evidence is good, and how well known the researchers are to the public is an appeal to reputation rather than to method.

  10. In analyzing a passage that debates the merits of a policy proposal, which element is essential for understanding the opposition's viewpoint?

    • A.The previous policies that served as templates for it
    • B.The economic model its sponsors used when drafting it
    • C.The poll numbers showing how many citizens support it
    • D.The exact objections that its critics make against it
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The exact objections that its critics make against it

    The opposition's viewpoint consists of its reasons for resisting the proposal, so the specific objections its critics make are what a reader must grasp. The earlier policies that served as templates and the economic model the sponsors used explain the proposal itself, not the case against it. Poll numbers on support measure popularity and do not state anyone's reasons for opposing the plan.

  11. When a passage discusses the ethical implications of artificial intelligence, which of the following would most likely be used to challenge the optimistic view of AI's potential?

    • A.Moral arguments about who answers for injuries these systems cause
    • B.Surveys of how quickly businesses abroad are adopting such systems
    • C.Figures on productivity gains in firms that installed such systems
    • D.Forecasts of the advances engineers expect such systems to deliver
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Moral arguments about who answers for injuries these systems cause

    An ethics passage challenges optimism about AI by raising moral problems, and arguments about who is accountable for the injuries these systems cause do exactly that. Productivity gains at adopting firms, forecasts of coming advances, and fast adoption by businesses all reinforce the optimistic view instead of questioning it.

  12. In a passage examining the effects of globalization on local cultures, which approach would the author most likely take to argue that globalization enriches local cultures?

    • A.Statistics showing income growth in regions newly open to trade
    • B.Warnings that regional dialects and old rituals are fading away
    • C.Accounts of native cuisines merging into one bland global style
    • D.Examples of towns blending imported styles with their own music
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Examples of towns blending imported styles with their own music

    To argue that globalization enriches local cultures, an author would show communities absorbing outside influences and reworking them into something of their own, as towns do when they blend imported styles with their own music. Native cuisines merging into one bland style and dialects and rituals fading away describe cultural loss, which supports the opposite thesis. Income growth is an economic measure and cannot show that a culture has been enriched.

  13. In a passage discussing the concept of "universal basic income" (UBI), which type of evidence would most likely be cited to support the argument that UBI could reduce societal inequality?

    • A.Testimonials from recipients describing how the money felt to them
    • B.Models projecting how payments would change the spread of earnings
    • C.Histories of nations that never offered their citizens cash relief
    • D.Opinion polls gauging how many residents truly welcome the program
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Models projecting how payments would change the spread of earnings

    Inequality is a property of how earnings are spread across a whole population, so models projecting how the payments would change that spread speak directly to the claim. Testimonials about how the money felt describe individual experience and cannot show a shift in distribution. Histories of nations without cash relief say nothing about what this program would do, and polls on whether residents would welcome it measure popularity, not effect.

  14. When analyzing a passage about the ethics of genetic editing, which argumentative strategy might the author use to challenge the practice?

    • A.Raising doubts about the lasting effects on later generations
    • B.Reporting the impressive success rates of new clinical trials
    • C.Noting how low-cost tools have made the technique commonplace
    • D.Citing court rulings that let companies patent modified genes
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Raising doubts about the lasting effects on later generations

    A challenge to genetic editing would question its long-range consequences, such as the lasting effects on later generations. That low-cost tools have made the technique commonplace describes its spread, not a reason to oppose it. Court rulings letting companies patent modified genes and impressive success rates in trials make the practice look established and effective, so they support it rather than challenge it.

  15. In a passage evaluating the effectiveness of online education, what would likely be a point of comparison to traditional in-person learning?

    • A.The accreditation held by the colleges that offer web courses
    • B.The energy saved each year by shutting older school buildings
    • C.How students interact with peers and teachers in each setting
    • D.The price of the computers that remote learners must purchase
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: How students interact with peers and teachers in each setting

    Comparing online education with in-person learning calls for a factor present in both formats that bears on how well students learn, and how students interact with peers and teachers in each setting is such a factor. The price of computers concerns only the online side and measures cost, not effectiveness. Accreditation is an administrative status, and energy saved by shutting buildings is an environmental matter rather than a measure of learning.

  16. In a passage discussing climate change mitigation strategies, which factor would be critical in assessing the viability of geoengineering solutions?

    • A.The timeline of when scientists first studied rising temperatures
    • B.The ethical risks of consciously altering the planet's atmosphere
    • C.Surveys measuring how many adults fully understand climate change
    • D.The popularity of weather-control plots in science fiction novels
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The ethical risks of consciously altering the planet's atmosphere

    Judging whether geoengineering is viable requires weighing the risks and moral questions raised by intentionally altering the planet's atmosphere. A timeline of early climate research is history and does not bear on whether the intervention is sound. The popularity of weather-control plots in fiction is irrelevant to real-world feasibility, and surveys of how well adults understand climate change measure public knowledge, not whether the approach is safe or justified.

  17. When a passage explores the role of art in society, which argument might be used to support the claim that art is essential for human development?

    • A.Movements in auction prices for contemporary art since 2010
    • B.A comparison of arts funding across several wealthy nations
    • C.Studies showing that making art aids empathy and creativity
    • D.The number of art galleries and museums operating worldwide
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Studies showing that making art aids empathy and creativity

    A claim that art is essential to human development needs evidence about what art does for people, and studies linking art-making to empathy and creativity supply it. Funding comparisons across nations, auction price trends, and counts of galleries and museums describe the art economy and its institutions, which say nothing about personal growth.

  18. In a passage critiquing economic globalization, what kind of evidence would be used to argue that globalization exacerbates wealth inequality?

    • A.Figures showing profits collecting in a few multinational firms
    • B.Testimonials from shoppers pleased by cheaper goods from abroad
    • C.A tally of countries that have negotiated free-trade agreements
    • D.Stories of cultural exchange sparked by trade across boundaries
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Figures showing profits collecting in a few multinational firms

    To argue that globalization deepens wealth inequality, a critic needs evidence that gains are flowing to a narrow group, such as profits concentrating in a few multinational firms. Shoppers pleased by cheaper imports point to a benefit, not a widening gap. A count of free-trade agreements measures participation, and stories of cultural exchange concern culture rather than how wealth is distributed.

  19. When a passage delves into the psychology of decision-making, what concept might be discussed to explain why individuals often make irrational choices?

    • A.The link between high IQ scores and decision-making speed
    • B.Mental shortcuts and biases that distort how people judge
    • C.The importance of formal logic in solving geometry proofs
    • D.The history of laboratory methods and tools in psychology
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Mental shortcuts and biases that distort how people judge

    Irrational choices are explained by cognitive biases and mental shortcuts that pull judgment away from what careful reasoning would recommend. Formal logic in geometry proofs is an example of rational problem-solving, not a departure from it. The history of laboratory methods concerns how psychology is done, and a link between IQ and decision speed concerns how fast people choose, not why their choices go wrong.

  20. In a passage analyzing the intersection of technology and privacy, which argument might be presented to caution against the unchecked use of surveillance technologies?

    • A.The progress made in encryption and protected data storage
    • B.The drop in street crime recorded in watched neighborhoods
    • C.The modest price of camera networks for police departments
    • D.The risk that steady monitoring wears away civil liberties
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The risk that steady monitoring wears away civil liberties

    A caution against unchecked surveillance would stress the danger that constant monitoring erodes privacy and civil liberties. A modest price for camera networks and a drop in crime in monitored neighborhoods are arguments in favor of expanding surveillance. Progress in encryption and data storage concerns protecting information, which does not warn against the monitoring itself.

  21. When a passage discusses the dynamics of political power shifts in historical contexts, which factor is crucial for understanding the causes and effects of these shifts?

    • A.The building and monument styles that each regime favored
    • B.The firearms and uniforms carried by the competing armies
    • C.The personal routines and tastes of the monarchs involved
    • D.The broad social and ideological forces behind the change
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The broad social and ideological forces behind the change

    The causes and effects of a shift in political power are explained by the broad social, economic, and ideological forces that made the change possible and that it then reshaped. The firearms and uniforms of rival armies are surface details of conflict, not root causes. The rulers' personal routines and tastes and the building styles regimes favored are matters of personality and taste that do not explain why power moved.

  22. In evaluating a passage on the role of non-governmental organizations (NGOs) in global health initiatives, which evidence would best support the argument that NGOs are crucial in addressing health disparities?

    • A.The foreign laws that govern how such groups register abroad
    • B.The combined budgets that sponsors gave the groups last year
    • C.The total count of aid groups active in international health
    • D.Case studies where these groups curbed illness in poor areas
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Case studies where these groups curbed illness in poor areas

    The claim that NGOs are crucial to closing health gaps is best supported by evidence that their work actually reduced illness where care was lacking, which case studies from poor areas provide. A count of active groups and the size of their combined budgets show scale, not results. The laws governing how such groups register describe their legal status and say nothing about their effect on health.

  23. When a passage explores the ethical dilemmas of artificial intelligence in warfare, which philosophical question is likely to be central to the debate?

    • A.Which new arms engineers are likely to build in coming years
    • B.Who bears moral blame when a machine resorts to lethal force
    • C.How much of the military budget should go to robotic systems
    • D.How inventions like the tank changed the course of past wars
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Who bears moral blame when a machine resorts to lethal force

    The central ethical question about AI in war is accountability: who bears moral responsibility when an autonomous machine uses lethal force. Which weapons engineers will build next is a technical forecast. How much of the military budget should fund robotic systems is a fiscal question, and how the tank changed past wars is military history, so neither is the core philosophical issue.

  24. In a passage discussing the conservation of endangered languages, which argument might be used to emphasize the importance of this issue?

    • A.The heritage and knowledge that vanish with each dying tongue
    • B.The rise of English as the language of international business
    • C.The popularity of apps and courses that teach major languages
    • D.The overall number of languages spoken around the world today
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The heritage and knowledge that vanish with each dying tongue

    The case for preserving endangered languages rests on what is lost when one disappears: heritage and knowledge that vanish along with the language. The total number of languages spoken today is a bare statistic, not an argument. The rise of English in business explains why small languages decline rather than why they matter, and apps that teach major languages do nothing for endangered ones.

  25. When analyzing a passage on the impact of climate change on agricultural practices, which factor would be essential to consider in assessing adaptation strategies?

    • A.Developing crop strains that can withstand drought and heat
    • B.Tracking which grain brands sell best in urban supermarkets
    • C.Surveying which recipes are favored in the affected regions
    • D.Studying how farmers in ancient societies plowed their land
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Developing crop strains that can withstand drought and heat

    Adapting agriculture to a changing climate means helping crops cope with new conditions, so developing strains that withstand drought and heat addresses the problem directly. How ancient farmers plowed is historical interest, not a response to present conditions. Which recipes are favored and which grain brands sell best describe consumer taste, not how farms can keep producing under climate stress.

  26. In a passage critiquing the gig economy, what might be argued as a major drawback of this economic model?

    • A.The freedom workers have to choose their own hours
    • B.The new app-based models that the firms have built
    • C.The lack of reliable pay and benefits for couriers
    • D.The wider choice and ease that customers now enjoy
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The lack of reliable pay and benefits for couriers

    The main criticism of the gig economy is that its workers go without steady pay, job security, and benefits such as health coverage. The freedom to choose one's own hours is the model's chief selling point to workers. The firms' app-based business models and the wider choice and ease customers enjoy are presented as advantages, so neither is a drawback.

  27. When a passage examines the concept of "digital nomadism," which aspect is likely to be highlighted as a societal implication?

    • A.The paperwork needed to get a long-stay work visa abroad
    • B.The beach towns and cities that rank as top destinations
    • C.The internet bandwidth needed to work well from a laptop
    • D.A shift in how people define the workplace and community
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: A shift in how people define the workplace and community

    A societal implication is a change in how society is organized, and digital nomadism changes how people define the workplace and the community they belong to. The bandwidth needed to work from a laptop and the paperwork for a long-stay visa are practical requirements for an individual traveler. A list of top destinations is information about where nomads go, not a consequence for society.

  28. In discussing the role of public art in urban spaces, which perspective might be used to argue for its significance?

    • A.Whether residents tend to like abstract or lifelike works
    • B.Its power to draw neighbors together around shared issues
    • C.The rivalry among big cities to commission famous artists
    • D.The ongoing upkeep costs of sculptures and outdoor murals
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Its power to draw neighbors together around shared issues

    Public art's significance is usually argued from its social role, such as drawing neighbors together around shared issues and giving voice to them. Upkeep costs are a point about expense, if anything against it. Whether residents like abstract or lifelike works is a question of taste, and cities competing to commission famous artists concerns prestige rather than why the art matters to a community.

  29. In a passage about the future of space exploration, which argument might be presented to support the prioritization of manned missions to Mars?

    • A.The many past successes of robotic rovers and orbiting probes
    • B.The profits companies expect from short tourist hops to orbit
    • C.The prospect of human crews settling and doing research there
    • D.The funds that agencies have set aside for weather satellites
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The prospect of human crews settling and doing research there

    Prioritizing crewed missions to Mars is argued from what only people on the planet could achieve, namely settlement and hands-on research. The past successes of robotic rovers and probes suggest machines can do the work without crews, which argues the other way. Funds for weather satellites and profits from short tourist hops to orbit concern near-Earth activity, not Mars.

  30. In a passage about the ethical implications of autonomous vehicles, which argument might be used to question the reliance on AI decision-making in critical situations?

    • A.The dilemma of programming vehicles to decide who should survive
    • B.The gains in traffic flow that driverless vehicles would deliver
    • C.The sensor and mapping advances that made such vehicles possible
    • D.The claim that software handles crashes more fairly than drivers
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The dilemma of programming vehicles to decide who should survive

    Doubt about letting AI decide in emergencies centers on the moral dilemma of programming a vehicle to choose who survives a crash. Gains in traffic flow are a benefit that has nothing to do with life-and-death decisions. The claim that software handles crashes more fairly than drivers supports relying on AI, and advances in sensors and mapping explain how the vehicles work, not whether their choices should be trusted.

  31. When a passage examines the impact of social media on democracy, which evidence might be cited to argue that social media undermines democratic processes?

    • A.The way politicians post updates straight to their voters
    • B.The spread of false stories within closed partisan groups
    • C.The ease with which activists can organize rallies online
    • D.The increase in youth turnout attributed to the platforms
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The spread of false stories within closed partisan groups

    To argue that social media weakens democracy, a critic would point to false stories spreading inside closed partisan groups, which misleads voters and deepens divisions. Easy online organizing by activists, higher youth turnout, and politicians communicating straight to voters all show social media strengthening participation, so they support the opposite view.

  32. In analyzing a passage on the preservation of indigenous languages, which strategy might be highlighted as effective in revitalizing these languages?

    • A.Statutes compelling classrooms to use only the official language
    • B.Museum exhibits that play archived recordings of departed elders
    • C.Grammar studies by outside scholars printed in research journals
    • D.Immersion classes teaching young children in the heritage tongue
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Immersion classes teaching young children in the heritage tongue

    Revitalization means creating new speakers, and immersion classes that teach children in the heritage language are the most widely cited way to do it. Grammar studies printed in research journals document a language but do not produce speakers. Statutes forcing classrooms to use only the official language push the heritage language out, and museum recordings of elders preserve it as an archive rather than returning it to daily use.

  33. When a passage delves into the psychological effects of isolation, what might be argued as a long-term impact on individual behavior?

    • A.Lasting fear and tension when rejoining groups of people
    • B.A complete return to former patterns once isolation ends
    • C.A short-lived burst of new interests fading within weeks
    • D.Brief boredom that disappears as soon as routines resume
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Lasting fear and tension when rejoining groups of people

    The stem asks for a long-term effect, and lasting fear and tension when rejoining other people is the enduring harm usually linked to prolonged isolation. A complete return to former patterns once isolation ends describes no lasting change at all. Brief boredom that disappears when routines resume and a short-lived burst of new interests are temporary by their own terms, so they cannot be long-term impacts.

  34. In a passage discussing the concept of sustainable urban development, which factor would be essential for creating resilient cities?

    • A.Preserving the classic design styles of the downtown skyline
    • B.Increasing parks and tree cover while adding renewable power
    • C.Stimulating the annual growth rate of the provincial economy
    • D.Restoring historic landmarks to draw more tourists each year
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Increasing parks and tree cover while adding renewable power

    Resilient cities rely on parks and tree cover that absorb heat and storm water and on renewable power that keeps running when distant supplies fail. Preserving the skyline's design styles is an aesthetic goal. Restoring landmarks to draw tourists is heritage and tourism policy, and a faster economic growth rate can strain resources as easily as it builds resilience.

  35. When examining the challenges of implementing universal healthcare, which argument might be presented to highlight a potential barrier?

    • A.The savings that annual preventive checkups bring over time
    • B.The new medical devices that are improving patient outcomes
    • C.The expense and logistics of covering the entire population
    • D.The polls showing wide public support for national coverage
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The expense and logistics of covering the entire population

    A barrier is something that makes a policy hard to put in place, and the expense and logistics of covering an entire population are the standard obstacle to universal healthcare. Savings from preventive checkups and wide public support are arguments for the policy. New medical devices improve care in general and do not stand in the way of implementing universal coverage.

  36. In a passage about the role of public art in societal healing, which example might be used to illustrate its therapeutic impact?

    • A.Higher property values on blocks beside new art installations
    • B.A lengthy dispute over a monument protesters wanted relocated
    • C.Mural projects in which neighborhood residents help to create
    • D.Rising tourist revenue from the city's most famous sculptures
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Mural projects in which neighborhood residents help to create

    A healing effect comes from shared participation, so mural projects that neighborhood residents help create show public art working through collective expression. Tourist revenue and higher property values are economic effects, not healing. A lengthy dispute over a monument shows public art dividing a community, the opposite of the healing the passage describes.

  37. When discussing the impact of dietary choices on environmental sustainability, which dietary practice might be advocated to reduce one's carbon footprint?

    • A.Choosing packaged meals sealed in layers of plastic
    • B.Eating mostly plants in place of animal-based foods
    • C.Buying asparagus flown in from overseas each winter
    • D.Switching to beef raised on big commercial feedlots
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Eating mostly plants in place of animal-based foods

    Animal foods, especially beef, produce far more greenhouse gas per calorie than plant foods, so eating mostly plants is the practice most often advocated to shrink a diet's carbon footprint. Switching to feedlot beef raises emissions. Packaged meals sealed in plastic add manufacturing and packaging waste, and produce flown in from overseas each winter is among the most carbon-intensive ways to buy food.

  38. In a passage analyzing the effects of global trade on local economies, which consequence might be highlighted as a negative outcome?

    • A.Hometown mills closing as foreign firms take over
    • B.A broader variety of goods on supermarket shelves
    • C.Cultural exchange carried along by new trade ties
    • D.Lower prices as more sellers compete for shoppers
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Hometown mills closing as foreign firms take over

    A negative outcome of global trade for local economies is the loss of home industries as larger foreign competitors move in, which costs jobs and local businesses. A broader variety of goods and lower prices from competition are benefits to consumers. Cultural exchange is a social side effect, not an economic harm.

  39. When evaluating a passage on the historical significance of public libraries, which role might be emphasized as a key contribution to community development?

    • A.Housing rare old manuscripts for scholars to study
    • B.Opening free learning to residents of every income
    • C.Raising grand halls that later grew into landmarks
    • D.Drawing steady public funds to keep up collections
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Opening free learning to residents of every income

    A passage on community development would stress that libraries opened free learning to residents of every income, spreading education and narrowing social gaps. Keeping rare manuscripts serves scholars and preservation rather than the wider community. Grand halls are an architectural legacy, not a change in how residents develop, and the public money spent on upkeep is a cost to the community, not a contribution to it.

  40. In a passage critiquing the fast fashion industry, which argument might be used to discuss its environmental impact?

    • A.Low pay given to garment workers in poorer nations
    • B.Heavy ad spending on social media to target youths
    • C.Cheap prices that let poorer buyers dress in style
    • D.Fast trend cycles that push buyers to toss clothes
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Fast trend cycles that push buyers to toss clothes

    An environmental critique would point to fast trend cycles that push buyers to toss clothes, which drives textile waste and resource use. Low pay for garment workers is a labor and social problem, not an environmental one. Ad spending aimed at young people is a marketing practice, and cheap prices that widen access are usually raised in the industry's defense rather than as environmental harm.

  41. Passage: Until the 1970s, most historians of the American whaling industry treated its decline as a simple story of resource exhaustion: too many ships chased too few whales. Recent scholarship complicates this account. By examining insurance ledgers and port records, these historians show that whaling firms were already shifting capital into petroleum and railroads decades before whale populations collapsed. The industry did not so much die as quietly reallocate its money. Question: Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?

    • A.Insurance ledgers and port records are the most reliable sources on industrial decline.
    • B.Whaling firms moved into petroleum and railroads because those paid better than whaling.
    • C.Newer studies recast whaling's decline as capital moving elsewhere, not merely as depletion.
    • D.Whale stocks in fact collapsed decades earlier than most historians had once believed.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Newer studies recast whaling's decline as capital moving elsewhere, not merely as depletion.

    The passage presents the older view of resource exhaustion and then revises it with evidence that whaling firms moved capital into other industries, so the main point is that newer studies recast the decline as capital moving elsewhere, not merely as depletion. The ledgers and port records are the evidence used, not a claim about which sources are most reliable. The passage gives no reason for the move into petroleum and railroads, and it says the shift came before the whale collapse without dating the collapse earlier than historians believed.

  42. Passage: Some ecologists argue that wildfire suppression in western forests has been counterproductive. By preventing the frequent, low-intensity fires that historically cleared underbrush, decades of suppression have allowed fuel to accumulate. When fires do break out, they burn hotter and spread faster than the ecosystems evolved to withstand. Paradoxically, the policy meant to protect forests has made catastrophic fire more likely. Question: The primary purpose of the passage is to

    • A.argue that western forest managers should end fire suppression and let every fire burn
    • B.describe how frequent small fires in earlier times used to clear the forest underbrush
    • C.defend the policy of forest fire suppression against the criticism of a few ecologists
    • D.explain how a forest protection policy may have raised the danger of destructive fires
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: explain how a forest protection policy may have raised the danger of destructive fires

    The whole passage builds to one paradox: suppression, meant to protect forests, may have made catastrophic fire more likely, so its purpose is to explain that backfire. It never recommends ending suppression or letting fires burn, so that goes beyond the text. The note about small fires clearing underbrush is supporting detail, not the point. And the author reports the ecologists' criticism with apparent agreement rather than defending suppression against it.

  43. Passage: The composer Hildegard of Bingen is often celebrated today as a lone genius working in isolation. But this portrait, however flattering, obscures more than it reveals. Hildegard led a community of women who copied her manuscripts, performed her music, and almost certainly shaped it. To call her a solitary visionary is to erase the very people who made her work survive. Question: Which one of the following most accurately describes the author's attitude toward the popular portrayal of Hildegard as a lone genius?

    • A.Grudging admiration
    • B.Detached neutrality
    • C.Pointed disapproval
    • D.Guarded endorsement
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Pointed disapproval

    The author says the lone-genius portrait obscures more than it reveals and erases the women who made Hildegard's work survive, which is pointed disapproval. Calling the portrait flattering describes how it treats Hildegard; it is not the author admiring it, grudgingly or otherwise. Words like erase are too charged for detached neutrality. Nothing in the passage endorses the portrayal, even with reservations.

  44. Passage: Economist: Critics claim that raising the minimum wage always reduces employment. Yet several careful studies of neighboring counties, one that raised its wage and one that did not, found no measurable difference in employment afterward. These findings do not prove that wage increases never cost jobs, but they should make us skeptical of sweeping claims that such increases inevitably do. Question: Which one of the following can most reasonably be inferred from the economist's statements?

    • A.The employment impact of a higher minimum may vary more than critics concede
    • B.Raising the wage now has little effect on employment in most local economies
    • C.Studies of neighboring counties are the best way to measure these job losses
    • D.Minimum wage increases tend to raise employment in the areas that adopt them
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The employment impact of a higher minimum may vary more than critics concede

    The economist says the county studies do not prove that wage increases never cost jobs, but they undercut the claim that increases always do, so the employment impact may vary more than critics concede. Saying the wage now has little effect in most local economies generalizes far past a few county comparisons. The economist calls the studies careful but never ranks them as the best method. And the studies found no difference in employment, which gives no support to the claim that increases raise it.

  45. Passage: Passage A: Open-plan offices, proponents argue, dissolve the barriers that stifle collaboration. When colleagues sit shoulder to shoulder, ideas flow freely and innovation accelerates. Passage B: Surveys of workers in newly opened-up offices tell a different story. Many report retreating into headphones and email precisely to recover the privacy the design took away. The open plan, it turns out, can suppress the very exchanges it was meant to encourage. Question: Which one of the following most accurately describes the relationship between the two passages?

    • A.Passage B extends the argument of Passage A with supporting survey data
    • B.Passage B provides evidence that challenges the claim made in Passage A
    • C.Passage A anticipates and then rebuts the objection raised in Passage B
    • D.Passage B explains the historical origins of the trend that A describes
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Passage B provides evidence that challenges the claim made in Passage A

    Passage A claims open plans boost collaboration, and Passage B reports surveys showing that they can suppress it, so B challenges A. B's survey data cuts against A's argument rather than extending it. A never mentions any objection, so it cannot rebut one. B describes how workers respond now and offers no history of the trend.

  46. Passage: Passage A argues that public funding for the arts is justified because art generates measurable economic returns through tourism and local spending. Passage B contends that justifying art by its economic output concedes too much: it implies that art with no commercial payoff deserves no support, abandoning the works most in need of public defense. Question: Which one of the following best characterizes how Passage B responds to Passage A?

    • A.Passage B accepts A's economic figures but doubts how those figures were gathered
    • B.Passage B argues that public funding for the arts should be eliminated altogether
    • C.Passage B supplies extra economic evidence to support the conclusion of Passage A
    • D.Passage B objects that the economic case in A leaves noncommercial art undefended
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Passage B objects that the economic case in A leaves noncommercial art undefended

    Passage B says that justifying art by its economic output implies that art with no commercial payoff deserves no support, so A's case leaves noncommercial work undefended. B never questions how A's figures were gathered; its objection is to the kind of justification. B wants to protect art that lacks a payoff, not end funding. And B offers no economic evidence at all.

  47. Passage: For most of the twentieth century, linguists assumed that a child learning two languages from birth would inevitably lag behind monolingual peers. The reasoning seemed sound: two systems to master must mean slower progress in each. Yet longitudinal studies have repeatedly failed to confirm this. Bilingual children reach the major milestones of each language on roughly the same schedule as monolingual children, even if their vocabulary in any single language is smaller at a given moment. Question: The passage is structured to

    • A.describe a hypothesis about how bilingual children learn and then evidence backing it
    • B.argue that bilingual children outdo their monolingual peers in every area of language
    • C.trace how two rival theories of child language learning developed across that century
    • D.introduce an assumption that once seemed sound and then some evidence undercutting it
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: introduce an assumption that once seemed sound and then some evidence undercutting it

    The passage states the old belief that bilingual children must lag, notes that the reasoning seemed sound, and then reports studies that failed to confirm it. The studies undercut the belief rather than backing it. The author grants that bilingual vocabulary in a single language may be smaller, so there is no claim of superiority in every area. Only one assumption and the evidence against it appear, not two rival theories.

  48. Passage: The author writes: Defenders of the new zoning law point to the dozens of affordable units it has produced. But to praise a policy for building a few hundred apartments in a city short by a hundred thousand is to mistake a teaspoon for a flood. Question: The phrase mistake a teaspoon for a flood functions primarily to

    • A.emphasize how small the law's output is against the actual needs
    • B.concede that the law has produced a sizable number of apartments
    • C.suggest that the size of the city's housing shortage is inflated
    • D.propose a specific number of units the city should build instead
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: emphasize how small the law's output is against the actual needs

    A teaspoon set against a flood dramatizes the gap between a few hundred apartments and a shortage of a hundred thousand, so the image emphasizes how small the output is. The author is dismissive of the output, not conceding that it is sizable. The shortage figure is stated as fact and never questioned. No target for new building is proposed.

  49. Passage: Archaeologists once read the absence of weapons in certain ancient graves as proof that the buried individuals were not warriors. Newer analyses urge caution. Burial customs varied, and the choice of what to inter with the dead often reflected ritual or status rather than occupation. A grave without a sword tells us what the mourners chose to bury, not necessarily how the deceased lived. Question: Which one of the following principles is most clearly illustrated by the passage's reasoning?

    • A.Newer readings of past evidence are generally more reliable than the older ones were
    • B.Grave goods should be disregarded entirely as evidence about how the dead once lived
    • C.What is absent from evidence may reflect decisions rather than the facts in question
    • D.Burial customs remain the clearest available guide to the social station of the dead
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: What is absent from evidence may reflect decisions rather than the facts in question

    The passage argues that a grave without a sword shows what mourners chose to bury, not how the person lived, so an absence may reflect decisions rather than the fact in question. The newer analyses win on their reasoning, not because newer readings are generally better. The passage says grave goods do not necessarily reveal occupation, which stops well short of disregarding them entirely. It mentions status as one thing burials may reflect but never calls customs the clearest guide to it.

  50. Passage: A strong strategy for the Reading Comprehension section is to read for structure before chasing details. Before answering any question, a test taker should be able to state, in a sentence, what the passage is doing: what claim it advances, where it shifts, and how the author feels about the subject. Readers who track these features answer questions faster than those who merely highlight facts, because most questions test the passage's architecture rather than its trivia. Question: According to the passage, why does reading for structure improve performance on Reading Comprehension questions?

    • A.Because the details of a passage seldom bear on the argument it advocates
    • B.Because most questions test how a passage is built rather than its trivia
    • C.Because readers who highlight details tend to run out of time too quickly
    • D.Because readers who note structure rarely need to reread a passage at all
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Because most questions test how a passage is built rather than its trivia

    The last sentence gives the reason directly: structure readers do better because most questions test a passage's architecture rather than its trivia. The passage never says details seldom bear on the argument. It says highlighters answer more slowly, not that they run out of time. Rereading is never discussed.

  51. Passage: The novelist insists in interviews that her fiction is apolitical, mere storytelling with no agenda. Her novels, however, return again and again to characters crushed by indifferent bureaucracies and rescued, when they are rescued at all, by acts of private kindness. Whatever she says about her intentions, the books themselves make an argument. Question: Which one of the following can most reasonably be inferred about the author's view of the novelist's claim that her fiction is apolitical?

    • A.The author thinks the novelist is knowingly lying to those who interview her
    • B.The author concedes that the novels carry no political viewpoint of any kind
    • C.The author holds that the fiction conveys a view whatever its writer intends
    • D.The author regards the recurring themes of the books as accidental and empty
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The author holds that the fiction conveys a view whatever its writer intends

    The closing line, whatever she says about her intentions, the books themselves make an argument, shows the author finds a viewpoint in the novels regardless of intent. That phrasing sets her intentions aside rather than accusing her of lying. The author rejects, not concedes, the claim that the work has no political viewpoint. Themes that return again and again are treated as the substance of the argument, not as accidents.

  52. Passage: The author describes a debate over a proposed dam and then writes: It is worth pausing here to consider the testimony of the downstream farmers, whose fields the project would flood. The two paragraphs that follow summarize the farmers' objections in detail before the author returns to the engineers' case. Question: The reference to the testimony of the downstream farmers most likely serves to

    • A.resolve the debate conclusively in favor of the farmers whose farmland would flood
    • B.introduce a view that complicates the engineers' case shortly before it is resumed
    • C.supply technical detail that supports the engineers' case for building the new dam
    • D.briefly summarize the author's whole argument before the debate on the dam resumes
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: introduce a view that complicates the engineers' case shortly before it is resumed

    The author pauses on the farmers' objections and then returns to the engineers, so the testimony adds a complicating perspective in the middle of the argument. Because the engineers' case is taken up again, the testimony does not resolve the debate. The farmers' objections cut against the engineers rather than supplying technical support. And one group's testimony is not a summary of the author's whole argument.

  53. Passage: Critics of standardized testing often claim the tests measure nothing but test-taking skill. This objection proves too much. By its logic, any assessment, an essay, an interview, a portfolio review, measures only the skill of performing well in that format. If success on a measure disqualifies it as a measure, then nothing could ever assess anything. Question: The author responds to the critics of standardized testing primarily by

    • A.showing that consistent use of the critics' reasoning would discredit every form of assessment
    • B.conceding that standardized tests actually measure nothing more than the knack for taking them
    • C.citing statistical evidence that test scores reliably predict later success in school and work
    • D.arguing that essays and interviews gauge real ability less reliably than standardized tests do
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: showing that consistent use of the critics' reasoning would discredit every form of assessment

    The author extends the critics' reasoning to essays, interviews, and portfolios to show that, applied consistently, it would disqualify every measure, a reduction to absurdity. The author rejects the critics' claim rather than conceding it. No statistical evidence about predicting success is offered. The other formats are named to show the logic hits them equally, not to rank them below standardized tests.

  54. Passage: Two researchers studied why people abandon online shopping carts. The first concluded that surprise shipping costs were the dominant cause and recommended showing all costs upfront. The second found that shoppers often abandon carts deliberately, using them as a way to save items for later, and warned against treating every abandonment as a lost sale. Question: The main point of disagreement between the two researchers is best described as whether

    • A.every abandoned cart should be recorded as a sale the retailer lost
    • B.showing costs upfront would cut how many sales are lost at checkout
    • C.some shoppers treat online carts as a convenient spot to save items
    • D.surprise shipping fees push many shoppers to give up on their carts
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: every abandoned cart should be recorded as a sale the retailer lost

    The second researcher warns against treating every abandonment as a lost sale, which is how the first researcher's framing treats it, so that is the point in dispute. Only the first researcher speaks to showing costs upfront or to surprise shipping fees, and the second never denies either. Only the second mentions shoppers saving items, and the first never denies that. A disagreement needs both researchers to take opposing positions on the same point.

  55. Passage: The legal doctrine of adverse possession allows a person who openly occupies another's land for a long enough period to eventually gain legal title. Defenders argue the rule rewards productive use of land and punishes owners who neglect their property. Detractors counter that it effectively legalizes a slow-motion theft, transferring ownership from the inattentive to the bold. Question: Which one of the following pairs of words best captures the contrast the passage draws between defenders and detractors of adverse possession?

    • A.Careless owners versus bold occupiers
    • B.Formal title versus actual possession
    • C.Lengthy tenure versus brief occupancy
    • D.Productive use versus legalized theft
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Productive use versus legalized theft

    Defenders say the doctrine rewards productive use, while detractors call it a slow-motion theft, so that pair captures the contrast between the two sides. Careless owners and bold occupiers are the two parties both sides talk about, not the difference between their views. Title and possession describe how the doctrine works, which both sides accept. The passage never contrasts long with brief occupancy; the long period is common ground.

  56. Passage: When a passage opens by describing a widely held belief and the author later writes but the evidence points elsewhere, the careful reader should expect the remainder of the passage to challenge that belief. Tracking these structural signposts, words like however, yet, and in fact, lets a reader predict where an argument is heading before reaching the details. Question: Which one of the following best states the passage's recommendation for approaching a Reading Comprehension passage?

    • A.Read each detail closely before trying to see the overall argument
    • B.Skip the opening because a passage's first claim is often rejected
    • C.Use signpost words to predict where the author's argument is going
    • D.Read the questions beforehand so key details can be located easily
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Use signpost words to predict where the author's argument is going

    The passage recommends tracking words like however, yet, and in fact to predict where an argument is heading. It puts structure ahead of detail, the reverse of reading every detail closely first. The opening belief is what the rest of the passage responds to, so skipping it would lose the frame even when that belief is later challenged. Reading the questions first is never mentioned.

  57. Passage: Historians long credited a single inventor with the spinning jenny, but the records suggest a messier truth. Several workshops in the same region were experimenting with multi-spindle frames in the same decade, and the surviving patents may reflect who reached the clerk's office first rather than who built the first working machine. Question: Suppose it were discovered that one of the rival workshops had a fully operational multi-spindle frame two years before the patented version. This discovery would most directly

    • A.prove that the patented inventor appropriated the design from the rival workshop
    • B.support the author's suggestion that patents may not identify the first inventor
    • C.undermine the passage's claim that several workshops were working on such frames
    • D.confirm that the credited inventor had built the earliest working spinning frame
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: support the author's suggestion that patents may not identify the first inventor

    An operational rival frame two years before the patented one fits the passage's suggestion that patents record who reached the clerk first, not who built first. Building earlier does not show copying, so it cannot prove the design was appropriated. A working rival frame supports, rather than undermines, the claim that several workshops were at work on such frames. And it shows the credited inventor was not first.

  58. Passage: For decades, biographers portrayed the Romantic poet as a recluse who shunned all collaboration. Letters recently recovered from a provincial archive tell a different story. They show the poet circulating draft stanzas among a small circle of friends, soliciting line-by-line criticism, and revising heavily in response. The image of solitary genius, it seems, owes more to later admirers than to the poet himself. Question: Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?

    • A.The poet's letters show he sought criticism, which overturns that old portrait of solitude.
    • B.The poet's letters sat in a provincial archive, which explains why biographers missed them.
    • C.Later admirers hid the poet's letters, which kept his image as a recluse alive for years.
    • D.The poet revised more than his peers did, which set his letters and stanzas apart.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The poet's letters show he sought criticism, which overturns that old portrait of solitude.

    The passage sets out the recluse portrait, then uses the letters of shared drafts and requested criticism to overturn it, so that reversal is its main point. The passage says the letters were recently recovered from a provincial archive but offers no account of why biographers missed them. It credits later admirers with the image but never says they hid anything. It makes no comparison between the poet and his peers.

  59. Passage: Defenders of the new bike-share program point to its rising ridership as proof of success. But ridership numbers alone cannot settle the question. A program could attract many riders while still failing its stated goal of reducing car trips, if most of its users would otherwise have walked or taken the bus. To judge the program fairly, we must ask what its riders would have done in its absence. Question: The primary purpose of the passage is to

    • A.Argue that the program has failed to cut the number of car trips in the city
    • B.Warn that higher ridership alone does not show the program has met its goal
    • C.Show that most riders would otherwise have walked or taken a bus instead
    • D.Explain how the city counts riders and car trips for the bike-share program
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Warn that higher ridership alone does not show the program has met its goal

    The author grants that ridership is rising but says the numbers cannot show whether car trips fell, and proposes a better test, so the aim is to caution. The author never concludes that the program failed; the question is left open. Riders who would have walked or taken the bus are raised as a possibility, not shown to be the majority. Nothing is said about how the city counts riders or car trips.

  60. Passage: Passage A: Mandatory recycling laws are the most effective tool for cutting household waste, because legal requirements change behavior where voluntary appeals fail. Passage B: Recycling mandates often backfire. When forced to sort waste, residents resent the burden and comply carelessly, contaminating recyclable streams so badly that much of the material ends up in landfills anyway. Question: Which one of the following most accurately describes the relationship between the two passages?

    • A.Passage B adds evidence that supports the conclusion Passage A draws about mandates.
    • B.Passage B rejects the goal of reducing waste that Passage A treats as worthwhile.
    • C.Passage B questions the effectiveness that Passage A claims for mandatory recycling.
    • D.Passage B restates the case that Passage A makes for mandates in other words.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Passage B questions the effectiveness that Passage A claims for mandatory recycling.

    Passage A calls mandates the most effective tool, and Passage B argues they backfire through careless sorting, so B challenges A's claim of effectiveness. B's contamination point cuts against A, so it is not added support. B objects to mandates as a means and never questions the goal of cutting waste. B argues the opposite of A, so it is not a restatement.

  61. Passage: The author writes: Supporters of the highway expansion promise it will end congestion. History suggests otherwise. Time and again, adding lanes has drawn out latent demand, filling the new capacity almost as fast as it appears, until the widened road is as clogged as the old one. Question: Which one of the following can most reasonably be inferred from the passage?

    • A.Widening a highway can fail to relieve jams, since added room draws more cars.
    • B.Widening a highway will end congestion for good, since latent demand fades in time.
    • C.Widening a highway will cost more than promised, since busy roads wear out faster.
    • D.Ending highway congestion requires discouraging driving, since new lanes fill up.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Widening a highway can fail to relieve jams, since added room draws more cars.

    The author says added lanes draw out latent demand until the road is clogged again, which supports the claim that widening can fail to relieve jams. The passage says the opposite of latent demand fading. Cost and road wear are never discussed. The passage shows why widening falls short but never says discouraging driving is required to end congestion.

  62. Passage: Critics dismiss graphic novels as a lesser form, suitable only for readers unwilling to tackle real literature. This complaint reveals more about the critics than about the form. The best graphic novels demand a sophisticated reading that integrates word and image, a skill many prose readers never develop. To call such work simple is to confess one has not learned how to read it. Question: The author's attitude toward critics of graphic novels can best be described as

    • A.Sympathetic, regarding their complaint as partly fair though overstated
    • B.Dismissive, regarding their complaint as a symptom of their own inexperience
    • C.Neutral, regarding their complaint as one view among several reasonable ones
    • D.Hopeful, regarding their complaint as likely to fade once they read more
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Dismissive, regarding their complaint as a symptom of their own inexperience

    The author says the complaint reveals more about the critics than the form and amounts to confessing they never learned to read it, which treats the objection as uninformed. The author grants the complaint no partial merit. The essay takes a clear side, so it is not neutral. No hope is expressed that the critics will change their minds.

  63. Passage: A common belief holds that great scientific discoveries come from sudden flashes of insight. The historical record rarely supports this picture. Most landmark findings emerged from years of incremental testing, false starts, and quiet collaboration, with the famous eureka moment, if it occurred at all, arriving only after the hard work was nearly done. Question: Which one of the following most accurately states the main point of the passage?

    • A.Major discoveries usually grow out of long, gradual effort, not a sudden insight.
    • B.Eureka moments never truly happen, so tales of sudden insight in science are invented.
    • C.Quiet collaboration, more than testing, is what drives most landmark scientific work.
    • D.Insight mattered more in the past, but modern science advances by steady testing.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Major discoveries usually grow out of long, gradual effort, not a sudden insight.

    The passage rejects the flash-of-insight picture and says most landmark findings came from years of testing, false starts and collaboration, which is its main point. It allows that a eureka moment may have occurred, so it does not call such moments invented. Collaboration is listed alongside testing and is not ranked above it. The passage draws no contrast between past and present science.

  64. Passage: The essay begins by recounting a city's failed attempt to reduce litter through fines. It then describes a second city that cut litter dramatically by installing more trash bins and running a humorous ad campaign. The essay closes by suggesting that making the desired behavior easy and appealing often outperforms punishing the unwanted one. Question: Which one of the following most accurately describes the organization of the passage?

    • A.A general principle is stated first, and two examples are then offered to support it.
    • B.Two rival theories about litter are laid out, and the question is left unresolved.
    • C.A policy is proposed for one city, and an objection to it is raised and answered.
    • D.One failed approach is set against a successful one, and a lesson is drawn.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: One failed approach is set against a successful one, and a lesson is drawn.

    The essay opens with fines that failed, turns to the city whose bins and humorous ads worked, and closes with the lesson about making good behavior easy. The principle comes at the end, not the start. The two cases are approaches that were tried, not rival theories, and the essay does reach a conclusion. No policy is proposed and then defended against an objection.

  65. Passage: After praising the novel's vivid setting and inventive plot, the reviewer adds: Yet the characters remain curiously flat, mouthing positions rather than revealing inner lives, so that one finishes the book admiring its world while feeling one has met no one in it. Question: The function of the sentence beginning Yet the characters is to

    • A.Retract the earlier praise by declaring the novel a complete failure
    • B.Summarize the plot of the novel for readers who have not yet read it
    • C.Qualify the earlier praise by drawing attention to a deeper weakness
    • D.Explain why the setting of the novel struck the reviewer as so vivid
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Qualify the earlier praise by drawing attention to a deeper weakness

    'Yet' turns from praise of setting and plot to a complaint about flat characters, and the reader still ends up admiring the book's world, so the praise is tempered rather than withdrawn. The sentence keeps the admiration, so it does not declare the novel a failure. It describes the characters, not the plot. It says nothing about why the setting is vivid.

  66. Passage: Two economists studied why small farms in a region were failing. The first blamed competition from large industrial farms and urged subsidies to level the field. The second pointed to the small farms' lack of access to credit and recommended low-interest loans. Notably, neither disputed that the farms were in decline; they differed only on the cause. Question: The two economists would be most likely to disagree about which one of the following?

    • A.Whether the small farms in the region are in fact declining at all
    • B.Whether industrial rivals or scarce credit chiefly caused the decline
    • C.Whether small farms add jobs and income to the regional economy
    • D.Whether any form of policy help at all could aid the struggling farms
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Whether industrial rivals or scarce credit chiefly caused the decline

    The passage says the economists differed only on the cause, one blaming industrial farms and the other a lack of credit. Both accept that the farms are in decline. Neither discusses the farms' role in the regional economy. Each proposes a remedy, subsidies or loans, so both think policy can help.

  67. Passage: The architect argues that a building's worth should be measured not by how it looks on opening day but by how gracefully it ages: whether its materials weather well, whether its spaces adapt to new uses, and whether the public still values it decades later. By this standard, she contends, many celebrated modern landmarks have already failed. Question: It can most reasonably be inferred that the architect would regard which one of the following as evidence that a building has succeeded?

    • A.It won several major design awards and praise the year it opened.
    • B.It has been adapted to new uses and is still prized decades later.
    • C.It was built from the newest materials available when it went up.
    • D.It closely resembles the most celebrated landmarks of its own era.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: It has been adapted to new uses and is still prized decades later.

    The architect judges a building by how it ages, including whether its spaces adapt to new uses and whether people still value it decades later, and a building adapted to new uses and still prized decades later meets both tests. Awards and praise in the opening year are the opening-day standard she rejects. Newest materials say nothing about how they will weather. Resembling the most celebrated landmarks of its era earns no credit, since she says many celebrated modern landmarks have already failed.

  68. Passage: Passage A: The growth of remote work will hollow out cities, as workers free to live anywhere abandon expensive urban centers for cheaper towns. Passage B: Cities have survived every technology predicted to make them obsolete, from the telephone to the automobile, because people seek not just jobs but the dense social and cultural life only cities provide. Question: Passage B responds to Passage A primarily by

    • A.Conceding that cities will empty out but arguing that the change is welcome
    • B.Questioning whether remote work is in fact growing as fast as Passage A says
    • C.Proposing policies that would keep remote workers living in dense cities
    • D.Citing older technologies that cities outlasted to suggest they will endure
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Citing older technologies that cities outlasted to suggest they will endure

    Passage B points to the telephone and the automobile, earlier technologies predicted to make cities obsolete, and argues that cities will endure because of the social life they offer. B rejects the hollowing-out rather than conceding it. B never questions whether remote work is growing. B explains why cities persist but proposes no policy.

  69. Passage: The historian cautions readers against reading ancient tax records as straightforward economic data. Such records, she notes, were created to serve the state's purposes, listing what officials wished to count and omitting what they had no reason to track. To treat them as a neutral mirror of the economy is to mistake a tool of administration for a survey of society. Question: Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?

    • A.Ancient tax records omit too much, so they are of no use to economic historians.
    • B.Ancient tax records reflect the aims of the state, so they must be read with care.
    • C.Ancient tax records were falsified by officials, so they cannot be trusted at all.
    • D.Ancient tax records should give way to surveys, which capture all of society.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Ancient tax records reflect the aims of the state, so they must be read with care.

    The historian says the records list what officials wished to count and omit the rest, so they reflect the state's aims and should be read cautiously rather than as a neutral picture of the economy. She warns against misreading the records, not against using them. She describes selective counting, not deliberate falsification. The survey is her image for what the records are not; she does not propose replacing them with surveys.

  70. Passage: It is often said that translation inevitably loses something from the original. True enough. But this familiar lament overlooks what translation can add. A skilled translator may clarify an obscure passage, supply a rhythm the source lacked, or carry a work to readers who would never have encountered it, gains that no honest accounting of translation should ignore. Question: The author's primary purpose in the passage is to

    • A.Deny that anything of value is lost in any translation
    • B.Show that translation can bring gains as well as losses
    • C.Argue that readers should seek originals over translation
    • D.Describe the methods skilled translators use to add rhythm
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Show that translation can bring gains as well as losses

    The author grants that translation loses something and then points to what it can add, so the purpose is to widen the familiar view to include gains. The author says 'true enough' to the loss, so loss is not denied. Nothing in the passage urges readers toward originals. Rhythm is one example of a gain, not a method the passage explains.

  71. Passage: The lecture opens by defining a keystone species as one whose removal causes disproportionate collapse in an ecosystem. It then offers the sea otter as a case study, tracing how the otters' disappearance let sea urchins devastate kelp forests. It concludes by warning that protecting such species may matter more than their modest numbers suggest. Question: Which one of the following most accurately describes the organization of the passage?

    • A.A popular belief is stated, tested against evidence, and finally rejected outright.
    • B.Two definitions of a term are given, compared in detail, and then reconciled.
    • C.A problem is described, several remedies are weighed, and one is recommended.
    • D.A concept is defined, shown through an example, and used to urge protection.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: A concept is defined, shown through an example, and used to urge protection.

    The lecture defines a keystone species, works through the sea otter case, and ends by warning that such species deserve protection. No popular belief is set up to be refuted. Only one definition is given. The kelp loss is part of the example, and no list of remedies is weighed.

  72. Passage: The author notes that early film critics treated the close-up as a gimmick that broke the illusion of theater. Then, mid-paragraph, the author writes: But what these critics dismissed as a trick was in fact the medium discovering its own grammar, a way of directing attention that the stage could never match. Question: The function of the sentence beginning But what these critics is to

    • A.Concede that the early critics were right to call the close-up a trick
    • B.Show that the close-up came from the stage rather than from early film
    • C.Add more examples of the gimmicks that the early critics objected to
    • D.Recast the trick that critics dismissed as a real innovation of film
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Recast the trick that critics dismissed as a real innovation of film

    Signaled by 'But', the sentence turns the critics' 'trick' into the medium finding its own grammar, which recasts the dismissed device as a real innovation of film. It overturns the critics' view rather than conceding it. It says the stage could never match the device, so it does not trace the close-up to the stage. It adds no new examples of gimmicks.

  73. Passage: A reader might assume that the more sources a news story cites, the more reliable it is. This assumption is mistaken. A story can pile up citations that all trace back to a single dubious origin, creating an illusion of corroboration where there is really just one unverified claim echoing through many outlets. Question: Which one of the following can most reasonably be inferred from the passage?

    • A.A story citing many sources is usually less reliable than one citing few.
    • B.A story citing a single source is the most reliable kind of story.
    • C.A story citing many sources may in fact rest on just one unproven report.
    • D.A story citing many sources was built on a false claim on purpose.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: A story citing many sources may in fact rest on just one unproven report.

    The passage says many citations can all trace back to a single dubious origin, so a long citation list does not by itself make a claim well supported. It never says many citations make a story less reliable than one citing few, only that they do not settle reliability. It does not praise single-source stories. It describes an illusion of corroboration but says nothing about outlets acting on purpose.

  74. Passage: The museum director defends the decision to display reproductions alongside originals. Visitors, she argues, learn more from a clearly labeled copy they can examine closely than from a fragile original kept behind glass at a distance. Authenticity, she insists, is not the only value a museum should serve. Question: The director's argument depends on assuming which one of the following?

    • A.Visitors cannot tell a clearly labeled copy apart from the original.
    • B.Most visitors would rather look at a copy than at the original work.
    • C.Close study of a copy can teach visitors about the art it reproduces.
    • D.Every original in the museum is too fragile to be shown out of glass.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Close study of a copy can teach visitors about the art it reproduces.

    The director claims a closely examined copy teaches more than a distant original, which holds only if close study of a copy can teach something about the art it reproduces. The copies are clearly labeled, so she does not need visitors to mistake them for originals. Her claim is about learning, not preference. She contrasts copies with fragile originals but does not need every original to be too fragile to show.

  75. Passage: Passage A: Standardized building codes have saved countless lives by ensuring that structures meet minimum safety thresholds nationwide. Passage B: Uniform building codes, drafted with major cities in mind, often impose costly requirements ill-suited to rural areas, raising housing costs without commensurate safety gains. Question: Which one of the following best captures a point on which the two passages would agree?

    • A.Building codes should be relaxed or dropped in rural parts of the country.
    • B.Uniform codes cost more than the safety they deliver in most places.
    • C.National codes serve people better than codes made for local needs.
    • D.Building codes have at least some effect on how safe structures are.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Building codes have at least some effect on how safe structures are.

    Passage A credits codes with saving lives, and Passage B criticizes rural codes for adding cost without safety gains in proportion, which still grants that codes affect safety. Passage A would not accept relaxing or dropping codes, since it credits them with saving lives. A sees codes as worth their cost, and B's complaint is about rural areas, not most places. B criticizes uniform national codes, so the two would not agree that they beat local ones.

  76. Passage: The biologist explains that animals long thought to be solitary may simply be hard to observe together. Nocturnal habits, vast ranges, and shy behavior can hide social bonds from researchers who study a species only by daylight in a single locale. Absence of observed interaction, she warns, is not proof of absence of interaction. Question: Which one of the following most accurately states the main point of the passage?

    • A.Most species labeled solitary have now been shown to live in social groups.
    • B.Nocturnal species labeled solitary are more social than daytime species.
    • C.Researchers should stop observing solitary species during daylight hours.
    • D.Some species called solitary may be social in ways observers miss.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Some species called solitary may be social in ways observers miss.

    The biologist says night habits, wide ranges and shyness can hide social bonds, and warns that unobserved interaction is not absent interaction, so some species called solitary may be social in ways observers miss. She does not say most such species have been shown to be social. She never ranks nocturnal species against daytime ones. She criticizes studying only by daylight but does not call for giving it up.

  77. Passage: The author recounts how a town, alarmed by a wave of car break-ins, installed bright lighting in its parking lots. Break-ins fell sharply that year. Yet the author notes that break-ins also fell in neighboring towns that installed nothing, suggesting a regional trend the lighting alone cannot explain. Question: The author mentions the neighboring towns primarily in order to

    • A.Recommend that the neighboring towns also install lighting
    • B.Suggest that lighting did not cause the drop in break-ins
    • C.Show that the town responded faster than nearby towns did
    • D.Explain how the thieves chose which parking lots to target
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Suggest that lighting did not cause the drop in break-ins

    Break-ins also fell in towns that installed nothing, which points to a regional trend and makes the lighting a doubtful cause. The comparison weakens the case for lighting, so it cannot be a call for neighbors to copy it. Nothing is said about how fast any town responded. The passage never describes how the thieves operated.

  78. Passage: Folklorists once treated a tale's many regional versions as corruptions of a single original. The trend has reversed. Many now hold that there was never one authentic version to corrupt; the tale existed only as the sum of its retellings, each shaped by the teller and the moment, none more genuine than the rest. Question: Which one of the following can most reasonably be inferred about the newer view described in the passage?

    • A.It treats the regional versions as corrupted copies of the earliest one.
    • B.It rejects the idea that any one version of a tale is the true original.
    • C.It holds that the earliest recorded version is the most genuine of all.
    • D.It argues that regional versions no longer merit serious scholarly study.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: It rejects the idea that any one version of a tale is the true original.

    The newer view says there was never one authentic version and that no retelling is more genuine than another, so it rejects the idea of a true original. Treating regional versions as corrupted copies is the older view it replaced. Ranking the earliest version as most genuine contradicts 'none more genuine than the rest'. The newer view changes how tales are understood, not whether they merit study.

  79. Passage: The economist concedes that automation has eliminated many jobs. Still, she resists the conclusion that automation must shrink overall employment. Past waves of mechanization, she observes, destroyed whole occupations while creating new ones no one had foreseen, leaving total employment higher than before. Question: The economist's attitude toward the claim that automation must reduce overall employment can best be described as

    • A.Accepting, on the basis of the jobs automation has already cut
    • B.Alarmed, on the basis of how quickly automation is now spreading
    • C.Skeptical, on the basis of the ways past mechanization played out
    • D.Indifferent, on the basis that job totals do not concern her much
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Skeptical, on the basis of the ways past mechanization played out

    The economist resists the claim and points to past waves of mechanization that created new jobs and raised total employment, which is skepticism grounded in history. She concedes that jobs were lost but still rejects the conclusion, so she does not accept the claim. She shows no alarm at the pace of change. She cares about overall employment, since that is the very question she argues about.

  80. Passage: Passage A: City planners should prioritize wide roads, since smooth traffic flow is what keeps a commercial district alive. Passage B: The liveliest commercial districts are often those least friendly to cars, where narrow streets and busy sidewalks invite the foot traffic on which shops actually depend. Question: Which one of the following most accurately describes how the two passages differ?

    • A.They disagree about whether shoppers would rather arrive by car
    • B.They disagree about whether planners should poll local shop owners
    • C.They disagree about whether busy districts push up nearby rents
    • D.They disagree about whether wide roadways keep a district prosperous
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: They disagree about whether wide roadways keep a district prosperous

    Passage A says wide roads keep a district alive, while Passage B says narrow, car-unfriendly streets bring the foot traffic shops need, so they disagree about whether wide roads keep a district prosperous. Neither passage says what shoppers would rather do, so shopper preference is not their dispute. Consulting shop owners and the effect of lively districts on rents are never raised by either side.

  81. Passage: The critic argues that nostalgia in popular music is not mere sentimentality but a deliberate commercial strategy. Songs that echo the sounds of a listener's youth, she explains, trigger powerful memories that producers can convert into loyalty and sales, making the past a renewable resource for the music industry. Question: Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?

    • A.Older songs stay popular because their tunes are simpler
    • B.Listeners lose interest in fresh music once youth passes
    • C.Producers should stop copying the sounds of past decades
    • D.Pop nostalgia is a calculated strategy for raising sales
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Pop nostalgia is a calculated strategy for raising sales

    The critic's point is that nostalgia in pop music is a deliberate commercial strategy rather than simple sentiment. She explains why echoes of the past sell, but never credits simpler melodies. She says familiar sounds trigger memories, not that listeners stop caring about new music after youth. She describes how producers use the past without telling them to stop.

  82. Passage: The essay first describes the conventional wisdom that immigrants strain public services. It then reviews studies showing that immigrants, who tend to be young and employed, often pay more in taxes than they consume in services. It ends by urging readers to weigh evidence over intuition when forming views on the subject. Question: Which one of the following most accurately describes the organization of the passage?

    • A.A common belief is stated, disputed by studies, and advice follows
    • B.A policy is proposed, backed by survey data, and critics answered
    • C.A theory is outlined, tested in an experiment, and partly revised
    • D.A debate is sketched, both sides weighed, and a compromise offered
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: A common belief is stated, disputed by studies, and advice follows

    The essay opens with the conventional wisdom that immigrants strain services, challenges it with studies on taxes paid, and ends by urging readers to weigh evidence over intuition. No policy is proposed and no critics are answered. Nothing is tested in an experiment and then revised. The essay takes a side against the common view rather than weighing two sides toward a compromise.

  83. Passage: After describing the painter's lush early canvases, the art historian writes: It is tempting to read his later, austere works as a decline. But the restraint of these final paintings is no failure of power; it is the discipline of an artist who had learned which marks could be spared. Question: The function of the sentence beginning But the restraint is to

    • A.describe the methods that defined the painter's lush early style
    • B.explain why critics of his era overlooked the later paintings
    • C.reject the view that the austere works show lost ability
    • D.admit that the late paintings fall short of earlier canvases
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: reject the view that the austere works show lost ability

    The sentence opens with But and turns away from the tempting reading of the late works as a decline, recasting their restraint as discipline. The early canvases were described before this sentence, and it says nothing about technique. No critics of the painter's own era are mentioned. Far from admitting the late works are weaker, the sentence denies that their restraint is a failure.

  84. Passage: The author observes that maps are never neutral. Every map magnifies some features and suppresses others, choices that reflect the purposes and assumptions of its makers. A subway map distorts distance to clarify connections; a political map erases terrain to emphasize borders. To read a map well is to ask what it was made to do. Question: Which one of the following can most reasonably be inferred from the passage?

    • A.A map's features are chosen to serve its makers' purposes
    • B.Political maps are less reliable than maps of subway lines
    • C.Travelers should avoid maps that distort the distances they show
    • D.Most people read maps without asking what was left out
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: A map's features are chosen to serve its makers' purposes

    The passage says every map magnifies some features and suppresses others, choices that reflect its makers' purposes, so a map's features serve those purposes. It treats subway and political maps as two kinds of chosen distortion and never ranks them for reliability. It explains that distortion can clarify, so it gives no reason to avoid such maps. It says nothing about what most people actually do when they read maps.

  85. Passage: Passage A: Wilderness areas should be left entirely untouched, for any human management compromises their natural character. Passage B: Many wild landscapes were shaped for millennia by indigenous burning and cultivation, so to leave them untouched now is itself an intervention that lets them change in unprecedented ways. Question: Passage B undermines Passage A primarily by

    • A.disputing that unmanaged land is free of any human shaping
    • B.arguing that wild areas hold too little value to protect
    • C.proposing that native groups be given title to such regions
    • D.conceding that every form of upkeep does damage to ecosystems
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: disputing that unmanaged land is free of any human shaping

    Passage A assumes that leaving land untouched preserves a natural state free of people, and Passage B replies that these landscapes were shaped by indigenous burning and cultivation for millennia. B never says wild areas lack value; it cares about how they change. It describes past indigenous practice without proposing any transfer of ownership. B suggests that leaving land alone is itself an intervention, which is the opposite of conceding that all management does harm.

  86. Passage: The author challenges the idea that reading speed measures reading skill. A fast reader who retains little, the author argues, has not read well; comprehension and the ability to dwell on difficult passages matter far more than pace. Speed, in short, is a poor proxy for the thing it is so often taken to measure. Question: Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?

    • A.Slow readers grasp difficult texts better than fast readers do
    • B.Literacy is too complex for any testing to gauge reliably
    • C.Reading speed reveals little about how well a person comprehends
    • D.Schools should train students to read faster with daily practice
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Reading speed reveals little about how well a person comprehends

    The author argues that speed is a poor proxy for reading skill, since comprehension and dwelling on hard passages matter more, so pace says little about how well someone reads. The author never claims slow readers always understand more, only that speed is not the measure. The author points to comprehension as what does reflect skill, so skill is not called unmeasurable. Training for speed runs against the passage's whole argument.

  87. Passage: The scientist describes a study in which children who delayed a small reward to get a larger one later showed better life outcomes. She cautions, however, that the children differed in many ways besides patience, including their home stability, so the study cannot show that self-control by itself produced the outcomes. Question: The scientist's caution is best understood as a warning against

    • A.crediting one trait when other differences may explain the results
    • B.studying children without first getting the consent of the parents
    • C.offering rewards that could alter how children act during tests
    • D.assuming that all children are born with equal patience levels
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: crediting one trait when other differences may explain the results

    The scientist notes the children differed in home stability and other ways, so the study cannot show that self-control alone produced the outcomes; she warns against crediting one trait when other factors could be responsible. Consent is never mentioned. She does not object to using rewards in the study design. Whether patience is inborn or learned is not her concern; her concern is what caused the outcomes.

  88. Passage: The author argues that the spread of clocks did more than tell time; it remade habits of mind. Once daily life was synchronized to the hour rather than the sun, punctuality became a virtue, idleness a measurable waste, and time itself something one could save, spend, or lose. Question: It can most reasonably be inferred that the author regards the clock as

    • A.a tool whose effects stayed limited to work and its schedules
    • B.an instrument that mattered less than a calendar in daily life
    • C.a mere gadget whose inner workings deserve a much closer look
    • D.a device that changed how people valued and thought about time
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: a device that changed how people valued and thought about time

    The author says the clock remade habits of mind, turning punctuality into a virtue and time into something saved or lost, so it changed how people valued time. Those effects reach far beyond work schedules into moral attitudes. The calendar is never mentioned. The author cares about the clock's social effects, not its mechanism.

  89. Passage: Passage A: Public funding should favor proven treatments over experimental ones, since taxpayers deserve reliable returns on their money. Passage B: Confining funds to proven treatments starves the very research that turns experimental ideas into tomorrow's proven cures. Question: Which one of the following most accurately describes the relationship between the two passages?

    • A.Passage B supplies data that supports Passage A's main proposal
    • B.Passage B restates Passage A's view by using fresh examples
    • C.Passage B identifies a delayed cost of Passage A's policy
    • D.Passage B shares Passage A's doubts about experimental drug trials
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Passage B identifies a delayed cost of Passage A's policy

    Passage A wants funding confined to proven treatments, and Passage B warns that doing so starves the research that produces future cures, a cost that arrives later. B offers no data and opposes rather than supports A's proposal. B does not restate A; it attacks A's plan. A favors proven treatments, but B defends experimental research, so B does not share any doubts about it.

  90. Passage: The author notes that fans often praise a beloved book for being timeless. Yet, the author writes mid-essay: A book called timeless usually means a book whose particular moment we have agreed to forget, mistaking our own familiarity with its assumptions for the absence of any. Question: The sentence beginning A book called timeless primarily serves to

    • A.endorse the praise fans give beloved books as being timeless
    • B.challenge the idea that any book truly escapes its era
    • C.recommend older works that still speak to readers of today
    • D.explain why fans grow tired of books they once loved
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: challenge the idea that any book truly escapes its era

    The sentence says a book called timeless is one whose moment we have agreed to forget, so it doubts that any book truly escapes its era. It undercuts the fans' praise rather than endorsing it. It names no books to recommend. It is about how fans praise beloved books, not about fans tiring of them.

  91. Passage: A common assumption is that giving people more choices makes them happier. Research complicates this. Faced with too many options, shoppers often feel paralyzed, postpone deciding, and report less satisfaction with whatever they finally pick than those offered a modest range. Question: Which one of the following most accurately states the main point of the passage?

    • A.Giving people many choices can leave them less content overall
    • B.Retailers should show buyers only a single product at once
    • C.Shoppers are happiest when someone else decides on their behalf
    • D.The number of choices has no bearing on shoppers' satisfaction
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Giving people many choices can leave them less content overall

    The passage challenges the assumption that more choice brings happiness, citing research that too many options cause paralysis and lower satisfaction. It compares too many options with a modest range, not with a single product, so it gives no advice to offer just one. It never discusses letting others choose. It says the number of options does affect satisfaction, which is the reverse of saying it has no bearing.

  92. Passage: The geographer explains why coastal cities flooded for centuries before anyone called it a crisis. As long as flooding was rare and recovery quick, residents treated it as weather. Only when the floods grew frequent and the recoveries slow did the same water come to be seen as a threat demanding action. Question: Which one of the following can most reasonably be inferred from the passage?

    • A.Coastal cities never flooded at all until the last few decades
    • B.Floods seemed threatening only once they came often and recovery lagged
    • C.Residents have long regarded each and every flood as an emergency
    • D.Engineers first noticed the crisis by studying the old weather records
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Floods seemed threatening only once they came often and recovery lagged

    The passage says floods were treated as weather while rare and quickly recovered from, and seen as a threat only when they became frequent and recovery slow, so perception tracked frequency and recovery. It says the cities flooded for centuries, so flooding is not recent. Residents treated floods as weather for a long time, not as emergencies. Engineers are never mentioned.

  93. Passage: The author warns against judging a historical figure's views by today's standards alone. To condemn a thinker for failing to anticipate moral progress, the author argues, tells us little about the thinker and much about our confidence that our own age has nothing left to learn. Question: The author's attitude toward judging past thinkers solely by present standards can best be described as

    • A.approving, since it holds earlier thinkers fully to account
    • B.disapproving, since it assumes our own era knows best
    • C.neutral, since it treats the matter as private taste
    • D.hesitant, since the historical record is still quite incomplete
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: disapproving, since it assumes our own era knows best

    The author warns against the practice and says it reveals our confidence that our own age has nothing left to learn, which is disapproval of assuming the present knows best. The author does not praise it for holding thinkers to account. A writer who warns against something is not neutral, and the author never calls it a matter of taste. The author does not hedge or mention gaps in the historical record.

  94. Passage: Passage A: A free press is essential to democracy because it exposes the abuses of power that officials would otherwise conceal. Passage B: A press driven by competition for attention can distort democracy too, amplifying conflict and scandal while neglecting the slow, complicated issues that govern people's lives. Question: Which one of the following is a point on which the two passages would most likely agree?

    • A.The state should pay for most papers and broadcasts
    • B.Rivalry for readers raises the quality of all reporting
    • C.Democracy would work better if the press were weaker
    • D.News outlets have real power to shape democratic life
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: News outlets have real power to shape democratic life

    Passage A says the press protects democracy by exposing abuses, and Passage B says a competitive press can distort democracy, so both treat the press as a strong force on democratic life. Neither passage mentions government funding. Passage B says competition for attention distorts coverage, so they would not agree it raises quality. Passage A calls a free press essential, so it would reject a weaker press.

  95. Passage: The author recounts how, after a celebrated bridge collapsed, engineers blamed a single design flaw. Later analysis, the author notes, found that the flaw had existed in dozens of safe bridges; what doomed this one was a rare combination of wind, traffic, and corrosion acting together. Question: The author mentions the dozens of safe bridges primarily in order to

    • A.urge that all bridges with that defect be torn down
    • B.show the flaw could not have caused the collapse alone
    • C.praise the engineers for so quickly finding the true cause
    • D.describe the methods used to build the celebrated old span
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: show the flaw could not have caused the collapse alone

    Dozens of bridges had the same flaw and stayed safe, which shows the flaw alone was not enough; a rare mix of wind, traffic and corrosion was needed. Those bridges are cited as safe, so they are not a reason to tear anything down. The engineers blamed the flaw alone, which the author says was wrong, so there is no praise. The detail is about why the bridge failed, not how it was built.

  96. Passage: The author argues that boredom, far from being merely unpleasant, can be productive. A mind with nothing to occupy it, the author suggests, tends to wander, make unexpected connections, and generate ideas that constant stimulation would crowd out. Question: Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?

    • A.People now get bored more easily than earlier generations did
    • B.Constant stimulation is the main source of truly original ideas
    • C.An unoccupied mind is often where fresh ideas take shape
    • D.Boredom is an unpleasant state that people should try avoiding
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: An unoccupied mind is often where fresh ideas take shape

    The author's point is that boredom can be productive, because an unoccupied mind wanders and makes new connections. The passage makes no comparison between generations. It says constant stimulation crowds ideas out, the opposite of being their main source. It denies that boredom is merely unpleasant, so it does not advise avoiding it.

  97. Passage: The essay opens by stating a paradox: people say they want news that is balanced, yet they reward outlets that confirm their existing beliefs. It then surveys studies of online behavior documenting this gap between stated and revealed preferences. It concludes that designing better news may require attending to what audiences do, not only what they say. Question: Which one of the following most accurately describes the organization of the passage?

    • A.A puzzle is posed, supported by studies, and used to draw a lesson
    • B.A plan is set out, its critics are answered, and it is upheld
    • C.Two meanings are defined, then compared, and then one of them is preferred
    • D.A trend is traced, its causes are listed, and a forecast is made
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: A puzzle is posed, supported by studies, and used to draw a lesson

    The essay states a paradox about what readers say and do, documents it with studies of online behavior, and concludes that news design should attend to behavior. It proposes no plan and answers no critics. It never defines or compares meanings of balanced news. It traces no historical trend and makes no forecast.

  98. Passage: The author concedes that anonymous online comments can be cruel. Even so, the author resists banning anonymity outright, noting that anonymity also shields whistleblowers, dissidents, and the vulnerable, whose contributions a real-name rule would silence along with the trolls. Question: Which one of the following can most reasonably be inferred about the author's view of banning online anonymity?

    • A.The author thinks anonymous posts are mostly just idle fun
    • B.The author wants every user to post under their name
    • C.The author believes a ban would silence valuable speakers too
    • D.The author doubts that online comments are ever really cruel
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The author believes a ban would silence valuable speakers too

    The author resists a ban because anonymity shields whistleblowers, dissidents and the vulnerable, whose voices a real-name rule would silence along with trolls. The author concedes anonymous comments can be cruel, so does not call them harmless or doubt their cruelty. Resisting a ban on anonymity is the opposite of wanting everyone to post under a real name.

  99. Passage: The conventional view holds that the printing press caused the Protestant Reformation by spreading Luther's writings. But presses had existed in Europe for over half a century before Luther, printing mostly indulgences and devotional texts that reinforced the established church. The press was a tool that amplified whatever message its operators chose; what changed in the 1520s was not the technology but the demand for a particular kind of message. Question: Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?

    • A.Shifting public demand rather than the press itself drove the Reformation
    • B.Printing played no role at all in spreading the Reformation's ideas
    • C.Early presses mainly printed the texts that supported the established church
    • D.Luther's own works were the first books ever printed in Europe
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Shifting public demand rather than the press itself drove the Reformation

    The author grants that the press spread Luther's work but argues that presses existed long before him, so what changed in the 1520s was demand for a new message. The press amplified that message, so it was not without a role. Printing for the old church is a supporting detail, not the main point. The passage says presses printed indulgences and devotional texts for decades before Luther, so his works were not the first.

  100. Passage: Defenders of urban congestion pricing argue that charging drivers to enter crowded districts reduces traffic and funds transit. Skeptics reply that such fees fall hardest on workers who cannot easily switch to transit and must drive at fixed hours. Both sides, notably, accept that the fees do reduce congestion; they disagree only about who bears the cost. Question: Which one of the following can most reasonably be inferred from the passage?

    • A.Charging drivers has failed to ease traffic in busy districts
    • B.Most commuters could switch to transit with very little difficulty
    • C.Money raised by the charge is seldom spent on transit
    • D.Both camps accept the fees really do reduce traffic congestion
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Both camps accept the fees really do reduce traffic congestion

    The passage says both sides accept that the fees reduce congestion and differ only on who pays, so they share a belief about the effect on traffic. That same statement rules out the claim that the fees failed to reduce traffic. Skeptics say many workers cannot easily switch to transit, which contradicts the idea that most can. How the revenue is spent is never addressed.

  101. Passage: The biographer notes that the inventor kept meticulous notebooks, then writes: These pages, however, should be read less as a record of discovery than as a carefully staged performance for posterity. Entries were revised, dated inconsistently, and addressed to an imagined future reader. The two paragraphs that follow catalog specific instances of backdated entries. Question: The phrase a carefully staged performance for posterity functions primarily to

    • A.praise the inventor's care in keeping thorough written records
    • B.concede that the entries record discoveries in true order
    • C.signal that the notebooks were made for later readers
    • D.summarize how other biographers have long admired the inventor
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: signal that the notebooks were made for later readers

    The phrase introduces the biographer's own claim that the notebooks were staged for posterity, which the next paragraphs back with backdated entries. The phrase is skeptical, so it does not praise the inventor's record keeping. Revised, inconsistently dated entries show the notebooks do not preserve the true order of discovery. The claim is the biographer's own, not a summary of other writers.

  102. Passage: Passage A maintains that remote work boosts productivity because employees waste no time commuting and face fewer office interruptions. Passage B counters that the apparent gains are an illusion: remote workers log more hours not because they accomplish more but because the boundary between work and home has dissolved, and longer hours are mistaken for greater output. Question: Which one of the following most accurately describes the relationship between the two passages?

    • A.Passage B adds evidence that strengthens Passage A's whole case
    • B.Passage B reframes the apparent gains as merely longer workdays
    • C.Passage B reaches Passage A's conclusion by a different route
    • D.Passage B grants Passage A's claim that remote output falls
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Passage B reframes the apparent gains as merely longer workdays

    Passage A credits remote work with real productivity gains, and Passage B argues those gains are an illusion because longer hours are mistaken for greater output. B disputes A, so it does not strengthen A's case or reach A's conclusion. A never says remote work lowers output, so B cannot be accepting such a claim from A.

  103. Passage: For decades, paleontologists assumed that the largest dinosaurs must have been cold-blooded, since no warm-blooded animal could consume enough food to sustain such bulk. Bone-growth studies have undermined this assumption. The microscopic structure of the bones reveals rapid, sustained growth of the kind associated with warm-blooded metabolism, suggesting these giants may have run far hotter than once believed. Question: The passage is structured to

    • A.defend a traditional view against a much newer objection
    • B.present a long-held belief before casting doubt upon it
    • C.weigh two equally strong theories without taking a side
    • D.trace how methods for studying fossil bones have changed
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: present a long-held belief before casting doubt upon it

    The passage gives the old assumption that giant dinosaurs were cold-blooded, then describes bone-growth evidence that undermines it. It sides with the new evidence rather than defending the old view. It favors one view, so it does not treat two theories as equal. It uses bone-growth findings as evidence and says nothing about how the methods developed.

  104. Passage: Curator: Some visitors complain that our museum's new labels are too long, arguing that people come to look at art, not to read essays. But our attendance surveys show that visitors who read the labels stay nearly twice as long and rate their visits more highly. The labels do not distract from the art; they deepen engagement with it. Question: Which one of the following best describes the curator's method of responding to the complaint?

    • A.The curator denies that any visitor has raised this complaint
    • B.The curator asks whether the critics are qualified to judge
    • C.The curator offers to trim the labels to satisfy critics
    • D.The curator points to surveys where label readers stay longer
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The curator points to surveys where label readers stay longer

    The curator answers with attendance surveys showing label readers stay longer and rate their visits higher, evidence that the labels improve the experience. The curator opens by acknowledging that visitors complain. The curator never attacks the complainers' expertise. The curator defends the labels as they are rather than offering to shorten them.

  105. Passage: The poet's early reviewers dismissed her work as cold and overly intellectual, lacking the warmth they expected of lyric verse. The author of this passage suggests that these reviewers mistook restraint for absence of feeling, failing to notice how the poems' tight control of form was itself an expression of barely contained emotion. Question: Which one of the following most accurately describes the author's attitude toward the early reviewers?

    • A.The author agrees that the poems are cold and unfeeling
    • B.The author is unconcerned with whether the reviews were right
    • C.The author says the critics misread formal control as coldness
    • D.The author admires the early readers for their careful reading
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The author says the critics misread formal control as coldness

    The author says the reviewers mistook restraint for absence of feeling and missed the emotion in the poems' tight form. That is a rejection of their verdict that the poems are cold. Saying they mistook something shows the author cares whether they were right. Faulting them for failing to notice is not admiration for their reading.

  106. Passage: A common reading strategy is to identify the author's main claim first and treat every later paragraph as either support for, qualification of, or objection to that claim. A reader who labels each paragraph by its job rarely loses track of an argument's shape, even in dense scientific prose, because such labeling converts a wall of detail into a small set of moves. Question: According to the passage, why does labeling each paragraph by its job help a reader?

    • A.Because it lets readers skip most of the technical material
    • B.Because it ensures that readers accept the author's main claim
    • C.Because it reveals factual mistakes hidden in the author's logic
    • D.Because it turns dense detail into a few clear steps
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Because it turns dense detail into a few clear steps

    The passage says labeling converts a wall of detail into a small set of moves, which keeps readers from losing track of the argument. The reader still reads every paragraph, so nothing is skipped. Labeling a paragraph as an objection or qualification does not make anyone agree with the claim. The passage says the method tracks an argument's shape, not that it catches factual errors.

  107. Passage: Two scholars debate the cause of a medieval city's sudden growth. The first attributes it to a new trade route that brought merchants and capital to the region. The second argues that the route followed the growth rather than caused it, pointing out that the population had already begun to swell before the route opened. Question: The main point of disagreement between the two scholars is best described as whether

    • A.the city actually grew as suddenly as the records suggest
    • B.the city's growth mainly enriched its merchants and its bankers
    • C.the trade route caused the growth or merely followed it
    • D.medieval rulers did much to encourage commerce over long distances
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: the trade route caused the growth or merely followed it

    The first scholar says the trade route caused the growth, and the second says the route followed growth already under way, so they disagree about whether the route was cause or consequence. Both accept that the city grew suddenly. Neither discusses who profited from the growth. Neither says anything about the policies of medieval rulers.

  108. Passage: Advocates for replacing letter grades with written feedback claim that grades reduce a semester of learning to a single symbol. Critics respond that this objection proves too much: any summary, a transcript, a recommendation letter, even a written evaluation, also compresses learning into a limited form. If compression alone condemns a tool, no method of reporting student progress could survive. Question: The critics respond to the advocates primarily by

    • A.showing that their objection would condemn any summary of learning
    • B.offering new data showing that letter grades are accurate gauges
    • C.agreeing that written feedback should take the place of grades
    • D.doubting that students gain from any form of evaluation whatsoever
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: showing that their objection would condemn any summary of learning

    The critics say the compression objection proves too much: transcripts, letters and even written evaluations also compress learning, so the objection would rule out every way of reporting progress. They present no data on accuracy. They resist replacing grades, so they do not agree to it. They never question whether feedback benefits students.

  109. Passage: A botanist long believed that a certain orchid could be pollinated only by a single species of moth with an unusually long tongue. The botanist concluded that wherever the orchid grew, that moth must also live. Time-lapse photography later revealed several other insects successfully transferring the orchid's pollen. Question: This discovery, if accurate, most directly undermines

    • A.the belief that the flower can actually produce its own pollen
    • B.the claim that this insect has a tongue of unusual length
    • C.the idea that cameras can capture what insects are really doing
    • D.the conclusion that the moth must live where the orchid grows
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: the conclusion that the moth must live where the orchid grows

    The botanist inferred the moth's presence from the orchid's because only that moth could pollinate it; if other insects carry the pollen, the orchid can grow where the moth is absent. The footage shows insects moving pollen, which confirms rather than undermines the belief that the flower makes it. Nothing in the discovery bears on the moth's tongue length. Time-lapse images of insects show that cameras can record insect behavior.

  110. Passage: The historian writes: We are told that the treaty brought peace. It brought, more precisely, the kind of quiet that follows when one army has burned the other's fields and there is nothing left to fight over. Question: The phrase the kind of quiet that follows when one army has burned the other's fields functions primarily to

    • A.endorse the view that the agreement ended that war for good
    • B.recast the supposed peace as the stillness of a ruined land
    • C.supply figures on how many soldiers died in the long war
    • D.compare this pact to a second accord made in another era
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: recast the supposed peace as the stillness of a ruined land

    The historian uses the image of burned fields to push back on the word peace, presenting the quiet as exhaustion after devastation. That qualifies the claim of peace rather than endorsing it. The phrase is an image, not a set of casualty figures. Only one treaty is discussed, so there is no comparison.

  111. Passage: Passage A argues that zoos serve conservation by breeding endangered species and educating the public. Passage B replies that the conservation defense is mostly a comforting story: the species most zoos breed are not endangered, and the few genuine breeding programs could be run far more cheaply outside the entertainment business. Question: Which one of the following best characterizes how Passage B responds to Passage A?

    • A.Passage B denies the facts that Passage A's defense relies on
    • B.Passage B grants Passage A's premises but draws a fresh moral
    • C.Passage B urges zoos to widen the scope of their teaching
    • D.Passage B agrees that zoos are vital to saving rare species
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Passage B denies the facts that Passage A's defense relies on

    Passage B says most species zoos breed are not endangered and that real breeding programs need no zoo, which attacks the facts behind Passage A's conservation defense. Because B rejects those facts, it does not grant A's premises. B never mentions education programs. B calls the conservation defense a comforting story, so it does not agree zoos are vital.

  112. Passage: After describing a town's debate over a new highway, the author writes: Before turning to the engineers' projections, it is worth listening to the residents of the oldest neighborhood, whose homes the road would divide. Three paragraphs of their testimony follow before the author resumes the engineering analysis. Question: The reference to the residents of the oldest neighborhood most likely serves to

    • A.dismiss the residents' worries as irrelevant to the final decision
    • B.present the engineers' reply to the objections raised by residents
    • C.let those most affected speak before the technical case resumes
    • D.show that the oldest neighborhood actually wants the new highway
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: let those most affected speak before the technical case resumes

    The author pauses the engineering analysis to give three paragraphs to the residents whose homes the road would divide, then returns to the projections. Giving them that space is the opposite of dismissing them. The engineers' analysis comes after the testimony and is not framed as a rebuttal. The passage says the road would divide their homes and gives no sign that they want it.

  113. Passage: Editor: A reporter argued that since our paper's online articles get more clicks when their headlines pose questions, we should write all headlines as questions. But headlines that ask questions also draw more reader complaints about being misleading, and complaints erode the trust that keeps subscribers paying. Question: Which one of the following can most reasonably be inferred from the editor's statements?

    • A.Chasing clicks alone may not serve the paper's real interests
    • B.Question headlines never draw more visits than any other headlines
    • C.The newspaper should stop publishing any of its stories online
    • D.Reader complaints have no effect on whether people keep subscribing
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Chasing clicks alone may not serve the paper's real interests

    The editor grants that question headlines draw more clicks but says they also bring complaints that erode subscriber trust, so chasing clicks alone may hurt the paper. The editor accepts that such headlines draw more clicks, so they do draw more. Nothing suggests dropping online articles. The editor says complaints erode the trust that keeps subscribers paying, so they do affect subscriptions.

  114. Passage: The novelist's defenders praise her refusal to resolve her plots, calling it a brave fidelity to life's messiness. Her detractors call the same trait an evasion, a way of avoiding the hard work of bringing a story to a meaningful close. Question: Which one of the following pairs of words best captures the contrast the passage draws between the novelist's defenders and detractors?

    • A.Simplicity versus obscurity
    • B.Novelty versus familiarity
    • C.Grace versus clumsiness
    • D.Boldness versus avoidance
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Boldness versus avoidance

    Defenders call the open endings a brave fidelity to life, which is boldness, and detractors call them an evasion of hard work, which is avoidance. The dispute is not over whether the books are simple or obscure. Neither side calls the endings novel or familiar. Neither side talks about whether the writing is graceful or clumsy.

  115. Passage: The primary purpose of the following passage: For years, public-health campaigns against smoking emphasized long-term risks like cancer that lay decades in the future. Newer campaigns instead stress immediate, visible harms, yellowed teeth, shortness of breath, the smell on one's clothes, and these have proven far more effective at prompting people to quit. The lesson is that distant consequences move us less than present ones. Question: The primary purpose of the passage is to

    • A.argue that smoking carries no serious long-term health risks
    • B.show why immediate harms persuade more than distant ones
    • C.describe how tobacco chemicals damage the lungs over time
    • D.urge that public-health campaigns be brought to an end
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: show why immediate harms persuade more than distant ones

    The passage contrasts older campaigns built on distant risks with newer ones built on immediate harms and concludes that present consequences move people more. It calls cancer a long-term risk, not a myth. It lists visible harms but explains no chemical process. It praises the newer campaigns as effective rather than calling for campaigns to end.

  116. Passage: A reviewer notes that an architect's celebrated buildings are admired for their dramatic exteriors, then observes that the people who actually work inside them complain of cramped corridors, poor light, and rooms shaped for the camera rather than for use. The reviewer concludes that the buildings were designed to be photographed, not inhabited. Question: Which one of the following principles is most clearly illustrated by the reviewer's reasoning?

    • A.Buildings should be judged chiefly by the prizes they win
    • B.Designs putting looks above use can fail the people inside
    • C.Dramatic exteriors are always a sign of poor interior design
    • D.The views of occupants have no place in assessing architecture
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Designs putting looks above use can fail the people inside

    The reviewer contrasts admired exteriors with occupants' complaints about cramped, dim rooms and concludes the buildings were made to be photographed, so favoring looks over use failed the users. Awards play no part in the reasoning. The reviewer judges these particular buildings, not every dramatic exterior. The argument depends on what occupants say, so their views clearly count.

  117. Passage: Some economists argue that lotteries function as a regressive tax, since lower-income players spend a larger share of their earnings on tickets than wealthier players do. Defenders of state lotteries respond that participation is voluntary, unlike a tax. The economists counter that the voluntariness of an unwise choice does not make its costs any less concentrated among the poor. Question: The economists respond to the defenders primarily by

    • A.denying that anyone buys lottery tickets of their own will
    • B.holding that a voluntary purchase still burdens the poor most
    • C.conceding that the games are not really regressive after all
    • D.proposing that every player be refunded all the money spent
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: holding that a voluntary purchase still burdens the poor most

    The economists accept that playing is voluntary but say voluntariness does not make the costs any less concentrated among the poor, so the defenders' reply misses their point. They grant voluntary play rather than denying it. They keep their claim that lotteries are regressive. They propose no refunds.

  118. Passage: A well-known reading tip for dense passages is to treat the first and last sentences of each paragraph as a map: the first usually announces the paragraph's topic, and the last often signals where the argument is headed next. A reader who reads these sentences carefully and skims the middle can grasp a passage's structure quickly, then return to the details only where a question demands them. Question: According to the passage, what is the benefit of reading the first and last sentences of each paragraph carefully?

    • A.It lets readers skip each paragraph's middle and never come back to it
    • B.It lets readers see the overall layout fast and dig into details later
    • C.It lets readers spot the author's hidden biases and judge them at once
    • D.It lets readers answer each detail question and not make a single slip
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: It lets readers see the overall layout fast and dig into details later

    The passage says the first and last sentences work as a map, so a reader grasps the structure quickly and returns to specifics only where a question calls for them. It never says the middle can be skipped for good; the reader is told to go back to it when needed. Nothing promises error-free answers to detail questions, and the tip has nothing to do with uncovering an author's biases.

  119. Passage: The conventional account credits a single general with the army's surprising victory, citing his bold flanking maneuver. A revisionist historian argues that the maneuver succeeded only because an unusually heavy fog concealed the troops' movements, a circumstance no general could have planned. The victory, on this view, owed more to weather than to genius. Question: Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?

    • A.A revisionist hails the bold flanking plan as the source of victory
    • B.A revisionist claims the maneuver was a poor plan doomed to fail
    • C.A revisionist argues that fog has swung most battles in recorded history
    • D.A revisionist credits chance weather rather than the general for the win
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: A revisionist credits chance weather rather than the general for the win

    The passage sets the conventional credit to the general against a revisionist reading in which an unplanned fog made the maneuver work, so the victory owed more to weather than to genius. Praising the flanking plan as the true reason is the conventional account the passage challenges. The revisionist never calls the maneuver a bad idea, only one that needed luck, and makes no claim about battles in general.

  120. Passage: The author describes a long-running scientific consensus and then writes: It is here that we must pause, for the consensus rested on a single dataset that no one had thought to question. The next several sentences detail flaws later found in that dataset. Question: The structural role of the sentence beginning It is here that we must pause is to

    • A.Restate the agreed position as settled and defend its main dataset
    • B.Introduce the many experts whose backing made that position so popular
    • C.Mark the turn from recounting received wisdom to doubting its basis
    • D.Summarize the methods that the researchers used to gather their records
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Mark the turn from recounting received wisdom to doubting its basis

    The sentence pauses on the fact that the consensus rested on one unquestioned dataset, and the sentences after it detail that dataset's flaws, so it marks the turn from describing the consensus to doubting it. It does not defend the dataset as settled; it opens the attack on it. No list of supporting experts follows, and the passage describes flaws in the data rather than how the data were gathered.

  121. Passage: Critic A praises the documentary for letting its subjects speak without narration, calling this restraint a mark of respect for the audience's intelligence. Critic B argues that the absence of narration is not restraint but abdication: by refusing to provide context, the film leaves viewers to draw conclusions the filmmaker should have helped them reach. Question: Which one of the following most accurately describes the relationship between Critic A's and Critic B's views?

    • A.They dispute whether the film includes any narration at all
    • B.They join in praising the film for leaving out narration
    • C.They both rate the film a failure as a documentary
    • D.They assess one trait of the film in opposite ways
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: They assess one trait of the film in opposite ways

    Both critics discuss the same feature, the missing narration; Critic A treats it as respectful restraint and Critic B as an abdication, so they assess one trait in opposite ways. They agree the narration is absent, so that fact is not in dispute. Critic B does not join the praise but condemns the choice, and only Critic B finds fault, so they do not both call the film a failure.

  122. Passage: A psychologist long held that children develop empathy only after age six, when they can fully grasp another's perspective. Experiments using simplified tasks have since shown that toddlers will comfort a distressed adult and adjust their behavior to others' apparent needs. Question: This evidence, if accurate, most directly weakens the claim that

    • A.toddlers can comfort an adult who seems upset or distressed
    • B.toddlers can become distressed when they see others in distress
    • C.empathy shows up only once a child has reached six
    • D.perspective-taking is just one part of empathy in mature adults
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: empathy shows up only once a child has reached six

    The psychologist held that empathy appears only after about age six, and toddlers comforting a distressed adult contradicts that timeline directly. The experiments support the claim that toddlers comfort upset adults rather than weakening it. Toddlers' own distress is not what the evidence challenges, and nothing in it bears on whether perspective-taking is one component of mature empathy.

  123. Passage: The essayist writes: Supporters call the new surveillance program a shield. A shield, however, is something you choose to raise; this program watches whether you consent or not. The word protection here does a great deal of quiet work. Question: The author's remark that the word protection here does a great deal of quiet work most strongly suggests that the author

    • A.doubts that the program's protective name is apt or even neutral
    • B.accepts the supporters' notion that the program is a true shield
    • C.considers the program too narrow or minor to warrant any concern
    • D.objects mainly to how much money the program costs to administer
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: doubts that the program's protective name is apt or even neutral

    Contrasting a shield you choose to raise with watching that happens without consent, then saying the word does quiet work, signals that the author distrusts the flattering label. The author rejects the shield comparison rather than accepting it. Nothing suggests the program is too small to matter, and cost is never raised.

  124. Passage: A historian argues that the famine was caused not by crop failure but by policy: grain continued to be exported from the stricken region even as its people starved, because officials feared disrupting trade. The author presents export records as the central evidence. Question: The export records function in the passage primarily to

    • A.prove that harvests never failed in the years of the famine
    • B.imply that official acts and not a shortage drove the famine
    • C.show that officials did not know the famine was taking place
    • D.compare the famine to ones that struck in other regions too
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: imply that official acts and not a shortage drove the famine

    The historian's thesis is that policy, not crop failure, produced the famine, and records of grain leaving a starving region are the evidence for that. Showing grain was exported does not prove harvests never fell; the claim is about what drove the famine. The passage says officials feared disrupting trade, which implies awareness, and no other regions are discussed.

  125. Passage: Some literary scholars insist that an author's stated intentions should govern how we interpret a text. Others reply that once a work is published, it belongs to its readers, and the meanings readers find may legitimately exceed anything the author consciously planned. The first group counters that without the author's intentions as an anchor, interpretation becomes a free-for-all in which any reading is as good as any other. Question: The main point of disagreement between the two groups is best described as whether

    • A.readers other than the author ever take up a printed book
    • B.the writer's declared aims should fix what a text can mean
    • C.authors are able to plan the meanings of their works consciously
    • D.the study of literature repays the effort scholars put into it
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: the writer's declared aims should fix what a text can mean

    One group wants the author's stated intentions to govern interpretation, and the other says readers' meanings may legitimately go beyond them, so the dispute is whether those aims should limit what counts as a valid reading. Both sides assume published works have readers. The second group grants that authors plan some meaning and says only that readers may find more, and neither side questions the value of literary study.

  126. Passage: The geologist describes a canyon and writes: To call this gorge the work of the river is technically true and deeply misleading. The river merely carried away what the freezing and thawing of a million winters had already loosened. Question: The geologist's statement technically true and deeply misleading is meant to convey that the claim the river made the canyon

    • A.is right in a narrow sense but hides the role of frost
    • B.is wholly false and ought to be thrown out as an explanation
    • C.fits every canyon on Earth as well as it fits this one
    • D.cannot be judged in any way until more evidence has been gathered
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: is right in a narrow sense but hides the role of frost

    Technically true but deeply misleading means the river did carry material away, yet crediting it hides the freezing and thawing that did the real loosening. Calling the claim wholly false contradicts the geologist's own admission that it is true. The remark is about this gorge, not every canyon, and the geologist evaluates the claim confidently rather than suspending judgment.

  127. Passage: An economist observes that a city's decision to cap rents was followed by a sharp drop in the number of apartments available to rent. A colleague cautions that the cap took effect the same year a major employer left the city, shrinking the population, and warns against assuming the cap alone caused the change. Question: The colleague's response functions primarily to

    • A.confirm that the rent cap alone caused the loss of units
    • B.offer a rival cause that casts doubt on the cap's role
    • C.argue that the city ought to make the rent cap permanent
    • D.deny that the pool of rental units changed in any way
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: offer a rival cause that casts doubt on the cap's role

    The colleague points to the departing employer and the shrinking population as another possible cause, which weakens the inference that the cap produced the drop. The colleague warns against treating the cap as the sole cause, so the response does not confirm it. No policy recommendation is made, and the colleague accepts that the number of apartments fell.

  128. Passage: For generations, the painting was admired as a serene portrait of domestic contentment. A recent restoration, however, removed layers of darkened varnish to reveal a small, anxious figure in the doorway, previously invisible, watching the scene. Critics now debate whether the painting was ever as peaceful as it seemed. Question: The passage is structured to

    • A.argue that the restoration hurt the painting it set out to save
    • B.trace the life story of the artist who produced the famous painting
    • C.compare the painting with other works that were made in that period
    • D.show that a new finding upset the accepted view of the painting
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: show that a new finding upset the accepted view of the painting

    The passage moves from the long-held serene reading, to the restoration that uncovered an anxious figure, to critics now doubting that reading, so it shows a discovery unsettling an interpretation. The restoration revealed hidden detail; nothing says it damaged the work. The artist's life and other works of the period are never mentioned.

  129. Passage: Proponents of a four-day workweek argue that employees produce just as much in four focused days as in five distracted ones. A skeptic replies that the early trials showing this came from companies that volunteered for the experiment, firms already confident their workers could handle it, so the results may not generalize. Question: The skeptic's objection is best understood as a concern about

    • A.whether staff truly want a shorter week to begin with
    • B.whether output can ever be measured in any reliable way
    • C.whether companies would lose money by moving to four days
    • D.whether the volunteer firms are typical of most other employers
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: whether the volunteer firms are typical of most other employers

    The skeptic notes that the trial firms volunteered and were already confident, so their results may not generalize; that is a worry about whether the sample represents workplaces broadly. Employee preference is never raised. The skeptic accepts the measured results for those firms and questions only their reach, and financial losses are not part of the objection.

  130. Passage: The author writes that a celebrated reformer is usually remembered for a single famous speech, then adds: But the speech was the easy part. The reformer's real achievement lay in the decade of unglamorous committee work that made the speech's promises law. Question: Which one of the following most accurately describes the author's attitude toward the popular memory of the reformer?

    • A.The author agrees the speech was the reformer's greatest feat.
    • B.The author doubts the famous speech was ever really delivered.
    • C.The author feels the public misses the reformer's larger feat.
    • D.The author thinks the reformer earned no lasting public honor.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The author feels the public misses the reformer's larger feat.

    The author calls the speech the easy part and places the real achievement in a decade of committee work, implying that popular memory overlooks what mattered most. That rules out agreeing the speech was the reformer's greatest feat. The author never questions that the speech was delivered and praises the reformer's achievement rather than dismissing it.

  131. Passage: A standard piece of advice for the Reading Comprehension section is to answer comparative-passage questions by first identifying each passage's main claim separately, and only then asking how the claims relate. Test takers who jump straight to comparing details, before grasping each passage's overall position, tend to confuse points of agreement with points of conflict. Question: According to the passage, what mistake do test takers make when they skip identifying each passage's main claim?

    • A.They spend far too long reading and rereading each passage.
    • B.They confuse where the texts agree and where they clash.
    • C.They lose track of who wrote each passage and when.
    • D.They run short of time and miss the section's end.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: They confuse where the texts agree and where they clash.

    The passage says test takers who compare details before grasping each main claim tend to confuse points of agreement with points of conflict. It says nothing about reading too slowly or running out of time, and forgetting which author wrote which passage is not the mistake it describes.

  132. Passage: A sociologist claims that volunteering makes people happier, citing surveys in which frequent volunteers report higher life satisfaction. A critic notes that the surveys cannot distinguish whether volunteering causes happiness or whether already-happy people are simply more inclined to volunteer. Question: The critic's objection challenges the sociologist's argument by

    • A.denying that those who volunteer often claim more life satisfaction
    • B.suggesting that people who feel cheerful may be likelier volunteers
    • C.claiming that survey data cannot capture how satisfied anyone feels
    • D.proposing that everybody should be required to do volunteer service
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: suggesting that people who feel cheerful may be likelier volunteers

    The critic accepts the survey link but notes it cannot tell whether volunteering causes happiness or whether happy people are simply more inclined to volunteer, so the causal direction may run the other way. The critic does not deny the reported satisfaction or say surveys cannot measure it. Requiring volunteering is never proposed.

  133. Passage: The biographer writes of a famous explorer: His journals brim with talk of courage and destiny. They are notably silent, however, about the local guides without whom he would not have survived a single week. The silence tells its own story. Question: The phrase The silence tells its own story most strongly implies that the author

    • A.believes the explorer never kept any journals of his travels
    • B.treats the journals' omissions as telling something about their writer
    • C.thinks the journals were lost by accident before being printed
    • D.praises the explorer for crediting his guides in full honesty
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: treats the journals' omissions as telling something about their writer

    The journals dwell on courage and destiny but stay silent about the guides who kept him alive, and saying the silence tells its own story treats that omission as revealing about the explorer. The biographer describes what the journals contain, so they exist and were not lost. The point is that he failed to credit the guides, the opposite of praise for honesty.

  134. Passage: Passage A holds that translating poetry is impossible, since a poem's sound and rhythm are inseparable from its meaning and cannot survive in another language. Passage B replies that this sets an unreasonable standard: by the same logic, no two readers of the original could ever share the same experience, since each brings a different ear to the words. Question: Passage B responds to Passage A primarily by

    • A.showing that A's rule means no two people hear a poem alike
    • B.agreeing that a poem can never be carried into a new language
    • C.listing poems that have been carried over into other tongues with success
    • D.claiming that sound and rhythm matter little to what a poem means
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: showing that A's rule means no two people hear a poem alike

    Passage B turns A's standard on itself: if a poem's meaning cannot survive any change in how it is heard, then even two readers of the original could not share it. B rejects A's conclusion rather than agreeing that translation is impossible. B offers no examples of successful translations, and it does not deny that sound and rhythm matter; it says A's standard is unreasonable.

  135. Passage: The author describes a controversy over a museum's plan to return artifacts to their country of origin. After laying out the museum's legal arguments, the author writes: Yet there is a question the legal briefs never reach, which is whether possession won through conquest can ever ripen into rightful ownership. Question: The sentence beginning Yet there is a question the legal briefs never reach serves primarily to

    • A.summarize the single strongest point in the museum's legal case
    • B.concede that the museum's legal stance is in fact correct
    • C.turn from points of law to a deeper moral issue
    • D.introduce figures on how many artifacts are now in dispute
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: turn from points of law to a deeper moral issue

    After the legal arguments, the sentence opens with Yet and names a question the briefs never reach, whether conquest can become rightful ownership, which turns the discussion to morality. It does not restate the museum's best legal point or concede that the museum is right. No figures on disputed artifacts appear.

  136. Passage: A nutrition researcher reports that people who drink diet soda tend to weigh more than those who do not, and some readers conclude that diet soda causes weight gain. The researcher cautions that people already trying to lose weight are more likely to switch to diet soda in the first place. Question: The researcher's caution suggests that the readers' conclusion overlooks the possibility that

    • A.diet soda may have more calories than the usual kind
    • B.the reported tie between soda and weight was made up
    • C.heavy adults could well be likelier to buy diet soda
    • D.few of the people surveyed truly drink any diet soda
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: heavy adults could well be likelier to buy diet soda

    The researcher notes that people already trying to lose weight are more likely to switch to diet soda, so the weight may come first and the soda choice follow, the reverse of the readers' conclusion. The caution says nothing about calorie content and does not question that the correlation was found. It also assumes plenty of people drink diet soda.

  137. Passage: The critic concedes that the symphony's finale is thrilling, then writes: But a thrilling ending cannot redeem the empty half hour that precedes it; one does not forgive a tedious journey because the final mile is pleasant. Question: The analogy of a tedious journey whose final mile is pleasant functions primarily to

    • A.back the view that a fine close cannot rescue dull music
    • B.argue that only the finale of the symphony is worth hearing
    • C.praise the whole symphony as a complete and deeply satisfying work
    • D.describe what it is physically like to sit through a concert
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: back the view that a fine close cannot rescue dull music

    A pleasant final mile does not excuse a tedious trip, just as a thrilling finale does not make up for the empty half hour before it, so the analogy supports the claim that a strong ending cannot redeem a weak work. The critic's point is that the whole work fails, not that the finale alone deserves a hearing. The analogy is a criticism rather than praise, and the journey is figurative, not a description of attending the concert.

  138. Passage: Historians of medicine once assumed that handwashing was widely accepted by physicians soon after its life-saving benefits were first demonstrated. In fact, the practice met fierce resistance for decades, as established doctors took the suggestion that their own hands spread disease as an insult to their competence. Question: Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?

    • A.Handwashing was never shown to curb the spread of disease.
    • B.Historians were right that doctors were quick to adopt handwashing.
    • C.Handwashing was the chief cause of disease spread in hospitals.
    • D.Physicians fought handwashing for decades after it had been proven.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Physicians fought handwashing for decades after it had been proven.

    The passage corrects the old assumption of quick acceptance: physicians fiercely resisted handwashing for decades after its life-saving benefits were demonstrated. The historians' belief in quick acceptance is exactly what the passage says was wrong. The passage states the benefits were demonstrated, so they were shown, and it never blames handwashing for spreading disease.

  139. Passage: For decades, museum curators assumed that visitors learned most from the longest, most detailed exhibit labels. A series of observational studies overturned this view. Researchers found that visitors rarely read past the first two sentences of any label, and that exhibits with brief, vivid captions produced higher recall of factual content than those with exhaustive text. The lesson, the researchers conclude, is that a label's value lies not in how much it says but in how little it asks the reader to absorb. Question: Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?

    • A.Short labels aid recall since visitors scan only a few lines.
    • B.Most visitors have little interest in learning any facts at exhibits.
    • C.Curators have long ignored research on how their visitors actually behave.
    • D.Long labels hurt recall as visitors find them hard to grasp.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Short labels aid recall since visitors scan only a few lines.

    The studies found visitors rarely read past the first two sentences, and brief captions produced better recall, so a label works best when it asks little of the reader. Visitors did learn facts from brief captions, so they are not uninterested. The passage says the old view was overturned, not that curators ignored the research, and it blames unread text, not hard-to-understand text, for the weak recall.

  140. Passage: A common complaint about juries is that ordinary citizens lack the expertise to weigh technical evidence. Yet defenders of the jury system note that juries are not asked to become experts; they are asked to evaluate the credibility of experts who disagree. Assessing whether a witness is evasive, consistent, or candid is a task at which lay people are often quite capable. The jury's job, on this view, is not to master the science but to judge the scientists. Question: The primary purpose of the passage is to

    • A.answer a charge against juries by redefining their real role
    • B.trace how juries came to take on their present form
    • C.urge that panels of experts replace juries in every court
    • D.show that expert witnesses often give misleading testimony to jurors
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: answer a charge against juries by redefining their real role

    The passage opens with the complaint that jurors lack technical expertise and replies that their job is to judge the credibility of experts, not to master the science. It gives no history of the jury system. It defends lay juries rather than proposing expert panels, and it says experts disagree, not that they are often misleading.

  141. Passage: The latest biography of the inventor recycles every flattering anecdote its predecessors did, adds nothing from the archives that have opened in the last decade, and treats each of its subject's failures as a misunderstood triumph. A reader hoping to meet a human being rather than a monument will close the book disappointed. Question: The author's attitude toward the biography is best described as

    • A.disapproving of its slanted and flattering picture of the man
    • B.neutral toward its handling of the hero's flaws and failures
    • C.enthusiastic about its fresh and lively take on its subject
    • D.grateful for its careful and full use of new archives
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: disapproving of its slanted and flattering picture of the man

    The author complains that the book recycles flattering anecdotes and recasts failures as triumphs, leaving a monument instead of a person, which is plain criticism of a one-sided portrait. The author is not neutral about the failures but objects to how they are spun. The book is called a rehash, not fresh, and it is faulted for ignoring the new archives.

  142. Passage: Coral reefs that experience occasional mild heat stress sometimes survive later, severe heat waves better than reefs that have never been stressed at all. Biologists suspect that mild exposure activates protective cellular responses that remain primed afterward. No one would recommend deliberately heating reefs, but the finding suggests that a reef's history, not only its present temperature, shapes its prospects. Question: Which one of the following can most reasonably be inferred from the passage?

    • A.Two colonies equally warm today could each handle a heat wave differently.
    • B.Reefs that were never stressed are immune to the worst heat waves.
    • C.One bout of mild heat permanently removes any reef's vulnerability to heat.
    • D.Warming reefs on purpose may be the best way to protect them.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Two colonies equally warm today could each handle a heat wave differently.

    The passage says a reef's history, not only its present temperature, shapes its prospects, so two coral colonies at the same current temperature can respond differently to a severe heat wave. Unstressed reefs actually fared worse, so they are not immune. Mild stress improved survival but nothing says it removes risk permanently, and the passage says no one would recommend heating reefs.

  143. Passage A argues that remote work boosts productivity because employees waste no time commuting and face fewer office interruptions. Passage B counters that productivity gains in remote work are often illusory: the hours saved on commuting are frequently absorbed by longer workdays and the erosion of boundaries between work and rest. Question: Which one of the following most accurately describes the relationship between the two passages?

    • A.Passage B examines parts of remote work unrelated to Passage A.
    • B.Passage B adds examples that strengthen the claim of Passage A.
    • C.Passage B grants Passage A is correct yet deems it unimportant.
    • D.Passage B accepts the time savings but disputes what they mean.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Passage B accepts the time savings but disputes what they mean.

    Passage B does not deny that commuting time is saved; it argues the saved hours are absorbed by longer workdays, so the productivity gain A infers may be illusory. Both passages address the same question, remote-work productivity. B counters A rather than reinforcing it, and it disputes A's conclusion instead of conceding it.

  144. Passage: The mayor calls the new transit plan a bold investment in the future. But a plan that adds three buses to a system short by a hundred is less an investment than a gesture. To dress up so modest a change in the language of transformation is to hope that words can do the work the budget will not. Question: The phrase "less an investment than a gesture" functions primarily to

    • A.praise the plan for its careful and gradual approach to adding service
    • B.offer a neutral tally of the capacity of the city's transit system
    • C.deflate the lofty label by stressing how small the plan really is
    • D.introduce a rival plan that the author then goes on to endorse
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: deflate the lofty label by stressing how small the plan really is

    Three buses for a system short by a hundred is called a gesture rather than an investment, which deflates the mayor's grand language by pointing to how little the plan does. The phrase is mocking, not praise for caution. The numbers serve the criticism rather than a neutral summary, and the author proposes no alternative plan.

  145. Passage: The essay first lays out the conventional explanation for the fall of a medieval trading city: a shift in sea routes left its harbor obsolete. It then introduces evidence the conventional view ignores, a series of devastating plagues recorded in city ledgers, and argues that disease, not geography, emptied the warehouses first. It closes by suggesting that the two causes reinforced each other. Question: The passage is organized to

    • A.Defend the standard view, rebut a challenger, and then restate it
    • B.Pose a puzzle, review the clues, and then pronounce it unsolvable
    • C.Describe two ports, compare their fates, and then rank the causes
    • D.Give the usual account, add neglected records, and then fuse both
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Give the usual account, add neglected records, and then fuse both

    The essay states the shifting-sea-routes explanation, brings in plague records that view ignored, and closes by saying the two causes reinforced each other. It does not defend the conventional view; it challenges it. It does find causes rather than calling the decline unexplainable, and it discusses one city, not two.

  146. Passage: One paleontologist argues that the dinosaurs were already in steep decline before the asteroid struck, citing a thinning fossil record in the final million years. Another contends that the apparent thinning is an artifact of how few rock layers from that period survive, and that the dinosaurs were thriving until the impact. Question: The two paleontologists most clearly disagree over whether

    • A.the fossil record alone can reveal why the dinosaurs died
    • B.the dinosaurs had already begun to fade before the strike
    • C.rock layers from the dinosaurs' last age survived at all
    • D.a space rock truly hit near the dinosaurs' final days
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: the dinosaurs had already begun to fade before the strike

    The first paleontologist reads the thinning fossil record as a real decline before the asteroid, while the second calls the thinning an artifact and says the dinosaurs thrived until the impact, so they disagree about a decline beforehand. Both take the impact as given. The second says few rock layers survive, which the first does not deny, and neither claims the fossil record is the only evidence.

  147. Passage: A reviewer praised a restaurant for its inventive menu but admitted she had eaten there only once, on its opening night, when the kitchen was staffed by visiting chefs who have since left. A single visit under unusual conditions, the editor noted, cannot fairly stand for what diners will ordinarily encounter. Question: Which one of the following principles is most clearly illustrated by the editor's reasoning?

    • A.Reviews written by professional critics should never be trusted.
    • B.One unusual case may poorly reflect what is typical.
    • C.An inventive menu generally signals a smoothly run kitchen.
    • D.First impressions are always the truest guide to quality.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: One unusual case may poorly reflect what is typical.

    The editor objects that a single opening-night visit with visiting chefs cannot fairly represent what diners ordinarily experience, which is the principle that an atypical instance may not reflect the typical case. The editor does not reject professional critics in general or say anything about what inventive menus signal. The reasoning in fact doubts a first impression rather than trusting it.

  148. Passage: Sleep researchers distinguish between sleep quantity and sleep continuity. A person may spend eight hours in bed yet wake briefly dozens of times, fragmenting the sleep so badly that its restorative value collapses. This is why, the researchers note, total hours alone is a poor predictor of how rested a person feels; the number of uninterrupted stretches matters at least as much. Question: According to the passage, why is total sleep time alone a poor predictor of how rested a person feels?

    • A.Because sleep cut into fragments restores little even after a long night.
    • B.Because the amount and continuity of sleep always rise and fall together.
    • C.Because most people cannot judge how many hours they have actually slept.
    • D.Because the restfulness of sleep depends entirely on what hour it begins.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Because sleep cut into fragments restores little even after a long night.

    The researchers explain that frequent brief wakings fragment sleep so badly that its restorative value collapses, even for someone in bed eight hours. If quantity and continuity always moved together, total hours would predict restfulness well, which is the opposite of the point. Estimating hours and the time of night are never discussed.

  149. Passage: A historian argues that a famous explorer's journals were heavily edited by his publisher to make the voyages sound more heroic, pointing to the journals' uniformly polished prose as evidence of later tampering. Question: Which one of the following discoveries would most strengthen the historian's argument?

    • A.The explorer was praised as a skilled stylist in personal letters.
    • B.Other explorers of that era kept journals in equally smooth prose.
    • C.The publisher's files ask editors to make the notes more dramatic.
    • D.The publisher's sales of the journals were poor despite the drama.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The publisher's files ask editors to make the notes more dramatic.

    The historian infers tampering from the polished prose, and direct instructions from the publisher to smooth and dramatize the rough notes would confirm that inference. If the explorer wrote skillfully on his own, or polished prose was normal for the era, the polish needs no editor to explain it, which weakens the argument. Poor sales say nothing about who shaped the text.

  150. Passage: It is often said that translation is impossible, that no version in a second language can fully carry the meaning of the first. The complaint is true but beside the point. Readers who cannot read the original do not face a choice between a perfect translation and an imperfect one; they face a choice between an imperfect translation and no access at all. Judged against that real alternative, even a flawed translation is a gift. Question: Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?

    • A.Faulty translations earn praise since the true choice is them or nothing.
    • B.The best translations give up accuracy so that they read more smoothly.
    • C.Readers ought to study the original tongues and not rely on translations.
    • D.Translation is truly impossible and thus should not be attempted at all.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Faulty translations earn praise since the true choice is them or nothing.

    The author grants that no translation is perfect but argues that the real alternative for most readers is no access at all, so even a flawed translation is a gift. The passage never ranks readability over accuracy or tells readers to learn the original language. It calls the impossibility complaint beside the point and defends translating, rather than saying it should not be attempted.

  151. Passage: The author argues that scientific theories should be judged not by how certain they make us feel but by how readily they expose themselves to disproof. A theory that can absorb any conceivable result, she writes, explains everything and therefore predicts nothing. Question: The author would most likely agree with which one of the following statements?

    • A.The finest theories are the ones that inspire the most confidence.
    • B.A theory should be kept until someone manages to disprove it.
    • C.Scientific theories cannot be ranked against one another in meaningful ways.
    • D.A theory that fits every imaginable outcome tells us very little.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: A theory that fits every imaginable outcome tells us very little.

    The author says a theory that can absorb any result explains everything and predicts nothing, so one that fits all possible outcomes has little scientific value. She rejects judging theories by how certain they make us feel. Her test of how readily a theory exposes itself to disproof is itself a way of ranking theories. A theory that absorbs every result can never be disproved, so keeping any theory until it is disproved would protect exactly the empty theories she criticizes.

  152. Passage: After laying out an economist's optimistic forecast for a developing region, the author devotes a full paragraph to the objections of local farmers, who say the forecast assumes water supplies that have already begun to fail. Only after this paragraph does the author return to weigh the forecast's other assumptions. Question: The paragraph devoted to the local farmers' objections most likely serves to

    • A.introduce a topic that bears not at all on the forecast
    • B.summarize the predictions that the author makes for the region herself
    • C.press a concrete challenge to a premise that the forecast needs
    • D.confirm that the forecast is built on sound and safe ground
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: press a concrete challenge to a premise that the forecast needs

    The farmers say the forecast assumes water supplies that are already failing, which is a concrete challenge to one of its key assumptions. The objection is directly about the forecast, not a separate topic. The paragraph reports the farmers' view rather than the author's predictions, and it undermines the forecast's foundations rather than confirming them.

  153. Passage: Some claim that censoring offensive speech protects the vulnerable. But who is to decide what counts as offensive? Whatever authority gains the power to silence speech it dislikes will, sooner or later, be controlled by those one most fears handing such power to. The case for free expression is in the end a case against trusting any censor, however well-intentioned at first. Question: The author argues against censorship primarily by

    • A.denying that any speech is ever genuinely offensive to anybody
    • B.warning that control over speech will drift into hostile hands
    • C.citing studies of lands in which censorship is common practice
    • D.appealing to the long history and renown of free-speech causes
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: warning that control over speech will drift into hostile hands

    The author asks who decides what is offensive and argues that any power to silence will eventually be held by those one least wants to hold it, so no censor can be trusted. The author never denies that speech can offend. No empirical studies or history of free-speech movements are offered; the case rests on that warning about who will end up with the power.

  154. Passage: A study of charitable giving found that donors gave more when shown the story of a single identifiable child than when shown statistics about thousands of children in need. Strikingly, when both the single story and the statistics were presented together, giving fell back to the lower, statistics-only level. The numbers, it seems, can dampen the very compassion the story arouses. Question: Which one of the following can most reasonably be inferred from the study?

    • A.Donors refuse to give to charities that help very many people.
    • B.Stories about one identifiable child tend to discourage donors from giving.
    • C.Pairing figures with a moving story can lower what donors give.
    • D.Statistics about need always draw more giving than stories of individuals.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Pairing figures with a moving story can lower what donors give.

    When the statistics were added to the single child's story, giving fell back to the statistics-only level, so adding numbers to a compelling story can reduce giving. Donors still gave when shown statistics, so they do not refuse. The single story produced the most giving, and the statistics drew less, not more.

  155. Passage: Why do so many languages have irregular verbs? One might expect such inefficiencies to be smoothed away over centuries of use. The answer lies in frequency: the most irregular verbs are almost always the most common ones, and their constant use keeps their odd forms familiar enough to survive. Rarely used verbs, by contrast, are quickly regularized, because speakers forget the exceptions and default to the standard pattern. Question: The primary purpose of the passage is to

    • A.compare the grammar of several unrelated languages in fine detail
    • B.describe the hardship that learners face with irregular verbs now
    • C.argue that languages ought to drop their irregular verbs entirely
    • D.explain why irregular verbs endure thanks to their frequent usage
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: explain why irregular verbs endure thanks to their frequent usage

    The passage asks why irregular verbs persist and answers that frequent use keeps their odd forms familiar, while rarely used verbs get regularized. It does not compare particular languages or discuss the difficulty learners face. It explains irregularity rather than arguing that it should be eliminated.

  156. Passage: Supporters call the new surveillance program prudent, a reasonable precaution in dangerous times. Its opponents call it intrusive, an unwarranted reach into private life. The whole debate, in the end, turns on which of these two words the public comes to accept. Question: Which one of the following pairs of words best captures the contrast the passage draws between supporters and opponents of the surveillance program?

    • A.Prudent versus overbroad
    • B.Prudent versus intrusive
    • C.Popular versus intrusive
    • D.Popular versus overbroad
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Prudent versus intrusive

    The passage names the two competing words outright: supporters call the program prudent, opponents call it intrusive, and the debate turns on which word the public accepts. Pairing prudent with overbroad gets the opponents wrong, since nobody in the passage calls the program overbroad. Pairing popular with intrusive gets the supporters wrong, since they defend it as a precaution, not as something popular, and the last pair misstates both sides.

  157. Passage: A long-running debate pits those who say poetry should be taught by close analysis of individual lines against those who say it should be experienced first and dissected later, if at all. A growing group of teachers rejects the choice: they have students memorize and recite poems before any analysis, on the theory that a poem lodged in memory becomes a text the student can return to and examine for a lifetime. Question: Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?

    • A.Teachers should analyze each line of a poem before students memorize it
    • B.Students should simply enjoy poems and only rarely if ever dissect them
    • C.Most teachers now have students recite poems in place of analyzing them
    • D.Some teachers dodge an old debate by having pupils memorize poems first
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Some teachers dodge an old debate by having pupils memorize poems first

    The passage sets up a two-sided debate and then reports that a growing group of teachers rejects the choice by having students memorize and recite poems before any analysis. Analyzing each line before memorizing reverses the order those teachers use. Enjoying poems and rarely dissecting them is one side of the old debate, not the point the passage builds to. Nothing says most teachers now use recitation, or that it replaces analysis; it comes first, and analysis follows.

  158. Passage: The columnist insists his only loyalty is to the facts. Yet over the years his columns have defended the same political party in victory and defeat, excused its missteps as the price of progress, and treated its rivals' achievements as accidents. Whatever he professes, a pattern this consistent is hard to read as mere fidelity to fact. Question: Which one of the following can most reasonably be inferred about the author's view of the columnist's claim of loyalty only to the facts?

    • A.The author accepts the claim, treating the columnist as true to the facts
    • B.The author ignores the claim, turning to the few critics of the columnist
    • C.The author doubts the claim, taking the pattern as a sign of partisanship
    • D.The author withholds judgment on the claim, as the pattern is too unclear
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The author doubts the claim, taking the pattern as a sign of partisanship

    The author lists years of defending one party, excusing its missteps and belittling its rivals, then says a pattern this consistent is hard to read as fidelity to fact, which is doubt about the claim. The author does not treat the columnist as true to the facts; that is the claim being questioned. The passage never discusses critics of the columnist, and it calls the pattern strikingly consistent, so the author is not withholding judgment for lack of clarity.

  159. Passage: A scholar argues that a work of art's meaning is not fixed by its creator but is completed by each audience that receives it. A symphony written as a patriotic anthem may, a century later, be heard as a lament; neither hearing is mistaken, because the work lives in the encounter, not in the composer's intention. Question: Which one of the following best conforms to the scholar's view?

    • A.A novel once read as a comedy may legitimately be read as a tragedy today
    • B.A novel's message is set by its maker, and later readers can only find it
    • C.A novel holds the same meaning for each reader, no matter when it is read
    • D.A novel has no meaning until its critics agree on one right reading of it
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: A novel once read as a comedy may legitimately be read as a tragedy today

    The scholar holds that each audience completes a work's meaning, and that a later hearing of an anthem as a lament is not mistaken, so a comedy now read as a tragedy fits the view. Saying the maker sets the meaning is the position the scholar rejects outright. A meaning that never changes across readers contradicts the anthem example, and waiting for critics to agree on one right reading replaces the audience's encounter with a single official reading.

  160. Passage: The author opens by conceding that critics of urban density have a point: crowded neighborhoods can feel oppressive. She then argues that the remedy is not less density but better design, pointing to dense districts that feel spacious because of parks, light, and varied streetscapes. The problem, she concludes, was never density itself but the careless way it has often been built. Question: The passage proceeds by

    • A.Conceding a critic's point and then shifting blame from density to careless design
    • B.Rejecting a critic's point and then claiming density always helps every urban area
    • C.Accepting a critic's point and then arguing that density should be sharply reduced
    • D.Comparing two distinct cities and then noting that both suffered from bad planning
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Conceding a critic's point and then shifting blame from density to careless design

    The author first concedes that crowded neighborhoods can feel oppressive and then argues that the fault lies in the careless way density has been built, not in density itself. She does not reject the critics' point, since she explicitly grants it. She argues against reducing density, calling for better design instead, and she discusses dense districts in general rather than comparing two particular cities.

  161. Passage: Honeybees communicate the location of food through a waggle dance, in which the angle of the dance relative to vertical encodes the direction of the food relative to the sun, and the duration of the waggle encodes the distance. Remarkably, bees adjust the dance's angle throughout the day to account for the sun's movement, so that the same food source is described differently in the morning and afternoon. Question: According to the passage, what does the duration of a bee's waggle encode?

    • A.How much food the source holds
    • B.How distant the food source is
    • C.Which way the food source lies
    • D.When the food source was found
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: How distant the food source is

    The passage states that the duration of the waggle encodes the distance to the food. Which way the food lies is the direction, and the passage assigns that to the angle of the dance, not its duration. The passage never says the dance conveys how much food there is or when it was found; time of day matters only because bees adjust the angle as the sun moves.

  162. Passage: A commentator argues that televised debates no longer change voters' minds, citing polls showing that most viewers' preferences are the same before and after the debate. Question: Which one of the following, if true, would most weaken the commentator's argument?

    • A.Most viewers follow debates closely, but they rarely discuss them with their friends
    • B.Most polls are conducted by phone, but online polls show similarly fixed preferences
    • C.Most viewers are staunch partisans, but the few undecided viewers often switch sides
    • D.Most candidates rehearse for weeks, but rehearsal rarely changes the views they hold
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Most viewers are staunch partisans, but the few undecided viewers often switch sides

    The argument infers that debates change no minds because most viewers' preferences hold steady. If most viewers are committed partisans while the undecided minority often switches, the debates do change the minds that were open, and the overall figure hides it. Whether viewers talk about debates with friends says nothing about whether their preferences moved. Online polls showing the same stability would support the commentator, and candidates' rehearsals concern the candidates, not the voters.

  163. Passage: The myth of the self-made entrepreneur flatters its subjects and misleads everyone else. Behind nearly every celebrated founder stand publicly funded roads that carried goods, schools that trained workers, courts that enforced contracts, and research that someone else paid for. To call such a person self-made is to credit the diner for the meal while forgetting the farm. Question: Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?

    • A.Calling founders self-made is fair as talent counts for more than public goods
    • B.Celebrated founders deserve no credit at all for the companies they have built
    • C.Calling a founder self-made ignores the public goods that made it all possible
    • D.Successful founders should pay heavier taxes to repay the public for that help
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Calling a founder self-made ignores the public goods that made it all possible

    The passage argues that roads, schools, courts and research paid for by others stand behind every celebrated founder, so the self-made label ignores those public foundations. The author calls the label misleading, which rules out calling it fair because talent counts for more. Crediting the diner while forgetting the farm means the diner still gets some credit, so saying founders deserve no credit at all goes too far, and the passage proposes no tax policy.

  164. Passage: It is tempting to measure a scientist's importance by counting how often other scientists cite her work. But citation counts reward the fashionable over the fundamental: a flawed but provocative paper may be cited hundreds of times by those rebutting it, while a quietly correct result is absorbed so completely that no one bothers to cite it at all. Question: The author's primary concern in the passage is to

    • A.Propose a better way of judging a scientist's importance than citation counts
    • B.Expose a flaw in measuring a scientist's importance by counting her citations
    • C.Defend citation counts as the fairest way of judging a scientist's importance
    • D.Argue that no available method can ever measure a scientist's real importance
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Expose a flaw in measuring a scientist's importance by counting her citations

    The passage concedes that counting citations is tempting and then shows how it rewards provocative errors and overlooks quietly correct results, so its concern is a flaw in that measure. It offers no replacement, so it is not proposing a better way. It attacks citation counts rather than defending them, and it criticizes one measure without claiming that no method could ever work.

  165. Passage A maintains that zoos serve conservation by breeding endangered species and educating the public. Passage B replies that the species most zoos display are rarely endangered, that captive breeding seldom returns animals to the wild, and that the lessons visitors actually take away are about spectacle, not stewardship. Question: It can be inferred that the author of Passage B would most likely respond to Passage A's claim about education by saying that

    • A.Zoos should expand their programs until all of their visitors grasp conservation
    • B.Public education is the strongest justification Passage A gives for keeping zoos
    • C.Zoo exhibits teach visitors more conservation than the breeding programs ever do
    • D.The public actually learns much less about conservation than Passage A maintains
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The public actually learns much less about conservation than Passage A maintains

    Passage B says the lessons visitors actually take away are about spectacle, not stewardship, so its author would say the public learns much less about conservation than Passage A claims. Passage B never proposes expanding zoo programs, and it does not rank education as A's strongest justification; it rejects that justification. It also does not say exhibits teach more than breeding, since it criticizes both.

  166. Passage: Languages borrow words far more readily than they borrow grammar. English absorbed thousands of French words after 1066 yet kept its own basic word order and verb endings. The pattern repeats across history: a conquered or trading people may flood another's vocabulary while leaving its underlying grammar almost untouched. Question: The reference to English absorbing French words after 1066 functions primarily to

    • A.Show that English grammar changed much quicker after 1066 than its vocabulary
    • B.Argue that English is unusual among all languages in resisting borrowed words
    • C.Explain why French speakers later adopted English word order and verb endings
    • D.Illustrate the larger claim that words are borrowed more readily than grammar
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Illustrate the larger claim that words are borrowed more readily than grammar

    The English case shows thousands of French words entering the language while its word order and verb endings stayed intact, an instance of the general claim stated in the first sentence. The passage says the grammar was kept, so it did not change faster than the vocabulary. English absorbed borrowed words freely rather than resisting them, and the passage says nothing about French speakers adopting English grammar.

  167. Passage: We praise libraries for lending books, but their quieter service may matter more. A library is one of the last public places a person can enter and remain without spending money or explaining why. In an economy that meters nearly every square foot, that unmonitored, unpriced welcome is itself the rarest thing a library offers. Question: Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?

    • A.A library will soon need to charge its patrons small fees to remain solvent
    • B.A library's central value may lie in its free space rather than its shelves
    • C.Free public spaces have grown more common in cities over the last few years
    • D.A library might track its patrons closely to justify all the books it holds
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: A library's central value may lie in its free space rather than its shelves

    The passage says a library's quieter service may matter more than lending books: it is one of the last places a person can stay without paying or explaining why. Charging fees would destroy the unpriced welcome the author values, and tracking patrons would destroy the unmonitored one. The passage calls such spaces rare in an economy that meters nearly everything, the opposite of saying they have grown more common.

  168. Passage: The startup promises to disrupt grief itself, offering an app that simulates conversations with the deceased. One hesitates to mock a tool that might comfort the bereaved. And yet there is something both touching and troubling in the idea that mourning, of all human experiences, is a problem awaiting a software solution. Question: The author's attitude toward the grief-simulation app is best described as

    • A.Enthusiastic, praising its comfort while waving off doubts about its premise
    • B.Contemptuous, mocking its premise while denying that it could comfort anyone
    • C.Ambivalent, granting that it may comfort while questioning its basic premise
    • D.Indifferent, describing its functions while declining to judge it either way
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Ambivalent, granting that it may comfort while questioning its basic premise

    The author hesitates to mock a tool that might comfort the bereaved yet finds it both touching and troubling that mourning is treated as a software problem, which is ambivalence. That stated trouble rules out enthusiasm that waves off doubts. The author's reluctance to mock, and the admission that the app might comfort people, rule out contempt, and the touching-and-troubling judgment shows the author does take a position.

  169. Passage: Economists once assumed that giving people cash, rather than goods, would be wasted on temptations like alcohol. Repeated trials of unconditional cash transfers in poor communities have found the opposite: recipients tend to spend on food, school fees, and small investments, and spending on alcohol and tobacco does not rise. The poor, it turns out, often know their needs better than the planners who would direct their choices. Question: Which one of the following can most reasonably be inferred from the passage?

    • A.The concern that cash would be squandered on temptations was never borne out
    • B.The belief that goods work better than cash payments was confirmed by trials
    • C.The trials found that spending on temptations rose but school fees rose more
    • D.The trials showed that most recipients hoped to obtain goods instead of cash
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The concern that cash would be squandered on temptations was never borne out

    Economists assumed cash would be wasted on temptations, and the trials found recipients spent on food, school fees and investments with no rise in alcohol or tobacco, so that concern was not borne out. The trials point toward cash working well, not toward goods working better. The passage says spending on alcohol and tobacco did not rise at all, and it reports nothing about recipients wanting goods instead of cash.

  170. Passage: Skeptics dismiss eyewitness testimony as hopelessly unreliable, noting how often memory distorts events. But to throw out eyewitness accounts entirely is to overcorrect. Memory is fallible, not fictional; witnesses err about details under stress yet are frequently accurate about the central, unforgettable facts. The sensible course is to weigh such testimony carefully, not to discard it. Question: The author responds to the skeptics primarily by

    • A.Insisting that memory remains dependable for details recalled under heavy stress
    • B.Conceding that fallible memory makes all eyewitness accounts useless as evidence
    • C.Citing data showing that poor eyewitness memory causes most wrongful convictions
    • D.Arguing that fallible memory still deserves careful weight rather than dismissal
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Arguing that fallible memory still deserves careful weight rather than dismissal

    The author grants that memory is fallible but says discarding eyewitness accounts overcorrects, since witnesses are often accurate about central facts, so testimony should be weighed rather than thrown out. The author says witnesses err about details under stress, which rules out calling memory dependable for those details. The author rejects the idea that fallibility makes testimony useless, and the passage cites no data on wrongful convictions.

  171. Passage: A puzzle has long surrounded certain desert plants that flower only after rare, heavy rains. How do their seeds know to wait, sometimes for years, rather than sprouting at the first light shower that would leave them to wither? Recent work shows the seeds carry chemical inhibitors that only a sustained soaking can wash away, so that germination is triggered only by rainfall heavy enough to support a seedling to maturity. Question: The primary purpose of the passage is to

    • A.Argue that desert seeds are more resilient than plants from rainforest regions
    • B.Describe how light rainfall imperils desert plants that have grown to maturity
    • C.Compare the flowering seasons of the plants found in several different deserts
    • D.Explain how certain desert seeds delay sprouting till rainfall is heavy enough
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Explain how certain desert seeds delay sprouting till rainfall is heavy enough

    The passage poses the puzzle of how seeds know to wait for heavy rain and answers it with chemical inhibitors that only a long soaking removes. It makes no comparison with plants from other regions and no comparison among deserts. The danger it mentions is to seeds that sprout after a light shower and then wither, not to plants that have already grown to maturity.

  172. Passage: Critics often blame social media for shortening attention spans, but the charge is hard to sustain. People who claim they can no longer focus will still binge an eight-hour series or lose an afternoon to a video game. What has changed is not the capacity to attend but the willingness to attend to things that offer no immediate reward. The problem, if it is one, is about motivation, not ability. Question: Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?

    • A.Critics are correct that people can no longer concentrate on anything for long
    • B.What looks like reduced attention is a shift in motivation rather than ability
    • C.Social media has damaged the ability of people to concentrate on lengthy tasks
    • D.People should limit their gaming and streaming so as to regain their attention
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: What looks like reduced attention is a shift in motivation rather than ability

    The author points out that people who say they cannot focus still binge long series and games, and concludes that what changed is the willingness to attend to unrewarding things, not the capacity. The passage says the critics' charge is hard to sustain, so it does not agree with them, and it denies that the ability itself was damaged. The binge examples serve as evidence; the author never advises cutting back on games or streaming.

  173. Passage: An art historian attributes an unsigned painting to a famous master, citing the distinctive brushwork that matches the master's known works. Question: Which one of the following, if true, would most undermine the art historian's attribution?

    • A.The master's apprentices were trained to imitate his brushwork in every detail
    • B.The master left many of his completed paintings unsigned throughout his career
    • C.The master frequently painted subjects like the ones depicted in this painting
    • D.The master's brushwork was praised by many critics throughout his whole career
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The master's apprentices were trained to imitate his brushwork in every detail

    The attribution rests on brushwork matching the master's, so if his apprentices were trained to imitate that brushwork in every detail, the match no longer points to the master's own hand. Other unsigned works by the master would explain the missing signature and support the attribution. A favored subject is further evidence for the master, and praise for his brushwork says nothing about whether someone else could reproduce it.

  174. Passage: Volcanologists rank eruptions on a scale that measures the volume of material ejected. The scale is logarithmic, so each step up represents an eruption roughly ten times larger than the one below it. This design captures the enormous range of eruptions, but it also means that two eruptions a single step apart, though they appear close on the scale, differ vastly in their actual force. Question: According to the passage, what does it mean that the eruption scale is logarithmic?

    • A.Each step up the scale marks an eruption about ten times larger in its volume
    • B.Each step up the scale marks an eruption lasting an hour longer than the last
    • C.Each step up the scale marks an eruption with a fixed added quantity of magma
    • D.Each step up the scale marks an eruption roughly twice as violent as the last
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Each step up the scale marks an eruption about ten times larger in its volume

    The passage says the scale measures the volume of material ejected and that each step represents an eruption roughly ten times larger than the one below it. The scale does not measure how long an eruption lasts. A fixed added quantity per step would make the scale linear, not logarithmic, and the passage gives a factor of about ten, not two.

  175. Passage: A good map, the cartographer argues, must lie. To show every detail at full scale would yield a map the size of the territory and therefore useless. The art of mapmaking is the art of leaving out, of deciding which truths to suppress so that the truths worth showing become visible. Question: The cartographer would most likely agree with which one of the following statements?

    • A.A useful map must show every feature of its territory at full scale
    • B.A useful map must never delete any fact that bears on its territory
    • C.A useful map must knowingly omit much that is true of its territory
    • D.A useful map must be viewed with distrust, since all maps tell lies
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: A useful map must knowingly omit much that is true of its territory

    The cartographer says a full-scale map would be as large as the territory and useless, so mapmaking means deciding which truths to leave out. Showing every feature at full scale is the useless map he describes. Refusing to delete any fact contradicts his account of the art. His claim that a map must lie means it must omit, not that maps deserve distrust.

  176. Passage A argues that requiring schoolchildren to wear uniforms reduces bullying by erasing visible markers of wealth. Passage B reports a study of districts that adopted uniforms and found that bullying rates were essentially unchanged, while incidents of students personalizing or defacing uniforms to signal status rose sharply. Question: Which one of the following most accurately describes how Passage B relates to Passage A?

    • A.Passage B offers evidence that casts doubt on the mechanism Passage A posits
    • B.Passage B offers a historical account that affirms the claim Passage A makes
    • C.Passage B reaches Passage A's own conclusion by a separate line of reasoning
    • D.Passage B argues for a firmer conclusion about uniforms than Passage A draws
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Passage B offers evidence that casts doubt on the mechanism Passage A posits

    Passage A claims uniforms reduce bullying by erasing visible markers of wealth, and Passage B reports a study finding bullying unchanged while students found new ways to signal status, which undercuts that mechanism. The study is empirical evidence, not history, and it weakens rather than affirms Passage A. Passage B does not reach A's conclusion or push it further; it finds the predicted effect missing.

  177. Passage: A common defense of fast food is that it gives the poor an affordable way to eat. But affordability is more than a price tag. A meal that is cheap to buy yet costly in later illness is not truly cheap; it merely moves the bill to a column the buyer cannot yet see. Real affordability would weigh the full cost, paid now and paid later. Question: Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?

    • A.Fast food is the only affordable meal that poor families can readily buy
    • B.The price paid at purchase matters more than any bills that arrive after
    • C.Calling fast food cheap for its low price alone neglects its later costs
    • D.Poor families should be legally barred from buying fast food of any kind
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Calling fast food cheap for its low price alone neglects its later costs

    The author argues that a meal cheap to buy but costly in later illness is not truly cheap, so judging fast food by its price alone neglects those later costs. The passage questions whether fast food is affordable at all, so it does not call it the only affordable option. It says the full cost, paid now and later, is what counts, which rules out putting the purchase price first, and it proposes no legal ban.

  178. Passage: Everyone knows that practice makes perfect. Or does it? The author opens with this familiar slogan only to spend the rest of the essay complicating it, showing that practice improves performance only when it is effortful and corrected, and that mindless repetition can even cement bad habits. The cheerful proverb, she suggests, hides more than it tells. Question: The opening sentence, "Everyone knows that practice makes perfect," most likely serves to

    • A.Concede a point that the author treats as entirely closed to dispute
    • B.Offer evidence that the author will use to support the central claim
    • C.State the thesis that the author will defend through the whole essay
    • D.Introduce a familiar belief that the author will go on to complicate
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Introduce a familiar belief that the author will go on to complicate

    The author opens with the familiar slogan and then spends the essay complicating it, showing that practice helps only when it is effortful and corrected. The author does not treat the slogan as closed to dispute or defend it as a thesis, since the essay qualifies it. A popular proverb is a belief under examination here, not evidence offered in support of a claim.

  179. Passage: Marine biologists once dismissed amateur observations of coral health as too inconsistent to be useful. That view is changing. Smartphone apps now let recreational divers log standardized photographs of reef sites, and when thousands of such images are pooled, statisticians can correct for individual error and detect bleaching trends earlier than research vessels alone could. The crowd, it turns out, sees more reefs more often than any single lab. Question: Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?

    • A.Pooled diver photos, once dismissed, can now detect bleaching sooner than labs
    • B.Amateur divers, once ignored, should now take over from expert reef biologists
    • C.Research ships, once essential, have now been made obsolete by smartphone apps
    • D.Statistical tools, once neglected, are now the leading advance in reef science
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Pooled diver photos, once dismissed, can now detect bleaching sooner than labs

    The passage reports that amateur coral observations were once dismissed but that pooled, corrected diver photographs now detect bleaching trends earlier than research vessels alone. It praises the crowd as a supplement and never says amateurs should take over from biologists. Seeing more reefs than vessels alone does not make the ships obsolete, and statistical correction is described as a tool, not ranked as the field's leading advance.

  180. Passage: It is tempting to read the sudden popularity of a forgotten poet as evidence that critics finally recognized hidden merit. But popularity often follows accident: a film quotes a line, a politician misattributes a verse, an anthology needs a short poem to fill a page. To explain a reputation by appealing to merit alone is to ignore the machinery of chance that delivers some works to readers and buries others. Question: The primary purpose of the passage is to

    • A.Argue that the forgotten poet in question lacked any genuine literary merit
    • B.Challenge the notion that a poem's sudden popularity reveals its true merit
    • C.Describe the specific accidents that revived the fame of one forgotten poet
    • D.Urge anthology editors to cease selecting poems merely to fill unused pages
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Challenge the notion that a poem's sudden popularity reveals its true merit

    The author warns against reading a poet's sudden popularity as proof of merit and lists chance events that can deliver a work to readers, so the purpose is to challenge the merit explanation. The author never says the poet lacked merit, only that merit alone does not explain the reputation. The accidents are general examples, not the specific history of one revival, and the anthology example illustrates chance rather than calling for reform.

  181. Passage: Enthusiasts of personalized medicine promise that genetic profiling will let doctors tailor every prescription to the individual. The vision is appealing, and for a handful of conditions it has already paid off. Yet for most common diseases, the genetic contribution is so diffuse, spread across thousands of tiny effects, that a profile predicts little a careful family history would not. The promise is real but narrower than its champions suggest. Question: The author's attitude toward personalized medicine can best be described as

    • A.Excited by its successes while confident in its broadest promises
    • B.Doubtful of its successes while trusting of its broadest promises
    • C.Appreciative of its successes while wary of its broadest promises
    • D.Unmoved by its successes while silent about its broadest promises
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Appreciative of its successes while wary of its broadest promises

    The author grants that personalized medicine has paid off for a handful of conditions and calls the promise real, but says for most diseases it predicts little and is narrower than its champions claim. That rules out confidence in the broadest promises, whether paired with excitement or with doubt about the successes, since the author accepts those successes. The author takes a clear stand, so the attitude is not unmoved or silent.

  182. Passage: In medieval guild towns, a master craftsman could not legally sell goods made by an apprentice under his own mark unless he had personally inspected and approved each item. Records show that masters in larger workshops increasingly delegated inspection to senior journeymen, and that complaints about defective goods rose in precisely those towns where workshops had grown largest. Question: Which one of the following can most reasonably be inferred from the passage?

    • A.Senior journeymen were legally allowed to carry out inspections of the goods
    • B.Apprentices in big workshops made poorer goods than those in small workshops
    • C.Guild law may have penalized workshops that expanded beyond a permitted size
    • D.Workshop growth may have eroded the inspection that the guild rules required
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Workshop growth may have eroded the inspection that the guild rules required

    The rules required the master to inspect each item personally, yet larger workshops delegated inspection and those towns saw more complaints, which supports the inference that growth weakened the required inspection. The passage says only the master's personal approval made a sale legal, so nothing shows journeymen were legally allowed to inspect. It says nothing about apprentices' skill, and it never mentions any limit on workshop size.

  183. Passage: The reformer's plan to fund schools through a lottery has obvious appeal: no new taxes, voluntary participation, painless revenue. Set aside, for the moment, the question of whether lotteries tend to draw most heavily on those least able to afford the tickets. Even granting the plan its rosiest assumptions, the revenue it projects would cover barely a tenth of the schools' shortfall. Question: The function of the sentence beginning 'Set aside, for the moment' is to

    • A.Raise the objection on which the author's case against the plan relies
    • B.Concede that the lottery is fair so that its revenue projections stand
    • C.Bracket one objection so that the plan is defeated on separate grounds
    • D.Summarize the quick revenue that makes the plan so appealing to voters
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Bracket one objection so that the plan is defeated on separate grounds

    The sentence puts aside the worry that lotteries fall hardest on the poor, and the author then defeats the plan on revenue, showing it covers barely a tenth of the shortfall. The author's case does not rely on that objection, since it is set aside. Deferring the question of fairness does not concede that the lottery is fair, and the plan's appeal is summarized in the sentence before, not in this one.

  184. Passage: A common worry holds that machine translation will erode the demand for human translators. The data tell a stranger story. As cheap automated translation made it feasible for companies to enter dozens of new markets at once, the volume of material needing careful human revision grew faster than the machines could absorb. Cheaper translation did not shrink the field; it expanded the territory the field had to cover. Question: Which one of the following most accurately states the main point of the passage?

    • A.Companies should use human translators instead of cheap tools for contracts
    • B.Machine translation errors can be spotted only by trained human translators
    • C.Human translators are no longer in demand for ordinary commercial documents
    • D.Cheap machine translation has enlarged rather than shrunk demand for humans
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Cheap machine translation has enlarged rather than shrunk demand for humans

    The passage answers the worry that machines will erode demand by showing that cheap translation let firms enter new markets, so the material needing human revision grew. The author recommends nothing to companies. The passage does not claim that only humans can spot machine errors, and it never says humans are no longer in demand for ordinary documents, since it reports demand for them growing.

  185. Passage: The historian argues that the city's sudden prosperity in the 1300s stemmed not from its famous textile trade, which records show was already declining, but from its position as a clearinghouse where merchants settled debts across regions. Question: Which one of the following, if true, would most strengthen the historian's argument?

    • A.The city's surviving ledgers list far more debt settlements than cloth sales
    • B.The city's textile workshops employed more laborers in the 1300s than before
    • C.Nearby cities with thriving textile trades also grew wealthy during that era
    • D.The city's debts to foreign lenders grew steadily throughout the early 1300s
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The city's surviving ledgers list far more debt settlements than cloth sales

    The historian credits the city's wealth to its role as a clearinghouse where merchants settled debts, not to textiles, so ledgers dominated by debt settlements support that account. Record textile employment in the 1300s would contradict the claim that the trade was declining. Textile cities nearby growing rich suggests textiles could explain prosperity, which weakens the argument, and the city's own borrowing says nothing about its role in settling merchants' debts.

  186. Passage: Some educators insist that students learn best when allowed to discover principles for themselves, with minimal guidance. But novices, lacking the background to recognize which observations matter, often spend their effort on dead ends and draw confident but mistaken conclusions. Guidance is not the enemy of discovery; without it, beginners frequently discover the wrong things. Question: The author would most likely agree with which one of the following statements?

    • A.Beginners should never be allowed to discover principles without a teacher
    • B.Beginners who receive guidance are less likely to draw unsound conclusions
    • C.Beginners learn best when left to discover principles with little guidance
    • D.Beginners and experts gain equally from lessons that offer little guidance
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Beginners who receive guidance are less likely to draw unsound conclusions

    The author says novices without guidance often chase dead ends and draw confident but mistaken conclusions, so guidance makes such errors less likely. The author calls guidance a partner of discovery, not a ban on discovering alone, and says beginners frequently, not always, go wrong. Minimal guidance suits novices poorly in the author's view, and experts are never compared with novices.

  187. Passage: The essay first presents the standard claim that bird migration is triggered chiefly by falling temperatures. It then notes that some species depart while the weather is still warm. Finally, it proposes that changes in daylight length, not temperature, set the primary schedule, with temperature acting only as a fine adjustment. Question: Which one of the following most accurately describes the organization of the passage?

    • A.A hypothesis is stated, examples support it, and it is applied to more species
    • B.A standard view is stated, an anomaly is noted, and another cause is suggested
    • C.Two theories are compared, one is tested, and the other is then fully rejected
    • D.A term is defined, the term is illustrated, and some exceptions are then given
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: A standard view is stated, an anomaly is noted, and another cause is suggested

    The passage gives the standard view that falling temperatures trigger migration, notes species that leave while it is still warm, and proposes daylight length as the main trigger. The early departures count against the standard view rather than supporting it, and nothing is applied to more species. The passage does not open by comparing two theories or test either one, and it defines no term.

  188. Passage: When a museum returns an artifact to its country of origin, commentators often frame the act as either a triumph of justice or a loss to scholarship. This framing forces a false choice. Digital scanning now allows a returned object to remain fully available for study, its surface recorded at resolutions finer than the unaided eye can perceive, even as the physical piece goes home. Question: The primary purpose of the passage is to

    • A.Show how digital scanning removes an apparent conflict between return and study
    • B.Argue that museums should retain artifacts rather than return them to claimants
    • C.Describe the technical details and costs of the scanning equipment museums need
    • D.Criticize the observers who value scholarship much more than they value justice
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Show how digital scanning removes an apparent conflict between return and study

    The author calls the justice-versus-scholarship framing a false choice and explains that scanning keeps a returned object available for study, so technology removes the apparent conflict. The author does not oppose repatriation; the point is that return need not cost scholarship. Scanning resolution is mentioned only to support that point, with no account of equipment or cost, and commentators are faulted for posing a false choice, not for favoring scholarship over justice.

  189. Passage: The botanist observed that a certain orchid is pollinated by only one species of moth, whose tongue exactly matches the depth of the flower's nectar tube. Where the moth is absent, the orchid sets no seed at all, even when transplanted to soils that suit it perfectly. Question: Which one of the following can most reasonably be inferred from the passage?

    • A.The orchid can propagate by tubers or cuttings in areas that lack its moth
    • B.The orchid's range is limited mainly by the quality of soil in each region
    • C.The moth feeds on the nectar of this orchid and no other flower whatsoever
    • D.The orchid yields no seed in any place where its moth pollinator is absent
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The orchid yields no seed in any place where its moth pollinator is absent

    The passage says that where the moth is absent the orchid sets no seed at all, even in soil that suits it perfectly, so seed production depends on the moth being present. Nothing is said about the orchid spreading by tubers or cuttings. Soil is shown not to be the limiting factor, and the passage says the orchid has only one pollinator, not that the moth visits only one flower.

  190. Passage: The latest fashion among management consultants is to declare the annual budget obsolete, to be replaced by 'rolling forecasts' updated each month. There is something to the complaint that fixed budgets ossify. But a forecast revised every thirty days can become an excuse never to commit to anything, a way of mistaking motion for direction. Question: The author's attitude toward rolling forecasts is best described as

    • A.Eager approval, hailing the forecasts while ignoring all of the reservations
    • B.Guarded skepticism, conceding a valid complaint while warning of its dangers
    • C.Firm opposition, defending fixed budgets while denying that they ever ossify
    • D.Detached neutrality, reporting on budgets while adopting no position on them
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Guarded skepticism, conceding a valid complaint while warning of its dangers

    The author grants that there is something to the complaint that fixed budgets ossify, then warns that monthly forecasts can become an excuse never to commit. That warning is itself a reservation, which rules out eager approval. The author accepts the ossification complaint instead of denying it, and the closing judgment about mistaking motion for direction is an evaluation, not neutral reporting.

  191. Passage: For decades, urban planners measured a neighborhood's vitality by counting cars passing through it. A growing body of research reverses the metric: the streets people most value, and where small businesses thrive, are often those where cars move slowly or scarcely at all, leaving room for pedestrians to linger. Traffic, long treated as a sign of a district's health, may be closer to a symptom of its hollowing out. Question: Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?

    • A.Car counts, long used by planners, remain the best measure of vitality
    • B.Small shops, long reliant on drivers, may not survive on quiet streets
    • C.Heavy traffic, long regarded as a sign of health, may indicate decline
    • D.Car use, long tolerated in cities, should be banned from all districts
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Heavy traffic, long regarded as a sign of health, may indicate decline

    The passage reports research showing that valued, thriving streets often have slow or little traffic, and concludes that traffic may be a symptom of a district hollowing out rather than a sign of health. That reverses the car-counting metric instead of endorsing it. The research says small businesses thrive where cars move slowly, the opposite of the claim about shops, and the author proposes no ban.

  192. Passage: Defenders of the new dialect-recognition software boast that it identifies a speaker's home region with ninety percent accuracy. They cite this figure as proof of the technology's sophistication. The same figure, however, means that one caller in ten is misclassified, and the system routes callers to regional offices on the basis of that classification. Question: The author mentions that 'one caller in ten is misclassified' primarily to

    • A.Show that a figure the defenders praise also implies a practical cost
    • B.Praise the software for its accuracy figure of a solid ninety percent
    • C.Explain the methods by which the software was first built and trained
    • D.Argue that callers should be free to choose their own regional office
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Show that a figure the defenders praise also implies a practical cost

    The author takes the defenders' ninety percent figure and points out that it means one caller in ten is misrouted, so the impressive statistic carries a practical cost. The point is to undercut the boast, not to praise the accuracy. The passage never explains how the software was built, and it proposes no change in who picks the regional office.

  193. Passage A: Public subsidies for rural broadband are essential; without them, private firms will never extend service to areas too sparse to be profitable, leaving residents permanently cut off from modern commerce and schooling. Passage B: Subsidies for rural broadband too often lock in obsolete technology. By the time the wires are laid, wireless alternatives have leapt ahead, and the subsidized network becomes a costly monument to yesterday's solution. Question: The relationship between Passage A and Passage B is best described as

    • A.Passage B supplies evidence that confirms the chief claim in Passage A
    • B.Passage A defends a policy that Passage B opposes on different grounds
    • C.Both passages say that rural broadband should be left to private firms
    • D.Passage A and Passage B consider questions that have nothing in common
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Passage A defends a policy that Passage B opposes on different grounds

    Passage A says rural broadband subsidies are essential, while Passage B criticizes them because they lock in obsolete technology, an objection Passage A never addresses. Passage B argues against Passage A rather than confirming it. Passage A says private firms will never serve sparse areas on their own, so it rejects leaving broadband to them, and both passages discuss the same subsidies.

  194. Passage A: Critics of zoos argue that confinement, however comfortable, deprives animals of the range of behaviors they would express in the wild. Passage B: Modern conservation zoos have become the last refuge for species whose wild habitat no longer exists; for these animals, 'the wild' is not an alternative but a memory. Question: It can most reasonably be inferred that the author of Passage B would respond to Passage A by pointing out that

    • A.zoo animals in fact show most of the behaviors of their wild relatives
    • B.life in a modern zoo is more comfortable for animals than the wild is
    • C.critics overstate what animals lose by giving up their wild behaviors
    • D.for some animals no wild habitat is left to compare a zoo life against
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: for some animals no wild habitat is left to compare a zoo life against

    Passage B says that for some species the wild habitat no longer exists, so the wild is a memory rather than a real alternative to the zoo, and that undercuts the comparison Passage A depends on. Passage B never says zoo animals keep most of their wild behaviors, and it makes no claim that zoo life is more comfortable than the wild. It also does not dispute how much animals lose in confinement; it questions whether a wild option remains at all.

  195. Passage: We speak of 'discovering' a scientific law as though it lay waiting like a buried coin. But a law is a statement, and statements must be formulated in some vocabulary that did not exist before someone built it. The orbit was there; the concept that lets us describe it as an ellipse was made, not found. To call science pure discovery is to forget the labor of inventing the language in which discoveries can be stated. Question: The primary purpose of the passage is to

    • A.dispute the familiar picture of discovery as finding laws that no one made
    • B.argue that scientific laws are pure inventions describing nothing in the world
    • C.claim that inventing vocabulary matters more to science than observing nature
    • D.show that the orbit was elliptical before science had any concept for it
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: dispute the familiar picture of discovery as finding laws that no one made

    The author grants that the orbit was there but insists the concept used to describe it was made, so the passage disputes the picture of science as pure discovery. It does not call laws pure inventions describing nothing; the orbit is treated as real throughout. Nor does it rank vocabulary above observation, and the point that the orbit was elliptical before the concept existed is a step in the argument, not its purpose.

  196. Passage: Folklorists once raced to record dying oral traditions before the last elder speakers passed away, treating each tradition as a fixed text to be preserved intact. Newer fieldwork suggests that the traditions were never fixed at all: storytellers reshaped tales for each audience, and what looked like decay was often just the ordinary improvisation that had kept the form alive for centuries. Question: Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?

    • A.Oral traditions are disappearing faster than folklorists are able to record them.
    • B.Early folklorists arrived too late to capture the tales in their original forms.
    • C.Storytellers now reshape traditional tales more freely than storytellers once did.
    • D.Apparent decay in oral traditions was often the improvisation sustaining them.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Apparent decay in oral traditions was often the improvisation sustaining them.

    The newer fieldwork shows the traditions were never fixed, so what looked like decay was usually the same improvisation that had kept the tales alive for centuries. That rejects the earlier race against disappearing traditions rather than repeating it. Talk of original forms that folklorists arrived too late to capture assumes the fixed text the passage denies, and the passage says reshaping has always happened, not that it is freer today.

  197. Passage: The economist contends that the region's factories closed not because wages there were high, which they were not, but because the railway that carried their goods to port was allowed to fall into disrepair, raising shipping costs above what competitors paid. Question: Which one of the following, if true, would most strengthen the economist's explanation?

    • A.Factories in nearby regions with higher wages but sound railways stayed open.
    • B.Shipping costs rose by a similar amount in every region during the same years.
    • C.The port that received the region's goods was modernized during those years.
    • D.Factories in the region that sent their goods by road closed at the same rate.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Factories in nearby regions with higher wages but sound railways stayed open.

    If higher-wage regions with sound railways kept their factories, wages cannot be what closed them, and the difference in transport fits the economist's account. Shipping costs rising equally everywhere would erase the cost gap with competitors that the explanation needs. A modernized port is neutral, and road-shipping factories closing at the same rate would point to some cause other than the railway.

  198. Passage: Skeptics dismiss the revival of handwriting instruction as nostalgia, a sentimental wish to undo the keyboard. Yet several careful studies find that students who take notes by hand recall concepts better than those who type, perhaps because the slower pace forces them to summarize rather than transcribe. The case for handwriting need not rest on nostalgia at all. Question: The author's attitude toward handwriting instruction is best described as

    • A.Favorable, resting its case for the practice on evidence of better recall
    • B.Nostalgic, valuing the practice mainly as a link to an earlier era
    • C.Skeptical, doubting that the studies show any real benefit for students
    • D.Neutral, reporting the critics' view and the studies without judging them
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Favorable, resting its case for the practice on evidence of better recall

    The author cites studies showing better recall from handwritten notes and concludes that the case for handwriting need not rest on nostalgia, which is support grounded in evidence. The author explicitly sets nostalgia aside as the reason. The studies are presented as careful and persuasive, not doubted, and the closing sentence takes a clear side instead of staying neutral.

  199. Passage: A tax credit was offered to homeowners who installed solar panels, but only those who filed an itemized return could claim it. Surveys later found that lower-income households, who overwhelmingly file simplified returns, installed panels at far lower rates than middle-income households, even when the upfront equipment cost was fully covered by a separate grant. Question: Which one of the following can most reasonably be inferred from the passage?

    • A.Lower-income households may have had less interest in solar power than others.
    • B.The itemized-return rule may have kept many poorer households from the credit.
    • C.The separate grant did not fully pay for the equipment that households needed.
    • D.Middle-income households were more likely than poorer ones to own their homes.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: The itemized-return rule may have kept many poorer households from the credit.

    Lower-income households rarely itemize, so most could not claim the credit, and they installed fewer panels even when the grant covered equipment, which points to the credit's design. Nothing in the passage measures interest in solar power, so that explanation has no support. The passage states the grant fully covered the equipment cost, and it says nothing about home ownership rates.

  200. Passage: The proposal would require every new building to include a rooftop garden. Advocates point to the cooling effect such gardens have on dense city centers. Whatever the merits of that effect, the proposal applies equally to a remote warehouse on the city's edge, where no such heat problem exists and where the added structural cost buys nothing. Question: The author refers to 'a remote warehouse on the city's edge' primarily in order to

    • A.show that a uniform rule can impose costs where its promised benefit is absent
    • B.deny that rooftop gardens do much at all to cool the densest parts of a city
    • C.argue that warehouses on the city's edge should be exempt from building rules
    • D.suggest that rooftop gardens cost too much to be justified on any new building
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: show that a uniform rule can impose costs where its promised benefit is absent

    The author sets the cooling benefit aside and points to a building where no heat problem exists, so the requirement adds cost and delivers nothing there. The phrase about the merits of that effect leaves the cooling claim standing rather than denying it. The example targets this one requirement, not building rules in general, and it says gardens buy nothing on that warehouse, not that they are too costly everywhere.

  201. Passage: It is often said that anonymous online reviews democratize consumer information, freeing it from the grip of paid critics. But anonymity also strips away the one thing that made a critic accountable: a name that could be discredited by a bad call. A signed review stakes a reputation; an anonymous one risks nothing. The democratization comes at the price of accountability. Question: Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?

    • A.Anonymous online reviews are generally less accurate than the signed reviews.
    • B.Paid critics earn more trust than anonymous reviewers simply by being paid.
    • C.Anonymous reviews have made information on products far more widely available.
    • D.Opening reviews to anonymous writers gives up the accountability names gave.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Opening reviews to anonymous writers gives up the accountability names gave.

    The passage grants that anonymous reviews democratize information and then argues that the price is the accountability a signed name provided, so the main point is the trade-off. It never compares accuracy, only accountability. It also does not say critics earn trust by being paid; their name at stake is what made them answerable. Wider access is the concession the author starts from, not the conclusion.

  202. Passage: The author begins by recounting the widely repeated claim that a famous shipwreck sank because of a single faulty rivet. She then describes laboratory tests on recovered rivets that found them within acceptable tolerances. She closes by arguing that the disaster is better explained by a chain of small decisions, no one of which was fatal alone. Question: Which one of the following most accurately describes the organization of the passage?

    • A.A popular explanation is recounted, then undercut by tests, and then replaced.
    • B.Two rival theories are compared, then put to tests, then judged equally plausible.
    • C.A single cause is defended, then illustrated with tests, then accepted outright.
    • D.An experiment is described, then faulted for its method, and then dismissed.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: A popular explanation is recounted, then undercut by tests, and then replaced.

    The author recounts the popular single-rivet story, reports tests finding the rivets within tolerance, and then argues for a chain of small decisions. The passage weighs one popular account, not two equally plausible rivals, and it rejects that account rather than accepting it outright. The tests are relied on, not faulted, and the passage ends on a definite explanation instead of dismissing the findings.

  203. Passage: Advocates of 'teaching to mastery' insist that no student should advance until each skill is fully secured. The ideal is admirable, but classrooms run on shared time. A class held to the pace of its slowest mastery would leave its quickest learners idle for weeks, and idleness is its own kind of loss. Mastery for one can mean stagnation for another. Question: The author would most likely agree with which one of the following?

    • A.Students who have not mastered a skill should still move ahead with their class.
    • B.The pace of a class is best set by whichever students learn most quickly.
    • C.Pausing for slower learners does more harm to them than to the quickest ones.
    • D.Waiting until every student has mastered a skill can cost the fastest learners.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Waiting until every student has mastered a skill can cost the fastest learners.

    The author calls the mastery ideal admirable but notes that pacing a class to its slowest member leaves quick learners idle, and that this idleness is a loss. The author never says students should move ahead without mastery, and never proposes that the fastest learners set the pace. The harm of waiting falls on the quickest learners, not on the slower ones the class is pausing for.

  204. Passage: The archaeologist noted that the buried granary held grain from three distinct harvests, stored in separate sealed chambers. Such careful separation, she argued, would make no sense in a household storing food for itself, since a family draws on whatever is at hand; it points instead to a system of accounting, where each year's contribution had to be tracked. Question: Which one of the following can most reasonably be inferred from the archaeologist's reasoning?

    • A.The granary was most likely owned by a single family that kept its stores in order.
    • B.Grain kept in sealed chambers was expected to last longer than grain lying loose.
    • C.Keeping each harvest apart suggests that someone was tracking yearly contributions.
    • D.The three harvests were most likely gathered from the fields of three villages.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Keeping each harvest apart suggests that someone was tracking yearly contributions.

    The archaeologist argues that a family draws on whatever grain is at hand, so separating harvests by year makes sense only if each year's contribution had to be tracked. That reasoning rules out a single tidy household rather than supporting it. The argument says nothing about how long sealed grain lasts, and it ties the chambers to separate years, not to separate villages.

  205. Passage: Reviewers praised the novel for 'breaking every rule of the form,' as if rule-breaking were itself an achievement. But a rule broken at random produces only noise. What makes the novel worth reading is not that it abandons convention but that it abandons specific conventions for specific effects, withholding a narrator's name, for instance, to make the reader share the character's disorientation. Question: The primary purpose of the passage is to

    • A.dispute the reviewers by arguing that the novel breaks no real rules of its form
    • B.claim that breaking a form's conventions usually signals a real failure of craft
    • C.show that the novel's merit lies in breaking particular rules for set effects
    • D.endorse the reviewers' view that breaking the form's rules is itself an achievement
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: show that the novel's merit lies in breaking particular rules for set effects

    The author keeps the praise but relocates it: random rule-breaking is only noise, and the novel succeeds because it drops specific conventions for specific effects. The author agrees the novel breaks rules, citing the unnamed narrator, so it does not deny that. Broken conventions are not treated as a failure of craft, and the reviewers' idea that rule-breaking is itself an achievement is exactly what the passage rejects.

  206. Passage: It is a familiar lament that smartphones have shortened our attention spans. But the evidence usually offered, that people switch tasks more often than they once did, measures behavior in an environment engineered to interrupt. Remove the notifications and the same people sustain focus as long as ever. What has changed may be the environment, not the mind. Question: Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?

    • A.Smartphones may have permanently weakened people's ability to hold their focus.
    • B.Task-switching data may reflect a distracting setting more than a changed mind.
    • C.Removing notifications is the most effective way to lengthen people's focus.
    • D.People switch tasks more often today than they did in earlier decades.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Task-switching data may reflect a distracting setting more than a changed mind.

    The passage reinterprets the task-switching evidence: it was gathered in an environment built to interrupt, and without notifications people focus as long as ever, so the change may lie in the setting, not the mind. That rejects the idea of a permanent loss of focus. The notification point is evidence for the claim, not a ranking of remedies, and more frequent task-switching is the conceded data, not the conclusion.

  207. Passage A: A guaranteed minimum income would free people to refuse degrading work, forcing employers to improve conditions to attract labor. Passage B: A guaranteed minimum income would simply let employers cut wages, knowing the state would make up the difference, so the burden of low pay would shift from firms to taxpayers. Question: Which one of the following, if true, would most strengthen the position taken in Passage B over that in Passage A?

    • A.In trials of a guaranteed income, many recipients left their unpleasant jobs.
    • B.In places with state wage top-ups, employers cut base pay by nearly as much.
    • C.In tight labor markets, employers have long raised wages to draw in workers.
    • D.In trials of a guaranteed income, recipients said they were happier at work.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: In places with state wage top-ups, employers cut base pay by nearly as much.

    Passage B predicts that employers would cut wages and let public money cover the gap, and employers lowering base pay by about the amount of a state top-up shows that behavior directly. Recipients leaving unpleasant jobs is the leverage Passage A predicts. Employers raising wages to attract workers also fits Passage A, and higher job satisfaction does nothing to show a shift of costs to taxpayers.

  208. Passage: The columnist warns that automated grading of essays will reward formulaic writing. Suppose she is right that current systems favor the formulaic. It hardly follows that grading must do so: a system can be retrained on essays that human readers found surprising and effective, teaching it to reward exactly what the columnist fears it will punish. Question: The phrase 'Suppose she is right' functions to

    • A.endorse the columnist's warning that automated graders will reward formula
    • B.cast doubt on whether current systems truly favor formulaic prose at all
    • C.concede a premise that the author then shows cannot support the conclusion
    • D.introduce an example refuting the columnist's claim about current systems
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: concede a premise that the author then shows cannot support the conclusion

    The author accepts, for argument's sake, that current systems favor formulaic writing and then argues that retraining means grading need not do so, so the concession sets up a rebuttal. The author rejects the columnist's warning rather than endorsing it. The phrase grants the premise instead of casting doubt on it, and a retrained system is a possible future, not an example showing that current systems behave otherwise.

  209. Passage: A study of bilingual readers found that they were slightly slower than monolinguals at naming the color of a printed word when the word named a different color. Yet on tasks requiring them to ignore one rule and switch to another mid-stream, the bilingual readers were consistently faster. Question: Which one of the following can most reasonably be inferred from the passage?

    • A.Bilingual readers outperform monolinguals on cognitive tasks of every kind.
    • B.Bilingual readers may be slower than monolinguals at most reading tasks.
    • C.Being bilingual may slow some tasks slightly while speeding up others.
    • D.Monolingual readers are unable to switch from one rule to another one.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Being bilingual may slow some tasks slightly while speeding up others.

    Bilinguals were slightly slower at naming ink colors but faster at switching rules, so the effect of bilingualism depends on the task. Being slower on the color task rules out an advantage on every task. One slow result does not show slowness at most reading tasks, since rule-switching went the other way. Monolinguals were slower at switching, not unable to switch.

  210. Passage: Enthusiasts hail open-source mapping projects as the triumph of the amateur over the corporate atlas. Their enthusiasm is mostly earned: volunteers have charted villages no commercial firm bothered to survey. But the same openness lets a single careless edit erase a road for thousands of users until someone notices, and noticing can take days. Question: The author's attitude toward open-source mapping is best characterized as

    • A.Admiring and sure that the volunteer maps are free of any serious flaw
    • B.Appreciative and mindful of the weakness the openness itself creates
    • C.Critical and convinced that commercial atlases are more reliable
    • D.Indifferent and unconcerned about whether volunteer projects succeed
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Appreciative and mindful of the weakness the openness itself creates

    The author says the enthusiasm is mostly earned, then warns that the same openness lets one careless edit erase a road for days. That warning rules out being sure the maps are free of serious flaws. The author never says the commercial atlas is more reliable, and the clear praise and the specific warning show the author cares how these projects turn out.

  211. Passage: Critics of remote work predicted that workers freed from the office would scatter to cheap, distant towns, hollowing out cities. The migration has been smaller and stranger than predicted: many remote workers moved not away from expensive cities but to other expensive cities, choosing places for their amenities now that a job no longer pinned them to one. Question: Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?

    • A.Remote workers have mostly left costly cities for cheap towns far away.
    • B.Remote work has left most workers in the same cities and towns as before.
    • C.Remote workers have chosen towns and cities mostly by what housing costs.
    • D.Remote workers often moved to other pricey cities for their amenities.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Remote workers often moved to other pricey cities for their amenities.

    The passage says the predicted move to cheap towns was smaller than expected and that many remote workers went to other expensive cities chosen for their amenities. That is the reverse of a general flight to cheap distant towns. The passage is about where the movers went, so saying workers stayed where they were misses its point, and amenities, not housing cost, drove the choices it describes.

  212. Passage: The first part of the report establishes that a coastal town's flood defenses were built to withstand the highest tide on record. The second part observes that record tides are, by definition, periodically exceeded. The report concludes that defenses keyed to past records are guaranteed, in time, to be overtopped. Question: The second part of the report functions primarily to

    • A.supply the general rule turning the design standard into a warning
    • B.offer evidence that the defenses have already been overtopped once
    • C.raise an objection to the report's conclusion that is later rebutted
    • D.restate the first part's finding about the town's own flood defenses
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: supply the general rule turning the design standard into a warning

    The first part says the defenses match the record tide, and the second adds the general rule that records are eventually exceeded, which turns that design standard into the warning that the defenses will be overtopped. The second part reports no past overtopping. It supports the conclusion rather than raising an objection to it, and it adds a new fact about records instead of restating the first part's finding.

  213. Passage: The literary scholar argues that a parody can only succeed if its audience already knows the work being parodied; the humor lives in the gap between the original and its distortion. A reader ignorant of the source sees only the distortion and mistakes it for the thing itself. Question: Based on the scholar's view, which one of the following would most likely happen when a parody outlives the work it mocks?

    • A.Later readers who do not know the original might read the parody as sincere.
    • B.Later readers who know the original only by name might find the parody funnier.
    • C.Later readers who meet the parody would be led to seek out the original work.
    • D.Later readers who meet the parody would rank it above the original it mocked.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Later readers who do not know the original might read the parody as sincere.

    The scholar says the humor lives in the gap between original and distortion, and a reader who does not know the source mistakes the distortion for the thing itself. So once the original is forgotten, the parody is likely to be read straight. Knowing a work only by name removes the gap that makes the parody funny. Nothing in the view says a parody sends readers back to its source or makes them rank it higher.

  214. Passage: We are urged to 'follow our passion' in choosing a career, as though passion were a fixed star to steer by. But interest more often follows competence than precedes it: people grow passionate about activities they have become good at, not the reverse. The advice may have the arrow of causation backward, telling us to wait for a feeling that arrives only after the work. Question: The primary purpose of the passage is to

    • A.urge readers to find their true passion before they choose any career
    • B.question a popular maxim by arguing that interest tends to follow skill
    • C.argue that personal interest should have no part in choosing a career
    • D.describe the stages by which people usually learn what they do well
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: question a popular maxim by arguing that interest tends to follow skill

    The author says interest more often follows competence than precedes it, so the advice to follow your passion may have the causation backward. That questions the maxim rather than urging readers to find a passion first. The author does not say interest should play no part, only that it tends to come later, and gives no account of the stages by which people discover their skills.

  215. Passage: It has become common to praise 'failing fast' as a path to innovation, as though every failure were a tuition payment toward success. Yet a failure teaches only if someone examines why it happened, and the same speed that produces many failures leaves little time to study any of them. Failing fast without reflecting fast is just failing. Question: Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?

    • A.Failure rarely adds anything of real value to the process of innovation.
    • B.Failing quickly helps only when someone examines why each attempt failed.
    • C.Organizations should always avoid risks that could end in costly failure.
    • D.Innovation comes fastest to teams that manage to produce the most failures.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Failing quickly helps only when someone examines why each attempt failed.

    The passage says a failure teaches only when someone examines why it happened, and that the speed of failing fast leaves little time to do so. It grants that failure can teach, so it does not say failure rarely adds value. It gives no advice to avoid risk, and it rejects the idea that piling up failures quickly is a path to innovation.

  216. Passage: The new etiquette guide instructs us to answer every message within the hour, lest we seem inconsiderate. One pictures its author, phone in hand, mistaking a buzzing pocket for a moral summons. Consideration once meant attending fully to the person before you; now, apparently, it means attending instantly to the person who is not. Question: The author's tone in this passage is best described as

    • A.Earnest and approving of the standard that the guide sets out
    • B.Wry and disapproving of the standard that the guide sets out
    • C.Anxious and fearful about the standard that the guide sets out
    • D.Detached and neutral about the standard that the guide sets out
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: Wry and disapproving of the standard that the guide sets out

    The picture of the guide's author mistaking a buzzing pocket for a moral summons, and the twist that consideration now means attending to the absent person, are mocking, so the tone is wry and critical. The author plainly does not endorse the guide. The mockery is amused rather than fearful, and an author who takes sides this sharply is not neutral.

  217. Passage: In a long-term study of two reading programs, children in Program X scored higher on comprehension tests at the end of first grade, but by fourth grade children from Program Y had pulled even and then ahead. Program X drilled answers to test questions; Program Y spent more time on unhurried reading of whole books. Question: Which one of the following can most reasonably be inferred from the passage?

    • A.Drilling answers made Program X children worse readers in every single way.
    • B.Comprehension tests given in first grade tell us nothing real about reading.
    • C.Reading whole books raises test scores more quickly than drilling answers does.
    • D.A program starting behind can still produce higher scores in later grades.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: A program starting behind can still produce higher scores in later grades.

    Program Y scored lower at the end of first grade but had pulled even and ahead by fourth grade, so trailing early did not stop it from leading later. Program X children scored higher at first, which rules out their being worse readers in every way. The passage relies on the tests to compare the programs, and Program Y was the slower of the two to raise scores, not the faster.

  218. Passage: Reformers want to abolish letter grades, arguing that they reduce a year of learning to a single symbol. The complaint is fair. But the proposed replacement, paragraph-long narrative evaluations for every student, would consume hours teachers do not have, and harried teachers tend to fall back on a small stock of stock phrases. The cure risks reproducing, in prose, the very flatness it was meant to escape. Question: The final sentence ('The cure risks...') functions primarily to

    • A.endorse narrative evaluations as a clear improvement over letter grades
    • B.take back the author's concession that letter grades flatten learning
    • C.caution that the proposed remedy may reproduce the flaw it targets
    • D.suggest that teachers may lack the skill for good narrative reports
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: caution that the proposed remedy may reproduce the flaw it targets

    Having granted the complaint about letter grades, the author argues that rushed teachers would fall back on stock phrases, so the narrative cure could bring back the same flatness. The sentence questions the proposal rather than endorsing it. It keeps the earlier concession, since flatness is still the flaw at issue, and it blames a lack of time, not a lack of skill.

  219. Passage: For decades, museum curators assumed that displaying an artifact's country of origin was a neutral, factual label. Critics now argue otherwise. A single object may have passed through a dozen hands and borders before reaching a vault, and the label that fixes it to one nation often erases that journey, lending the museum's possession an air of natural belonging it has not earned. Question: The main point of the passage is that

    • A.museums should remove origin labels and return artifacts to their nations
    • B.curators know their labels are false and use them to mislead the public
    • C.most artifacts have changed hands many times and crossed several borders
    • D.origin labels are less neutral than assumed and can hide an object's past
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: origin labels are less neutral than assumed and can hide an object's past

    The passage reports that critics reject the old belief that origin labels are neutral, since a label tying an object to one nation can erase its journey and imply a belonging the museum has not earned. It makes no demand to remove labels or return artifacts. It describes an assumption, not deliberate deception, and the dozen hands are an illustration rather than a claim about most artifacts.

  220. Passage: Critics of remote scientific instruments contend that data gathered without a researcher present is less trustworthy than data from hands-on fieldwork. The author responds: A seismometer left alone on the ocean floor records the same tremor whether or not a scientist is watching it. What fieldwork adds is interpretation, not accuracy. To confuse the two is to imagine that nature performs differently when observed. Question: The author responds to the critics primarily by

    • A.conceding that remote data is less accurate while calling the loss minor
    • B.citing evidence that remote instruments rarely send faulty ocean data
    • C.separating the accuracy of the data from the reading that fieldwork adds
    • D.arguing that fieldwork no longer serves any purpose in modern science
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: separating the accuracy of the data from the reading that fieldwork adds

    The author says a seismometer records the same tremor whether or not anyone watches, and that fieldwork adds interpretation, not accuracy, which pulls apart two things the critics ran together. The author denies any loss of accuracy rather than calling one minor. No evidence about faulty instrument data is cited, and fieldwork keeps a real role in interpretation.

  221. Passage: Passage A: City planners praise narrow, tree-lined streets for slowing traffic and inviting pedestrians, making neighborhoods safer and more sociable. Passage B: Emergency responders note that the same narrow streets delay fire engines and ambulances, and that trees can obscure sightlines at intersections. A design that comforts a stroller may cost a patient critical minutes. Question: Passage B relates to Passage A primarily by

    • A.naming a separate benefit of wider streets that Passage A fails to consider
    • B.accepting Passage A's view while proposing a small change to its street design
    • C.showing that the very feature Passage A praises also creates a serious hazard
    • D.disputing Passage A's claim that narrow streets slow down passing traffic
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: showing that the very feature Passage A praises also creates a serious hazard

    Passage A praises narrow streets for slowing traffic, and Passage B points out that the same narrowness delays fire engines and ambulances, so the praised feature carries a cost. Passage B discusses the same narrow streets, not a separate benefit of wider ones. Critical minutes for a patient is a serious conflict, not a small adjustment, and Passage B accepts that the streets slow traffic.

  222. Passage: The poet's early reviewers dismissed her sparse, unpunctuated lines as the work of someone who had not mastered her craft. But a writer who could produce, elsewhere, sonnets of flawless meter was plainly capable of conventional polish. The bareness of the late poems was a choice, not a failure, and reading it as incompetence reverses the truth. Question: Which one of the following is an assumption on which the author's argument depends?

    • A.A poet who could write flawless sonnets would not fail by accident elsewhere.
    • B.The poet's late poems are better than the sonnets she wrote in strict meter.
    • C.The early reviewers had not read any of the sonnets that the poet had written.
    • D.Sparse and unpunctuated verse is most often the mark of a highly skilled poet.
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: A poet who could write flawless sonnets would not fail by accident elsewhere.

    The author moves from the flawless sonnets to the claim that the bare late poems were a choice, which works only if such a skilled poet would not produce real failures elsewhere. The argument does not need the late poems to be better than the sonnets. It does not depend on what the reviewers had read, and it concerns one poet's choices, not whether sparse verse in general shows skill.

  223. Passage: A common defense of zoos holds that they protect endangered species by breeding them in safety. The author writes: This is true as far as it goes, but a tiger born in a concrete enclosure, fed on schedule and never required to hunt, is in some sense a different animal from the one the program claims to save. We may be preserving a name while losing the thing the name once meant. Question: The phrase "preserving a name while losing the thing the name once meant" functions primarily to

    • A.propose that captive-bred animals be given names that set them apart
    • B.doubt that captive breeding preserves what makes the species itself
    • C.restate the claim that zoo defenders make about saving endangered species
    • D.concede that captive breeding has kept many endangered species in existence
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: doubt that captive breeding preserves what makes the species itself

    Just before the phrase, the author argues that a tiger raised in concrete and never hunting is in some sense a different animal, so the phrase voices doubt that breeding preserves what the species really is. The word name is figurative, not a call to rename animals. The defenders' claim and the concession come earlier in the passage; this phrase is the author's reply to them.

  224. Passage: Historians of medieval trade once relied almost entirely on the account books of large merchant houses, whose records survived because the firms were wealthy enough to preserve them. The author cautions that this survival is itself a distortion: the books that remain are the books of the winners. Building a picture of commerce from them alone is like reconstructing a city from its monuments while ignoring the houses that were torn down. Question: The analogy in the last sentence is used primarily to

    • A.fault medieval merchants for failing to preserve more of their records
    • B.suggest that monuments are more trustworthy sources than old account books
    • C.compare the rise of medieval trade with the growth of the medieval towns
    • D.show that studying only the surviving records distorts the whole picture
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: show that studying only the surviving records distorts the whole picture

    Monuments alone misrepresent a city because the torn-down houses are missing, just as the surviving books of wealthy firms misrepresent commerce because the failed traders' records are gone. The fault lies with historians who rely on those books alone, not with the merchants. In the analogy monuments stand for the biased sample, not a better source, and it compares ways of studying the past, not the growth of trade and towns.

  225. Passage: When evaluating a passage that presents an experiment, a careful reader should ask not only what the results were but whether the comparison group was treated identically except for the variable under study. A study showing that students who took a new course scored higher tells us little if those students were also more motivated to begin with. Without a fair comparison, an apparent effect may be an illusion produced by the difference in groups. Question: The passage is primarily concerned with

    • A.showing that the example's course had no real effect on scores
    • B.arguing that motivated groups of students outperform unmotivated groups
    • C.explaining why a fair study needs groups that differ in one respect only
    • D.recommending that studies stop relying on comparison groups at all
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: explaining why a fair study needs groups that differ in one respect only

    The passage advises readers to ask whether a comparison group was treated identically except for the factor under study, and uses the course example to show how a difference in motivation can fake an effect. The course example is hypothetical and is not shown to have had no effect. Motivation is one possible confound, not a claim that motivated groups always win, and the passage calls for fair comparison groups rather than dropping them.

  226. Passage: The administrator argues: Our library's circulation figures have fallen for three straight years, so the public clearly values the library less than it once did. The author replies that circulation counts only physical loans, and that the same library's downloads of e-books and database use have risen sharply over the period. The decline, the author concludes, measures a change in format, not in regard. Question: The author's reply weakens the administrator's argument by

    • A.denying that the library's physical loans have fallen over the period
    • B.arguing that circulation figures are unreliable for every library
    • C.pointing to rising kinds of use that the administrator's figures omit
    • D.showing that the public now values the library more than it ever did
    Show answerHide answer

    Correct answer: pointing to rising kinds of use that the administrator's figures omit

    The administrator reads falling circulation as falling regard, and the author replies that circulation counts only physical loans while e-book and database use have risen, so the figures miss a growing kind of use. The author accepts that physical loans fell. The objection concerns what this measure leaves out, not every library's figures, and the author concludes only that regard has not declined, not that it is higher than ever.

References

  1. 1.Law School Admission Council. “What to Expect Starting With the August 2024 LSAT.” lsac.org. ↑
  2. 2.Law School Admission Council. “LSAT and CAS Fees.” lsac.org. ↑
  3. 3.Law School Admission Council. “LSAT Scoring.” lsac.org. ↑
  4. 4.Law School Admission Council. “Limits on Repeating the Test.” lsac.org. ↑
  5. 5.Law School Admission Council. “LSAT Percentiles.” lsac.org. ↑
Career Employer

Career Employer is the ultimate resource to help you get started working the job of your dreams. We cover topics from general career information, career searching, exam preparation with free study materials, career interviewing, and becoming successful in your career of choice.

Follow Us:

All Posts

Career Employer’s Editorial Process

Here at Career Employer, we focus a lot on providing factually accurate information that is always up to date. We strive to provide correct information using strict editorial processes, article editing, and fact-checking for all of the information found on our website. We only utilize trustworthy and relevant resources. To find out more, make sure to read our full editorial process page here.