CASA Reading Domain 2: Critical and Evaluative Reading

A poem contrasts the tumultuous sea during a storm with the calm waters at dawn. What does this contrast most likely symbolize?

A journal article reviews the effects of global warming on polar regions, suggesting dire future consequences. What is a critical reason to question the validity of the predictions made in the article?

When reading a novel set in a dystopian future, which critical question is most relevant for understanding the author's message?

An article uses statistics from a variety of sources to argue that urban areas contribute disproportionately to climate change. Which factor would be most critical in evaluating the reliability of the article's argument?

An author argues that technology inherently leads to decreased privacy. Which of the following, if true, would most directly challenge this argument?

In a critical essay about media influence, the author asserts that television has a diminishing effect on children's creativity. What would be an essential element to evaluate in the author's argument?

In a book discussing the role of innovation in business success, the author frequently references companies from the technology sector. What critical aspect should be evaluated to assess the bias in the book's argument?

In discussing the consequences of economic policies, an article uses complex statistical methods to forecast long-term effects. What should be critically examined to evaluate these forecasts?

An author writes a critique of a government's handling of public health during a pandemic, suggesting that the response was inadequate. What is essential to critically evaluate to determine the fairness of the critique?

A review of a documentary about climate change scrutinizes the credentials of interviewed experts. What question is crucial for evaluating the integrity of the review?

In a historical analysis, the author claims that economic downturns are primary catalysts for political revolutions. Which evidence would be most critical to substantiate this claim?

A critical analysis of media coverage on environmental issues argues that there is an overemphasis on climate change to the detriment of other environmental concerns. What factor is essential to evaluate to assess the balance of the coverage?

A scholarly article presents an argument that public libraries are vital for maintaining community engagement. To critically evaluate this argument, which type of evidence would be most important to assess?

An essay discusses the decline in popularity of physical newspapers. To effectively critique the essay's argument, what should be primarily examined?

In a discussion about online learning, an author claims it enhances student autonomy. What would be a critical point to evaluate in this claim?

An article analyzes the role of media in shaping public perceptions of science. Which methodological aspect should be critically examined to evaluate the article's conclusions?

A paper argues that modern architectural practices contribute to social isolation. Which evidence would most effectively support this argument?

In a debate about climate change, a speaker uses anecdotal evidence of unusual weather patterns to support their arguments. Which approach is most critical for evaluating the strength of these arguments?

An analysis piece in a magazine critiques the lack of diversity in science fiction literature. What should be evaluated to determine the validity of this critique?

A journalist writes a feature article suggesting that public art installations significantly improve urban quality of life. What aspect should be critically examined to assess the claim's robustness?